Baby Squared

I love playgrounds. I hate playgrounds.

Nothing beats a playground for an outing with toddlers / preschoolers (which one applies to two-year-olds? I'm not quite sure these days...) They're free, they offer exercise and fresh air, they're a great way for kids to practice various gross motor skills and learn to play nicely with others. For parents, it's a nice change of scene from the house or backyard, requires relatively little mental effort, is a fun way to interact with your kid(s) and can even have fitness benefits. (I'm sure someone has done a piece for a parenting mag on this kind of thing -- Playground Pilates! Tone your Triceps with your Tots! Swings, Slides and Rock-hard Abs!)

 

Yes. Playgrounds are good. The one we went to this morning -- Beaver Brook park in the suburban oasis of Belmont -- was especially good, with its many different play area options and -- best of all -- a big water play area with all kinds of spray jets and big rocks for little 'uns to play on and amongst. We'd never been there before, and it was well worth the trip.

 

But here's why playgrounds also stress me out. The first is twin-specific. (And probably also applies if you've got two small children close in age.)  If the playground is anything other than a very small "tot lot," it's a constant challenge to keep an eye on both kids at once, as they will almost inevitably want to go in two different directions and do two different things. Today at Beaver Brook, true to form, all Elsa wanted to do was play in the water, while Clio only wanted to go on the swings. The place wasn't set up such that I could push Clio and keep Elsa in sight, and even if that was an option, it wouldn't have been ideal. Because Elsa might have tripped and done a full-frontal face plant, nosebleed and all, and it would have taken me that much longer to get to her, and everyone would be thinking "where on earth is that poor girl's mother? Somebody call social services!"  Or she might have blithely grabbed a bucket away from some other kid, and gotten scolded by some judgy, helicopter mom thinking, "where on earth is this girl's mother, and why hasn't she raised her daughter properly? Call social services!"

 

All of which leads to other, related reason that playgrounds stress me out -- the other parents. (If you hadn't guessed already.)

 

I fully realize that this is partly, or even mostly, my own problem. I know that I'm a good mother, that I do the best I can given the challenges of twin toddlers, and that I shouldn't give a crap what other parents think -- particularly judgemental parents. They're probably the same people who think that feeding your kid non-organic produce or letting them watch television is tantamount to abuse. Who needs them? Meanwhile, I suppose it's silly for me to assume that anyone's judging me in the first place. 

 

But the fear of judgement is just one aspect of the intra-parent playground dynamic that I never have felt totally comfortable with. And I think this may be in part because I'm not a stay-at-home mom who does the playground thing on a regular basis. I get the sense that there's some kind of unwritten code of interaction and etiquette that I'm not quite cued into. Like how friendly you are or aren't supposed to be with other parents. Whether or not you're supposed to let your kids use other kids' toys that are lying around. How much you're supposed to interact with other people's kids, and how "parent-y" it's acceptable to get with them.

 

Today, for example, I was standing next to a slide, and a little boy who'd just come down it needed a boost down. He was calling for his mom, who was a few feet away, chatting with another mom, and I found myself quickly deliberating: his mom will be over in two seconds, but should I just help him get down? Or would that be weird? Or is it even weirder to ignore him? (Plenty of parents have ignored my girls in similar situations.)

 

I guess I just find the whole thing odd. Parenting is such a private thing in our culture. You'd think that might change in a place like a playground; instead we're all there together "parallel parenting." Which, on the one hand I like -- I don't particularly want to feel obligated to look after anyone's kids but my own -- but on the other hand I find oddly unnatural and isolating. Especially, admittedly, as the harried woman who's running around trying to keep after two toddlers while other moms are happily hanging out with their one child.

 

And then there's weird, random, bad vibe stuff that crops up -- like today: at this playground we went to there's a big long bench in the shade, and a number of people had parked their strollers in front of it and/or put their diaper bags on the bench. I sat down with the girls on an empty segment of bench to give them their snack. We were sort of between two strollers, but there was nothing on the bench, and the owners of the strollers were nowhere near. Then this guy comes over and gives me a sort of dirty look and very purposefully takes his stroller away and parks it in front of another section of bench a few yards down. Then proceeds to go back and play with his kids some more. So, I'm thinking: what? If you park your stroller in front of a certain section of bench, does that mean that part of the bench is yours? And nobody else can sit there? Even if you're not currently there? And even though it's PUBLIC FREAKIN' PROPERTY??

 

On the other hand, I may have been completely misinterpreting his actions. What do I know? I'm just a working mother of twins. An interloper on the carefully constructed, highly coded society that is the sub/urban playground.

 

 But please tell my I'm being paranoid, in this and the other things I mentioned. It would be a great comfort.

 

* * *

Subscribe to this blog and get notified each time a new post is published.

 


+ DIGG + DEL.ICIO.US

Comments

 

jessica said:

You're probably not being paranoid at all - your only problem, as far as I can tell, is that you actually give a sh*t what these random people think of you. You need to (mentally) tell them to take a hike, because what do you care if some guy got his boxers in a knot over where you were sitting at the playground?

Maybe I just hang out at a very low-key playground, but I really just don't notice any of this weird parenting competitive stuff where I live. Maybe you should move to the not-too-tony sections of Denver.

July 17, 2009 11:43 PM
 

maggie may said:

It IS a weird thing how we are all squished up against one another and yet still so isolated. Good blogging-

Maggie May

July 18, 2009 12:42 AM
 

Alison said:

Yeah, you're probably not paranoid.  I'm a SAHM so we go to the park everyday.  But I live in France, so throw those cultural questions into the mix too, and things can get really interesting.  I let my guys stray pretty far as long as I can see them (as you know, corraling the two of them is a full time sport).  And I very often see other parents looking at the one, and then looking around, clearly wondering where the hell this poor toddler's mommy is.  Twice I have had someone make a comment to me about this (both times, men - how funny!?).  Oddly enough, I didn't let it bother me.  

July 18, 2009 5:01 AM
 

emma said:

I am a SAHM w/ one and have no idea how you do a park w/ two who are at the age where they still can lose balance, get in over their heads, etc stage.  Regarding the "rules".  I don't know them, but I do this: am friendly to parents who's kids are near mine, especially if they're not part of a group (need the adult conversation sometimes), don't care if kids use my kid's toys (we always have shovels and buckets) as long as they don't wander away with it, help other kids who's caregivers are busy or not apparent.  I rarely "reprimand" any other kid unless they do something physically to my kid (hit, deliberatly throw something to hit them) AND the parent is no where nearby to correct them.  Usually I just move away from the situation (like the kid who repeatedly pointed a wood chip at my 1 year old's head and said "I shoot you, I shoot you".  Parent nearby, ignoring kid.  We move).

July 18, 2009 8:04 AM
 

Amy said:

This is a great post.  I'm sahm (of just one toddler) and I don't know the rules either!  I really like Emma's comments and how she negotiates playground turf, and I'm going to adopt her theories.  

Also, "parallel parenting" is a perfect description for the feeling I get while visiting ANYWHERE with an accumulation of parents and children.  I've been trying to search for a term to describe that feeling, and that hits the mark perfectly.  Why do we feel so judged by the very people going through the same experiences?  I don't understand why we aren't more supportive of each other.  

July 18, 2009 3:14 PM
 

Camilla said:

The quickest way to get other parents to not treat you like a potential child molester, is to ask one of them to do a minor favor for you.  I discovered this over a "hey, could you spot him at the bottom of the slide, please" request that I made.

I think the discomfort is often "I'm going to stop your child before he hurts himself, but I expect that you'll flip out when I touch him."

July 18, 2009 4:14 PM
 

Cathy Hurst said:

Toddlerhood will not be the last time other parents annoy you!!! Wait until you encounter soccer moms et al.....

July 18, 2009 6:54 PM
 

hippygoth/jenn said:

Oh God, I am so THERE with you on the whole playground thing.  I find it hilarious (and unsettling) that when I was younger, I rather flagrantly didn't care what people think, and now that I'm a parent, I'm constantly wondering if people are judging my parenting.  On my (rare) weekdays off, when I take Charlotte to the park, I totally feel like a weird outsider.  We also live in a home-schooly area, so when I go to the park, I sometimes encounter large groups of school-aged kids whose parents all know each other, and aren't necessarily watching their seven year olds who are playing rough on the baby playground and not watching out for my almost-two year old.  I had one nice interaction with a young woman and a kid who was younger than C, and then I realized as they were leaving that she was the nanny/babysitter.  

On a side note (in an already long and parenthetical comment, sorry), I think that part of my insane judging paranoia is that I don't have any parent friends.  As a result, for me, all my parent interactions are online.  And I spent way too time involved in communities that really went to town on any perceived "bad parents."  I think that I weirdly live in fear that these people that I once so badly wanted to like me are now watching me and shaking their head at me and my kid.

July 18, 2009 8:40 PM
 

April said:

I take my 2 year old twins to playgrounds often. We love them!  Like you I have a hard time keeping up with the two toddlers who go in different directions.  Honestly, though I sometimes am the most attentive parent there even over the moms of singletons.  I am that one parent who is laughing chasing her kids around and going down the slides with them, etc.  I am not the one who sits on the bench and looks bored.  Oftentimes other kids wander up to me and try to befriend me because their own parent is not paying attention.  

I don't think much of helping another kid off a ledge, up a ladder, etc if I am close by.  I don't care if another parent helps mine either even though I am usually first to try to help them anyways.  I think I would be hands on even with one kid because that is how I am, but with two I have to be involved and on the go to keep up with them.  

I don't mind other kids playing with toys we bring as long as they don't run off with them and are not too rough with them.  But if I have the toy in a wagon or off to the side that means don't mess with them.  But if they are out and being used you can have a turn, as long as my toddler does not start freaking out when your kid touches it.  I know I need to teach mine to share and believe I do constantly to no improvement from them.  But sometimes I just need to let my kid be selfish because I don't want to deal with the crying when another kid touches their toy. Sorry if that makes me mean.  

There are unspoken rules of playground etiquette, but you are not breaking them.  :)  Main thing, watch your kids and be aware if they are bothering others, then correct it.

July 18, 2009 9:42 PM
 

Courtney said:

I go to playgrounds in the Davis Square area all the time with my 15 month old.  You are definitely not paranoid, in that there are some weird parent dynamics that go on, but I've found that the more I relax and stop worrying, the more comfortable things get.  There are definitely times when I am the judgy mom, like when 8 year olds take over the toddler areas while their parents blithely talk at the other end of the park or another toddler is persistently following my kid around and taking away the toys he's playing with and the parent isn't doing anything, but for the most part everything is live and let live.  If a kid needs help and his or her parent seems like they'll be right there, I just monitor the situation until the parent gets there.  If it seems more dire or the parent is held up, I intervene.  I think that the unspoken toy rule is that if it's lying around, it's fair game unless there's some indicator of ownership on it, but that obviously if the kids whose toy it is is freaking out or the family is leaving, it's time to hand it over.

I will say that while there are times when I feel judged, but for the most part the other moms and nannys are pretty nice.  I have had a couple of bad days at the playground (as I'm sure we all have), including one where I had a tearful fight with my mother over the phone (yeah, I was that mom) while my son got mixed up in an issue another kid was having.  I felt horrible, like a failure as a mom and a playground menace as I tearfully collected my son, apologized profusely, and got us both out of there.  The other moms there, however, were extremely sweet and were mostly concerned that I was ok.  Maybe they were judging me internally (I wouldn't blame them), but outwardly they were perfect and I really appreciated their kindness.

July 19, 2009 2:25 PM
 

EG said:

You know what drives me crazy?  People who let their kids climb UP the slide on a crowded playground.  I should not have to say, "Excuse me, child coming down!" because you're supposed to go DOWN.

I feel so much better.

July 19, 2009 3:12 PM
 

MidLifeMama said:

I tend to err on the overly conservative side with playground ethics. Cooper doesn't get to play with other kids' stuff unless expressly invited. We encountered a mom with two girls, one almost 4 the other almost 2, today at a park near us. The older child was VERY bossy and wanted to tell Cooper what to do and when. Mom was busy paying attention to the younger one, but managed to tell the older one to stop being bossy. She did ask me to help her off of something at one point, and given that mom was on the other side of the structure and she had asked, I went ahead and helped. But I did stop and review in my brain how that would seem if mom was overly protective. I take it case by case. But I am only keeping an eye on one kid. I don't know that I would be brave enough to try with two of him.

July 19, 2009 8:34 PM
 

Melinda Zerkula said:

Hello, this is my first comment ever, I`ve been reading your blog since the very beginning, I have twin cousins, 14 month-old Jessika and Timea whom I absolutely adore and reading your blog truly makes my day, you are an inspiration to me. I have a blog as well, melindazerkula.blogspot.com and I have posted some pictures of my cousins (also my God-daughters since I christened them last August). Tkank you for taking your time and writing for all of us to read, keep up the good work, you are wonderful at it, I hope your girls will someday love writing as much as you do.

July 20, 2009 8:01 AM
 

Melissa said:

I'm old school.  If your kid does something nearby that requires action, I'll take action.  I think most little ones are adorable anyway, so I will talk to them if they're nearby and call them cute.  That usually warms the parents up from the start.  If they fall, I'll help them up.  If they do something dangerous, I'll tell them in a nice way to be careful or "we have to keep our hands to ourselves" or something like that.  Maybe I'm more comfortable doing this since I worked in a day care center ages ago?  As far as judgement goes, we're all vulnerable (and guilty of it), but I don't let it get to me.  

Some things I have seen: I've seen a two year old walking around on the jungle gym with no parent in sight, only an older sibling who was off playing by herself.  I didn't see any parent until the child started walking off by herself to the parking lot at which time her mother, cell phone in hand, got out of the pickup truck she was hanging out in to yell at her not to come out into the parking lot.  Nice.

Just yesterday two boys, 6 and 8 came to the playground BY THEMSELVES, which is in the middle of a large field, not close to anything in particular.  It only in view of about 3 houses and they are senior housing, so I don't think they live there and they didn't come from that direction.  They were very friendly talking easily to me and my family whom they have never seen before.  Anyone could easily have kidnapped them.

July 20, 2009 12:00 PM
 

betty said:

the last time i went to the park with my twins (and my husband was there too!) i screamed "I H-A-T-E THE PARK!" (don't want to teach the 2-year-olds about hate, right?). it. is. stressful. the big kids are just doing what big kids do. it's not their faults. but the parents, on the other hand... i won't take my twins by myself. i barely make it through storytime alone and that's in a confined space.

July 20, 2009 3:39 PM
 

NotCarol said:

I can't do the park. It stresses me out. To the point where I have totally barked at bigger kids. And had more close encounters with panic attacks than I care to remember. Its so bad that we had to buy a house with a huge yard and build an ENORMOUS swin set this summer just to save me from the terrors of the MommyCliques and the big kids.

July 20, 2009 7:18 PM
 

Patty said:

I rarely do the playground thing.  We're lucky to have enough space to run around in, and a little privacy too.  Plus grandparents nearby with welcoming houses.  Given that both my husband and I work, weekends are the only available playground time and we just rarely make it.  So I don't know the rules either.

I do know that if a kid asks me for help I'll oblige, and usually the parent seems grateful for it.  I'm grateful when other parents help out my kid.  I'm rarely far enough away to require another parent, but on the big high slide that's meant for older, bigger kids (my son is a very small 2-year-old) I need a second person -- one for the top, one for the bottom -- because I'm terrified that my kid is going to crack his skull open on the soft, springy woodchips under the playset.  (It's only in the past week that he has started getting scrapes or bruises on anything OTHER than his skull, so I'm not just completely OUT THERE...)

Several years ago, long before I even seriously considered parenthood, I went to a small community gathering as a guest of a regular member.  It was a very close-knit community, and everyone's kids were everyone else's kids.  Any adult was not only allowed, but expected to help, reprimand, and hug any kid that needed it.

That was really, really awesome.

July 21, 2009 2:40 PM
 

Ohio Mom of Twins said:

The only playground I will venture to solo with my two year old twins are gated/enclosed ones - even if they are further away. Then all I need to worry about one falling off the playset while I'm assisting the other. Playground = High Blood Pressure for me!!!!

July 28, 2009 3:23 PM

Leave a Comment

(required)  
(optional)
(required)  
Add

About Roper

I'm an advertising copywriter, wannabe novelist, mother of twins, musician's wife, bleeding heart and wiseass.

in

About the Blogger

Jane Roper

Jane Roper in Boston

One baby? Piece of cake. Try two. This working mother gives you the inside scoop on the ultimate in extreme parenting: twins.

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage