Home/Work

I'm becoming the nap nazi

With my three older children, I was pretty loosey-goosey about naps and bedtimes. If they got naps, that was great. If they didn't, no biggie. Until they became school age, at which point I tightened up bedtimes, I tended to let them stay up in the evening until they actually acted sleepy. But when they were babies and toddlers, we had very flexible sleep routines - certainly nothing resembling a "schedule." I was inordinately proud of the fact that all of them could generally fall aslseep anywhere, at any time, with any amount of distraction, That worked fine for them, and fine for me. 

 

With their one year old sister, however, we actually have a schedule and frankly, I am rather rigid about it.

 

This is C operating on plenty of sleep.

 

 

Jon and I first discovered C's love of a predictable routine before she was even three months old. Through trial and error, we realized that if we bathed her, nursed her, swaddled her, and put her down to sleep for the night at approximately the same time and in the exact same way each evening, she slept far better than if we mixed things up, or kept her up later. Given that I returned to full time employment when she was only 8 weeks old, and Jon has a full time job, too - plus I have three other children to care for - maximum quality sleepage for the baby meant happier household.

 

She still isn't what many more highly scheduled parents would consider a "good" sleeper, if your definition of that is sleeping 8 hour stretches in a separate bed. Instead she sleeps with us, and she does usually wake a time or two for a moment or two during the nightttime hours. However, she goes down to bed at a very regular time each night - between 7 and 8 pm -  and the little bit of wakefulness she has at night is easily soothed; she goes right back to sleep with little effort on our parts. If, however, we keep her up much past her bedtime, or if she misses her bath, or if we sleep somewhere away from our house, her sleep is greatly disturbed, and so is her mood the next day. This is a child who craves a regular schedule, and who lets you know when her beloved routine has been disturbed. And have I mentioned the white noise machine? She will really only sleep deeply with the white noise machine turned on; we even take it with us when we travel.

 

This is C, awake after her bedtime after a day with no real nap

 

 

This is even more true of her naptimes. C generally takes a 1-3 hour nap every day right after lunch.  If she misses that nap, or if it is disturbed in some way (like, we are out and about at that time and she only gets 30 minutes while riding in the car), she transforms from a sunshiney toddler into Princess Whines-A-Lot. Missing the nap, or significantly altering the nap time or location makes everyone else in the family's day a living hell. She simply cannot function on sub-optimal sleepage. There is no "second wind" later in the day after a missed nap. Instead, there is meltdown after meltdown after meltdown. Plus, somewhat counterintuitively, she sleeps much worse at night if we alter her regular daytime nap schedule. So then we have a double-whammy of sleep deprivation going on.

 

Having realized all of this about my child, I have become something of a nap nazi. On weekends, I regularly turn down opportunities to do anything that would interfere with C's naptime, and I often find myself rushing home with her to avoid missing the optimal nap window. Night time activities are planned carefully to minimize the chance that C will miss bath-and-bed by 8 pm. I am sure my zealousness about this routine seems a bit odd to those who know how differently I approached sleep with my other children. But this kid is different; she's more like her Daddy, who is a noted lover of  predictability. I am parenting what I got, and what I got this time is a child who needs a lot of sleep, provided at specific times in specific places. Plus, it's a bit selfish on my part. I don't really relish dealing with a widly fussy toddler all weekend or all evening after being gone at work all day. And getting her down to bed at a reasonably early hour each night means I have more time for the older kids, who, of course, stay up later and also need mama-attention.

 

SUBSCRIBE TO THIS BLOG

FOLLOW KATIE'S BLOGGING ON TWITTER OR FACEBOOK

READ MORE OF KATIE'S BABBLE BLOGGING

VISIT KATIE'S OTHER BLOG

 

 


+ DIGG + DEL.ICIO.US

Comments

 

Stacie said:

Katie - Oh I can't tell you how happy I am to see you blog about this very subject. I, a new, first-time mom, have just this week began to change my whole way of thinking about the sleeping and sleep routine. You said it "I am parenting what I got, and what I got this time is a child who needs a lot of sleep, provided at specific times in specific places."  

Well what I got is a baby that seems to require little sleep throughout the day and will fight for every last second of awake time when it comes time to settle in for the night. I am quite sad to say that I have spent the past 5 months trying to figure out "what I was doing wrong" or "what is wrong with her" instead of just parenting the baby I have...she is who she is. Tearfully this weekend after an hour and a half of settling her in I set out to find the answer to my "problem" and instead I found this random essay by Diana Hartman blogcritics.org/.../092205.php

and it put everything into perspective for me.

So I have thrown out the advice from others who said I should have never rocked her to sleep, held her so much, or that I "need" to let her cry to "teach" her to sleep.

She isn't my sister's, mother's, best friend's baby...she is mine and she is who she is!! I just hate that it has taken me 5 months to figure this out! Thank you for your perspective and giving new moms like me confidence in our instincts to just parent by our child's needs.

January 22, 2009 8:20 AM
 

Debbie T. said:

You're a wise mommmy!!  :-)

January 22, 2009 8:25 AM
 

jon said:

Now my parents will never want to watch C over night!

January 22, 2009 8:51 AM
 

Laura Creekmore said:

I learned early on with the 9yo that regular sleep routine was critical to my sanity, if not hers. I was never a "let them cry it out mom" -- I read Attachment Parenting when the 9yo was a baby and found it fit perfectly with what I was doing. ;)

But I have always worked hard at giving the kids the tools they need to sleep. Routine is a big part of that.

I finally had to relent on being the nap nazi this winter with the 3yo -- he was CLEARLY ready to outgrow his nap, no matter what I wanted. :(

January 22, 2009 9:01 AM
 

EG said:

I have been blessed with a great sleeper - and my definition of that is 10+ straight hours per night.  I didn't really have a philosophy (other than him being in his own bed, sorry attachment parents) but he fell into this great routine and now at 22 months, sometime around 8:00 every night, he says, "Night night?" and happily says good night to everyone, gets his teeth brushed ("Aaaaahhhhh") and hits the hay.

Now that I've said all of that, #2 will probably demand to be held all the time and co-sleep and wake up every night for the first 2 years.  'Cause God is funny like that.

Well said that we have to parent what we get.

January 22, 2009 9:19 AM
 

E said:

My 15-month old is the exact same way as C.  He's my first, so i didn't have anything to compare it to, but still it was a shock.  i always thought that babies could fall asleep anywhere!  Not my baby -- he needs to go to sleep at the same time each night with his very predictable routine, and same for his nap.  Otherwise, like you said, his sleep gets messed up and I have one very cranky baby on my hands.  Up until a month ago, he was taking two naps, so I felt like all i was doing was rushing home to get him to bed.  It was so hard to do anything.  But its worth it to have a happy, well-rested baby.    

January 22, 2009 12:06 PM
 

Heather said:

I think you're right that C was just born this way.  I say that because I-- at 31!!-- still very much need consistent quality sleep and my routine.  My mom says I have been like this all my life.  For me, its how I manage the challenges and stresses of my daily life.  And when you think about it, toddlers face their own stresses and challeneges on a daily basis too.  C is effectively managing her stress!

January 22, 2009 1:29 PM
 

Miriam said:

C. and her sleep needs remind me so much of my youngest daughter. She also couldn't be overly stimulated in the late afternoon/evening or we would be up all night.(or dealing with a whiny toddler all evening) I found in general she needed less sleep than my other daughter had. But that allllll changed in kindergarten, thankfully. She was so tired from the day that she slept like a baby, finally!

January 22, 2009 2:45 PM
 

Dewi said:

Stacie  

I just read the essay by Diana Hartman, fantastic.

Where did this women come from??? She wrote a whole slew of pamphlets on coping with life.

Katie

C has some lessons in there for you, creates routine, and it slows your life down.

January 22, 2009 5:29 PM
 

Jen said:

@Dewi - such a tiresome barrage of unrelenting, negative critical posts aimed at Katie and with no takeaway for us - why not go elsewhere?

@Katie - I think most infants/toddlers need much more sleep and structured sleep than we realize or acknowledge. I wonder - do you think the parenting change in asserting nap schedules has anything to do with your age now? As an older first-time mother (40) I find myself dreading the prospect of appeasing an unhappy toddler for long stretches ESPECIALLY after a long day at work and on weekends (when I try to carve out essential alone time). I find unmediated stretches of crying/grumpiness intolerable and am happy to delegate care to others, my husband and our nanny. I wonder though if my threshold of tolerance would have been radically different if I were in my 20s or early 30s.

January 22, 2009 6:55 PM
 

Dewi said:

Jen

Who are YOU?

Exactly what are you reading into my words.

Whats up with your snide remark towards me?

You interpret what I write as "unrelenting, critical and negative".

January 23, 2009 1:30 PM
 

Diana Hartman said:

I would like to thank your commenters for the nice things they said about my articles - and I genuinely hope the suggestions I made have helped them.

I would encourage any mother who has exhausted the resources in that article to scroll down to comment #13 where I address the concerns of a mother who identified herself as "exhausted." Her concerns are very real and more common than many parents think.

Again, thank you to your commenters. I sincerely hope everyone gets a good night's sleep - eventually!

January 27, 2009 6:41 PM
 

Dewi said:

Diana,

I loved your article on sleep, and all the topics you address. I'm glad Stacie provided your link.

January 28, 2009 4:43 PM
 

ricky said:

http://www.rickydeez.com/ handles all programming aspects of creating a web site including HTML programming, creating graphics, adding pictures, creating links, and everything else that goes into building a web site.

April 14, 2009 5:31 AM

in

About the Blogger

Katie Allison Granju

A working mom embraces life with four busy kids and a continually buzzing Blackberry.

Katie Allison Granju lives in a 100-year-old house with her husband and her four children, who range in age from one to seventeen. She's a book author, a freelance writer and Director of Social Media at a public relations firm. She doesn't know how she does it either.

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage