FameCrawler

The Duggars: God-Lovin' Family-Values Folk, Or Child Abusers?

Posted by HerBadMother

 

Are the Duggars - that happy-go-lucky, home-schoolin', Jeebus-praisin', birth-control rejectin' family of 17 that just became a family of 18 - really the models of good Christian family values (every child a blessing!), or are they, in fact, child-abusers?

Gawker raised the question last week, and I gotta say, having watched a few episodes over the holidays, it's kind of a good question. Obviously, nobody is suggesting that the Duggar mere and pere beat their children or whatever, but still - doesn't having so many kids that you couldn't, as a parent, possibly have a close relationship with any single one of them (18! How do they even remember their names?) count as a kind of benign neglect? You can't tell me that those children aren't effectually raising each other - there simply aren't enough hours in the day for the parents (especially seeing as they have multiple businesses and a TV show) to provide attention to each kid. Maybe it's not abusive or negligent, but there's a case to be made, as Gawker says, that it's at best disturbing and at worst terrifying.

Which, whatever. There are a great many children in the world that deal  with much worse. But still - these people are cashing in on their apparent devotion to the principles fo family and the cherishing of children as God-given gifts. Gifts, shmifts - back in the day, when I was insisting to my parents and grandparents and aunts and uncles that there was no such thing as too many Barbies, a whole lot of those dolls ended up ignored, under my bed or stuffed in boxes. The first few were cherished, the first half-dozen, even, were doted upon - but once I had a crowd, they all kinda started looking the same and I couldn't remember their names and it just got a bit boring.

Children aren't Barbies, I know, but still - moderation has long been considered a virtue for a reason. Excess is excess. Just sayin'.

Source 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Courtney said:

I have to say, add in the fact that they all dress the same and that the dad is pastor of his own church and it does get a bit creepy...

December 30, 2008 8:15 PM
 

Alice said:

The older kids are all assigned a "buddy" according to the birth mother, Michelle.  The older kid is responsible for getting their buddy up in the am, bathing and dressing them, feeding them, wathcing them all day, the whole nine yards.  So they are given a child to raise.  The girls do all of the housrework, laundry and cooking for the boys.  Personally I think they are Grifters who have found a way to make money by prostituting themselves and their kids.  Gross.

December 30, 2008 9:12 PM
 

yes said:

i say the same thing about angelina and brad -- how can they possibly give these kids the love and attention each one needs? they can't. it's pure selfishness to raise that many children. i know. i was one of 10.

hey brad -- angie -- they're not barbies. stop with the adoptions and the traveling all over the place. you wanted kids. now be there for them. don't just use them for your publicity show. they need roots. they need stability. they need time and attention from their own parents.

there is absolutely nothing spiritual or kind about raising a flock of kids. nothing at all. in fact, it can easily damage a child to have to compete hard and long for a little bit of time and love from a parent.

December 30, 2008 9:38 PM
 

Megg said:

babies raising babies.  I'm oddly drawn to the show but I find that I make the "what the f*ck are they thinking" face the whole time.  It's a train wreck and I can't stop watching sometimes.

...sometimes.

My grandmother was one of 17 children.  A big catholic Portuguese family fresh off the boat.  I guess it seems normal for my great grandmother to have done it, but this family creeps me out.

December 31, 2008 2:53 AM
 

missy said:

I think at best it's negligence. There are not enough hours in the day for 18 children. It's not possible. You can be a kind 'overseer' of sorts, but you're not an effective parent. I agree with the person who called them grifters. They're making a successful business of baby making. It's not going to stop anytime soon.

And as much as I like Brangelina, and despite myself I do find them appealing, they need to stop having children and care for the ones they have. Those kids deserve it.

December 31, 2008 3:32 AM
 

lori said:

Their buddy system really angers me.  You never see the mother taking care of a child.  It's one thing to run a large household but another to be a mother.  

December 31, 2008 10:43 AM
 

sarah said:

I wish them well they seem to really love each other and are close and no ones personally knows them so I supose we oughta not judge

January 4, 2009 4:45 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage