A Girl Grows In Brooklyn

Lying Liars and The Lying Liars Who Lie

It's hard being a new parent.  I reflect on this a lot, even though my daughter is two years old now.  I will never, ever forget those first few months, I mean that whole first year.  I am still catching up on lost sleep from that time.  I had no idea what I was doing and yet I wanted to do it all myself.  I would look at other moms and everything seemed so easy for them.  Was I the only one having a tough time?

 

I remember talking to a friendly neighbor about it.  We had kids roughly the same age and so I thought she'd understand.  But as I looked to her for some head nodding, all I got were tales of how her son goes to sleep easily all the time, 24-7, nah, not a problem, neck wring and all (Ok, I'm adding that in.)  While I have come to be happy for parents who have excellent sleepers from day one, at this time I was new and nervous and yes, jealous.  And the fact that there wasn't even a remote understanding of what we were going through with the not sleeping thing, well, that made me feel even more uneasy.  When she added that her kid was "Superbaby" and that everything comes easy to him, I thought, should I have done more kegels?  Would that have made a Superbaby?  Please, how to make a Superbaby?

 

Luckily, I knew other moms with babies who also didn't sleep without some kind of help;  kids who fell asleep on the bottle or boob, took 45 minute naps and that was it for the day, only slept in the car, would only slumber in the bouncy seat (that was us for 3 solid months.)  I thought less and less about sleep issues and resigned myself to the fact that this was life right now.  It was a life with way less sleep so I should just get used to it (more coffee, nap when you can, eat high protein foods, kvetch with others like you.)  What else would I doing with myself but be bjorning my kid to sleep, rocking a baby in a chair or slinging a kid around?  This was life and that was ok.  What, I was missing out on Entertainment Tonight?

 

Then one night when I had finally gotten my kid to sleep (bottle, then jiggling -- oy my back! --  45 minutes of my life gone in a haze of "monster walking" while bouncing my baby), my husband went out to get us some delicious takeout grub.  He came back upstairs with an interesting story.

 

"Guess who I just saw?" 

 

My mouth filled with aloo motor gobi, I asked "hngfshueht?"

 

"Superbaby!  And he's been wheeled vigorously on our block because the daddy says that is the only way he will fall asleep!"

 

"He said that?" I said.  Why was that making me so happy?

 

I felt for Mr. Superbaby because I knew that pain all too well but I was also secretly glad that Superbaby needed a little help to fall asleep too.  So yeah, I felt "better" but it also bummed me out that this neighbor (truth be told, they were nice people, except for the, you know, whole competitive thing) felt compelled to lie to us when we were in the same boat.  I mean, couldn't we have supported each other?  But that's the thing you have to remember -- people lie. They're as freaked out as you and so maybe they stretch the truth a little -- or a lot.  Now I see that it's ok, if it makes them feel better.  Just don't let it get you down.  Your kid will sleep.  You will sleep.  It will happen.  

 

And that's no lie.

 


Comments

 

sumoo said:

Perhaps they weren't lying.  I'm learning w/ our baby that things CHANGE.  For weeks on end she'll sleep beautifully and all of a sudden she can't sleep unless I'm lying right next to her.  Annoying if they were, though.

February 18, 2007 9:42 PM
 

Kate said:

I love your writing!

February 19, 2007 9:25 AM
 

RachelZ said:

Yes, with the lying.  And it goes both ways.  I find myself sometimes exaggerating the "issues" we have with The Jillian (thank heavens, they are few) so that the other mommies in the playgroup won't hate me because she sleeps 12-13 hours a night with absolutely no "training" on our part.

I fully expect that to go away, though.  And, as a semi-professional insomniac, I will be ready.

February 19, 2007 11:32 AM
 

BarbaraR said:

I was truly happy for people who got their kids to sleep thru the night, either it just happening of thru sleep training.  It was just nuts how some people couldn't be honest.  I was so looking for honesty, esp. in those early months.

February 19, 2007 1:36 PM
 

J9 said:

Oh, bless you for sharing this experience. We have a beautiful, darling, precious 4.5 month old, who happens to also be, ahem, a "reluctant" sleeper. I feel like everyone I know has a story about how amazing their baby slept from early on. I figure at least some of them have got to be full of crap, right? I mean, right?!?!  Your article made me laugh and feel a whole lot better. I have read the last few sentences about twenty times now: "Your kid will sleep.  You will sleep.  It will happen." I feel so very fried but we are figuring out what works for him little by little, every day (and night!) Thanks!

February 19, 2007 7:48 PM
 

BarbaraR said:

J9 - it IS true - your baby will sleep.  Mine didn't sleep thru the night til 9 months -- and then still kinda woke up once for a bottle.  Whatever, you do what you gotta do.  i wrote this piece after seeing a new dad in the park with his 8 week old baby.  He looked tired and I asked him how it was going.  He said to me "all these people are telling me their baby sleeps thru the night and ours is up 2-3-4 times."  And I was like, "of course, you have a newborn.  Those people are lying."  And he looked at me, with such validation and said "I knew it!"  He felt so much better and I was happy to share my story with him.  People need to know that they are not alone.  New parenthood is a scary deal sometimes and knowing others are in your boat helps a ton.

February 19, 2007 8:04 PM
 

HeadMutha~ Rocky said:

Lying about what I like to call Muthahood creates the "I'm better than you" mentality. I'm the exact opposite here. I know all my kids strengths and all of their weaknesses and have no problem sharing both. Sharing the truth about Muthahood (all the good, the bad and the ugly) could bring us together as a group. If we were to be totally honest, we could be there for each other physically, mentally and spiritually. Because when times are tough and you just to rip all your hair out, the US vs. THEM should be moms vs. the kids, not moms vs. moms!

February 19, 2007 11:30 PM
 

Mommyca said:

thanks for your article, i totally agree with you. my daughter didn't sleep thru the night until she was 9 mo and i was also worried because of many things i read on the contrary. then as sumoo said things CHANGE! after many months of bliss of my daughter sleeping 11-12 hs straight, now she wakes in the middle of the night and wants me to stay with her, no matter that i sleep in a little bed next to her crib. she doesn't want me to leave the room at all, even though she doesn't  want me to hold her.

it seems that their sleeping patterns are dynamic and we have to adapt to them, but unfortunately they don't tell you that very often and we (I guess first-time parents) tend to freak out. but yes, to J9: your kid will sleep and it will be wonderful!

February 20, 2007 3:30 PM
 

simone said:

I think here in LA the thing to lie about is tv. I can't prove it, but apparently nobody watches tv. My friend went to a preschool orientation night where they were told, no media of any kind until they are 5--no tv, computers, no MUSIC.

Hey, I'm just curious since my daughter has a dairy allergy too and we'll be testing her in June--did your daughter outgrow her allergy? I can't wait to start making quesadillas and all that other good kid stuff!

February 20, 2007 3:40 PM
 

BarbaraR said:

hey simone -- nah, mamie is still allergic to dairy.  it bummed me out but i know she will outgrow it, but most likely when she is close to 4 years old.  so that means another blood test next year.  she lives on amy's organic vegan meals - the shepard's pie, veggie loaf and tofu scrambles.  i am running out of ideas!  how old is yr daughter?  and what are you cooking for her?!

February 20, 2007 3:42 PM
 

simone said:

Ah, I can talk food all day! This has been quite a journey for me since everything I know how to cook turns out to have cheese in it. Do you eat chicken/meat or eggs? My daughter  is 2.5 and likes her food pretty simple and identifiable--in case I would try to sneak some zucchini in there somewhere.  So, avocado and bean tacos, spaghetti with marinara,  stir frys, chinese chicken salad, soyriso and egg burritos, hummus and ikra with pita, black beans and rice, teriyaki chicken, chicken adobo, bacon tomato avocado sandwiches. (wow--I've never seen the list, kind of sad.) Most of the time, however, her plate looks lie a selection of hors d'oerves or like she's a raw foodist: apple, cherry tomatoes, cucumber, bread and soybutter. She rejects vegan cheese-- that would make cooking a bit more interesting. If you ahve any ideas, I'm looking to branch out too-- I'll try the Amy's Organics.

February 21, 2007 12:36 AM
 

BarbaraR said:

Simone - i am impressed!  Mamie is a meat eater but refuses eggs.  We try like everyday and she looks at me as if I am crazy (smart kid.)  Sounds like your daughter is eating great though.  Tonight, spaghetti with turkey meatballs - wish us luck!  And yes, that soy cheese is gross, but mine eats it....  Bec. of her bad teething we even tried tofutti last night and she rejected it.  Maybe I got a picky eater?....

February 21, 2007 7:56 AM
 

simone said:

No, no--Phoebe is picky too. That list is literally everything I could think of that she will eat and only sometimes. No shepherds pie for her. She hates the Tofutti too which is weird--maybe it's a texture thing. My friend said to me, "You wait--you'll be calling me in 3 years and telling me she's making her own Cobb salad." I hope so! :)

February 21, 2007 12:33 PM
 

Jackie said:

My oldest is 12 now, and I swear she didn't sleep thru the night until she was 3, and only after I bribed her with a sleeping bag present..despite all sorts of attempts.  But my favorite story is when a very bleary eyed me, stupidly asked the mother of a baby a few months ago whether her son slept thru the night, and she proudly said, oh yes, he is an angel.. She then paused, and without missing a beat, in her happy voice said, "he only got up for a few minutes, we read four books, and played with blocks, and went right back to sleep."  (this was the same mom who months after I SAW her spooning instant mashed potatoes into her son's mouth, wrinkled her own mouth and told me she wouldn't feed her child tater tots -- but that was the difference between a stay at home mom (her), and a working mom (me).  

Is it lying, or just basic delusional behavior?

February 21, 2007 2:58 PM
 

BarbaraR said:

jackie - lying AND delusional behavior, i think!  i shall never forget the mom i met with her 14 month old.  the kid couldn't talk but yet the mom told me she was ready for toilet training.  then she asked her daughter to poop and said "look at her, she pooped," in this weird proud voice.  she changed her diaper and .... no poop.  then the kid started eating dirt.

February 21, 2007 7:54 PM
 

GirlsGoneChild said:

YES! Ahhhhh! This makes me MENTAL! And I agree with the TV thing... No one lets their kids watch TV but... BUT, they do? Or it's on, but their kids aren't watching it? Huh? WTF?

February 22, 2007 2:59 AM
 

panthergirl said:

And you know what else?

I had a baby who slept all the time. And never cried. Ever. My friends hated me...they saw it for themselves, with their own eyes, as their kids shreiked and screamed. Every picture we have of her as an infant is a sleeping one. We even laid her next to the Thanksgiving turkey, fast asleep. Slept through fireworks, fire trucks, you name it.

HOWEVER...... she more than made up for the crying by the time she was four, through horrid tantrums at 7, and the sleeping? You try and wake a 12-hour block sleeper when it's time to get up for school!

Everybody gets theirs... even if they aren't lying. ;)

March 10, 2007 9:28 AM
 

panthergirl said:

Er, that was "threw horrid tantrums".

March 10, 2007 9:29 AM
 

kalimurzino@rambler.ru said:

David

May 28, 2007 3:03 PM

in

About the Blogger

Barbara Rushkoff

Barbara Rushkoff in N.Y.C.

From preschool applications to park-bench gossip, nothing escapes the gimlet eye of this Park Slope magazine writer. She'll tell you how A Girl Grows in Brooklyn.

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.

PERSONAL BLOGS

back to blog homepage

Tags

    No tags have been created or used yet.