Knocked Up

To work or not to work?

The inevitable work outside the home or stay at home crisis has come.  Lately, I've been entertaining deluded, romantic fantasies of staying at home with two little ones, fantasies that included morning runs, healthy Crockpot meals, an absence of sibiling rivalry, and homemade play clay art projects that left no mess.  Though I know staying at home would be nothing like that, these daydreams have me thinking more about work, life, motherhood, and my ever-shrinking retirement fund.

 

I'm sure you mamas out there were asked if you were going to go back to work when you were pregnant. I think that's the third or fourth question in the list of inquiries for pregnant ladies, after what are you having and what are you naming it.  Note that no one has asked my husband this question.   Ever.

 

Here are the things whirling and swirling inside of my head.  The list makes it all appear nice and organized, but truthfully it's anything but.  It's a tilt-a-whirl of frazzle and what-ifs that makes me kind of queasy. 

 

1.  I like my job.  I work for a community foundation, reviewing grant proposals and engaging with nonprofits.  It's a pretty great gig.  What's more, I like my coworkers, I work four days per week, and I have an office with a door - a benefit that I didn't value highly enough until I had to pump three times a day.  I worked hard for this job, and I don't want to give it up, nor do I feel confident that I'd be able to get it back if I did decide to leave for awhile.

 

2.  This is not an economy in which having a job - a good, stable, engaging job that you like - should be taken lightly.  The endless reports of rising unemployment rates, not to mention friends and neighbors losing their jobs, reinforces that now is a time to hang on to what you've got.  You never know when it - or your partner's job - might be gone. 

 

3.  Paying for childcare for two children will suck up the vast majority of what I take home. 

 

4.  When I'm at work, I miss my son.  But working stimulates a part of my brain that endless readings of Baby One Two Three and conversations about dogs just do not. 

 

5.  There are fabulous, loving, dedicated nannies and teachers at childcare centers.  But I am a better caretaker for my children than anyone I could hire. 

 

6.  I firmly believe that I am more patient and engaged when I'm with Axel because of my work outside of the home.  It both throws me off balance - because of the chaos and time crunch - and helps me be balanced.  I don't think this is true for everyone, but it is for me. 

 

7.  That whole chaos and time crunch thing?  I imagine it's only going to get worse come July, when little Junior arrives.  Getting out the door with one child is a crazy adventure of flying raisins and lost socks.  Getting out the door with two, with all three of us fully dressed and fed and with our lunches and bottles and work stuff in hand seems like a challenge of herculean proportions. 

 

8.  Financially, there's no right decision.  Things will be kind of tight for the next three to five years if I keep working at the same rate, and really tight if I'm not working or am working less.  I recognize that I'm incredibly lucky to even consider work as an option, not a necessity to feed my family. 

 

9.  My husband's job is going to get even crazier come fall, just when I'll theoretically be going back to work, and so I'll be doing more for the next year - more cooking and cleaning and pediatrician's visits.  In the long term, this is a good thing.  In the short term, I will have to invest in family-sized brownie mix and lots of trips to the park to stay sane. 

 

10.  Life, as they say, is short, and it gets even shorter when children are involved.  Babies create some kind of time warp that makes five minutes of crying last for two days and makes the progression from sitting up to crawling happen in thirty seconds. 

 

As you can see, I don't have an answer.  I go back and forth so much that I lose track of the question. 

 

How did you go about making the decision about going (or not going) back to work after baby? 

 

 

 

 


+ DIGG + DEL.ICIO.US

Comments

 

RIAR said:

I have been going back and forth for the same reasons you list here for more than a year!  When I first found out I was pregnant and for most of those months I totally thought I was going to quit work just like my mom did.  Then the baby came along and my world was flipped upside down and I was offered to come back part time which I accepted.  Part time is GREAT!  At the first of this year though I was told that I had to come back full time or nothing.  Since my husband is self employed and we get great health insurance (cheap too!) from my employer I decided to come back.  Thats where the guilt, tightness in chest and morning commute crying started.  I see my son for 10 minutes in the morning and about 45 to an hour at night.  The poor guy looks completely confused every time I see him.

I believe there are perfectly good care takers out there but I actually have a physical ache in my chest from anxiety and missing him all day long.  The day care plus sitter costs now run us about the same amount of money that a COBRA payment would so I just made my decision last night, I'm going to quit June 1.  My husband works crazy hours and with that and my job and shuttling back and forth, its not working for us.  Stressed out and crying is no way to go through life.  I'm sure I'll be stressed out by not being able to go to work everyday (something I've done for the last 13 years).  And I do like my job and I am really scared that I'll never be able to find something that fits me as well as this job but its a chance I have to take for our family.  I owe it to us.

Sorry this is so long!  Good luck with your decision, its not easy I know!

April 9, 2009 2:15 PM
 

Kellye said:

We live a lifestyle that we've both become quite comfortable with and without two incomes, that lifestyle just isn't possible. Call us selfish, but we life that we can take our family on vacations without much of a strain on our wallet and give them more experiences that will make them better for their life.

It's a struggle, believe me it is because I always have that longing in my heart to be with my boys and the pull that no one can raise my kids like I can...but then again, I think I'm just better suited to having a job and it's opening doors for me that I may be able to walk through later in life that I wouldn't have should I stay home. It works for us!

April 9, 2009 2:42 PM
 

EG said:

AMEN.  Don't you wish someone could just give you the right answer?  I'm hoping to go with the stay-at-home option come July.  Actually I'm hoping to be laid off and get a package, darn my company being one of the "healthy" financial services companies.  Smart buggers.

Anyway, I would really like to stay home.  I'm really glad I worked after Little Man came, because I never have to wonder what it would've been like.  And I'll never judge working moms, 'cause I've been there.  And I'm REALLY not looking forward to cutting our income in half.  I like spending money.  But the older LM gets, the harder it is to leave him every day and when I travel.

All of that said, we've added #2 to the daycare roster, and added him to the daycare waiting lists that Little Man is already on.  Not counting my chickens yet.

April 9, 2009 2:44 PM
 

Hillary said:

I'm with you on #6. As much as I feel guilty leaving The Boy some days, as much as I sometimes wish I could stay home and play, getting out and working makes me a better, more patient momma.

Your boys will be great, whatever you decide. Good luck figuring it out ...

April 9, 2009 3:14 PM
 

Chantal said:

I live in Canada.  Up here those decisions are easier to make because we have access to one year of parental employment insurance benefits and if you are lucky enough to work for a great company, they top-up those benefits up to 93ish% of our annual income.  I think too that being a working mom helps me be a better mom but it took me the full first year of my twins life to feel that way (to feel that I could juggle both kids and work).   For me, I needed to go back to work 4 days a week for the first six months to keep that balance.  I do work for an employer that supports young families and empowers us to find our own balanced life.  If I didn't have that I am not sure that I would have gone back to work though.  If I felt all the time that I was dropping the ball at work and at home I couldn't do that for very long.

From reading your post, I got the vibe that you really understand yourself well.  Your work seems to bring something to your well-being that in turn makes your children well.  

April 9, 2009 3:39 PM
 

cnoelk said:

Ah, the impossible balancing act. Here's how it works at my house for my two- and three-year-old.

Sunday = Mommy on her own day and night

Monday = Grandma while mom and dad are at work, Mommy alone in PM

Tuesday = Daddy while mom is at work, Mommy and Daddy in PM

Wednesday = Daddy while mom is at work, Mommy and Daddy in PM

Thursday = Granny for a short day while Mommy is at work and Daddy is getting things done/having time alone, Mommy and Daddy in PM

Friday = Grandma while mom and dad are at work, Mommy alone in PM

Saturday = Mommy on her own day and night

It looks crazy on paper, but it works for us! My husband is a pilot so he is gone first thing Friday through late Monday pretty much every week. My mom fills in the gaps when I am at work and the rest is my time with the kids.

April 9, 2009 3:48 PM
 

ableponder said:

I stay at home, but write novels. And my daughter goes to "play school" half-days since she was 13 months.

And I can say it's a lot easier to be a better mom when the kid is gone for a few hours a day. With #2 due May 31st (meaning 2 kids under the age of 2), I have no doubt I would lose my mind if left alone all day with both of them.

This all-or-nothing approach just doesn't seem to work for most women-- 24 hours spent at ANYTHING is too long.

April 9, 2009 4:16 PM
 

knockedup said:

Cnoelk - your schedule sounds sort of like mine, except that the day's my husband is gone rotate.  So, this week, he's at work (26 hours, if you include commute time) Wednesday, Friday, and Sunday - meaning that Wed. day Axel was at daycare and it was me alone at night, Thursday it was both of us in the evening, Friday is me alone (24 + hrs), Saturday is both, and Sunday is me alone (24 + hrs).  The nice thing is that, days I'm at work and he's home, he takes care of dinner, pick up, etc.  The hard thing is that the shift schedule rotates so it's never, ever the same from one week to the next.

Ableponder, good point about two under two.  I'll be in the same boat come July.  

April 9, 2009 4:26 PM
 

eringremlin said:

Its so tough on paper. But do what you feel is best for you and yours, adjust fire if neccessary once you've put the plan to action, and it'll all smooth out perfectly.

I stay home with my son. We always knew one of us would be home full time once we had children, so we planned accordingly. Our house is small. Our cars are older models. We vacation within driving distance. Our income was cut exactly in half when I stopped working, and while that sounds daunting, it hasn't been hard at all. We certainly don't have tons of extra cash, but we have everything we need including the security of knowing that the most capable people are raising our son- US!

Wish me luck though, because while one has been a breeze, my bro is soon adding one to my mix so he and his wife can continue working, and we're shooting for an '09 pregnancy ourselves. I picture happy days full of picnics and hand holding. It'll more likely be a gogurt-flinging, chaos riddled wild ride. But they're not little for long, and I'll have a career again someday, complete with finely honed conflict-resolution skills....

April 9, 2009 5:21 PM
 

hapamama said:

Let me say upfront, I don't have an answer or even a suggestion here...just some self-doubt and hand-wringing of my own to add.  I'm normally an on-line blog "lurker", but this hit so close to home, I wanted to share/vent.  

My daughter is 14 months old now and while I was pregnant I never imagined not going back to work as soon as I had the chance, but fate intervened and I've had the immense pleasure of not working and getting to care for my child.  There has also been a lot of guilt, knowing how lucky I was that not working was an option. So many of our friends and family were/are struggling, with mom and dad working 2 or 3 jobs each just to make ends meet.  In this economic climate, my husband and I have come to consider our situation a luxury, one that we do not regard lightly.  

Now, however, with the impending high school graduation of my step-son (who is an bright, sweet kid with a great mother who will not be able to assist us financially), his college tuition and our family's future financial security to consider, my husband and I both decided it was time for me to go back to work.  Only now, there is a part of me that is twisted in knots at the thought of leaving my precious child with someone else for 8 hours a day.  I think of all the things I will miss in her life and wonder how it will feel to have someone else tell me about her day and all the silly things she did.

I keep wondering, will working for a salary help me feel more fulfilled and well-rounded than being with my daughter all day, everyday?  How do you let go of your desires to be with one child to make a better balance for your entire family and your futures?  I know there are no easy answers to these questions (or most of the questions in parenthood!) but these are the actual ones that wake me up in the middle of the night complete with cold sweats and grinding teeth...

April 9, 2009 6:36 PM
 

Kim said:

I am expecting my first child in September and we don't have much choice about me going back to work. I have to. I am the primary bread winner and hold our health insurance. My husband also works full time, but at a much lower wage than I, but it would be a struggle to make it on my income alone, so I expect that we will both have to work.

We are very concerned however that we will end up with schedules that don't allow us to see eachother ever and just pass the kid back and forth as one of us goes off to work.

I'm hoping I can work out half of my time as work from home, but I know this will be hard to do with a babe needing my attention. I love my job and don't really want to ever give it up, so I'm kinda glad I can't really. But if my husband becomes the stay at home parent, there is a big chunk of me that is super jealous that he might get to stay at home and do what I always imagined myself doing.

April 9, 2009 6:48 PM
 

MidLifeMama said:

Financially not working was not an option for us. Even though Bob is currently laid off, we are keeping Cooper in day care, at least for the time being. He really loves it, and is learning and thriving. I agree, no one takes better care of a child better than the parent, but I see how it is benefitting Cooper to be in day care. If I could afford not to work, I probably would not, but I can't imagine not being involved in something outside of the home. But this is such a personal decision I couldn't possibly suggest what you should do.

April 9, 2009 7:55 PM
 

snorkmaiden said:

I took a five month maternity leave after my baby was born, and I was pretty miserable, lonely, and exhausted by the end of it.  It was only after I went back to work 30 hours/week that I felt like me again (and instantly became a much better mother because I was much more happy and present with my daughter).  Not only do I love my job, but being able to do things like relax and drink a leisurely cup of tea every day at work make me not resent the fact that there is rarely a moment when I can do that at home.  My husband and I are lucky in that we both have flexible jobs and were able to cut our hours back to part time (he works much fewer hours than I do).  We both get to spend hours with our 14 month old every day, and we also both get to spend time interacting with grown-ups and using different parts of our brains at work.  There are times when I wish I could cut back to 20 hours (gotta keep it at 30 to maintain health insurance -- $36 a month to insure 3 people just can't be beat).  But I'm never going back to being home 100% of the time.  I need my job for my sanity as much as I need it for my paycheck.

April 9, 2009 8:06 PM
 

amanda said:

This is such a tough one, and there is no right answer. I went back to work full time after my daughter was born. The first day I dropped her off at daycare when she was three months old was one of the saddest days of my life. I will never forget it as long as I live. I think I was crying harder than any of the babies in the room! It did get easier (emotionally), but, like you mentioned, the craziness of getting out of the house in the morning, along with the insanity of every evening, makes the whole thing completely exhausting to me sometimes. Now that she is 20 months old, I know she is getting more out of the daycare situation than she was when she was an infant (socialization, etc), but at the same time, she's sick, constantly. If I had another kid, my financial situation would be such that I would essentially be working to keep two kids in daycare. I would have no disposable income after that. So it would be a matter of working just to stay in the work force and have that adult time. Look at me - providing absolutely no help, because it's such a tricky question. I guess if you were looking for suggestions, I would say that maybe you could attempt to go back to work and just see how it goes. If it's stupid crazy, then try staying at home, if you guys can swing it, money-wise.

April 9, 2009 8:55 PM
 

Melissa said:

I would have preferred to have maybe 6 or 8 months off after I had Michael, but that wasn't possible.  That being said, I love my son, but there is no way I could stay home with him all day.  I think it's better for both of us to get out and see different people.  And he really does learn a lot at day care.  

This just applies to me personally, but I don't know if I would have the patience and discipline to be his mommy and his full-time teacher.  I don't think I'm the best person to teach him.  I think he does best with a combination of teachers in a center with a curriculum, other kids, and a mommy who's missed him all day and is happy to see him when she comes home.

April 9, 2009 9:32 PM
 

jenn/hippygoth said:

Oh man, I really feel for you.  It's such a hard decision to make.  When I had Charlotte 18 months ago, things just coalesced - a position opened up at my husband's workplace that would have the option to work at home, and because it's a small company where he's worked for years, they would be very flexible and allow him to work from home on days when I was required to be in the office.  It would mean a 20% pay cut, but I'd save by not having to pay for day care.  So that's what we did.

Now, fast forward to working from home with a toddler.  My job requires me to be in front of the computer most of the day, so if there are updates on work conditions, I can be appraised.  When Charlotte was 6 months old, she could sit on my lap, or near me, or whatever, and just talking to her would keep her amused.  Now she gets a little bored and a little mischeivous, and I have to either turn away from her or turn away from work.  I've thought about having a babysitter for a few hours a day, but provided I can even find one, our apartment is really small, and I don't know if Charlotte would be able to forget that I'm home, and I don't know if I'd be able to forget that I'm not watching her.  There is a fabulous day care that I used to work at, and I'd love to have her in the toddler room a few mornings a week, but I don't know if we could afford it, even if we could get in.  

Okay, comment in reply to your entry and other long comments....I don't have an answer.  I wish I didn't have to work just because I don't think I split my attention that well (don't tell my husband I said that).  But that's also because my job is just a job and not a part of who I am.  If I still had a job I loved, I might feel differently.

April 9, 2009 9:46 PM
 

Cara said:

After months of agonizing, I decided to stay home with my daughter when she was born. Like you, I had a great job with a company and coworkers that I really loved. But in the end, the chunk of my salary that would go towards daycare and the amount of time I would miss in my daughter's life (my work day was rarely less than 10 hours), staying home was the way I wanted to go.

I won't say that there aren't hours and days where I think I was crazy to think I could do this. There is absolutely frustration and loneliness. But there was stress and frustration at my job, too. And we are certainly on a tighter budget than before, but we prepared for this by living on just my husband's salary for the last three months of my pregnancy as we paid off our cars and credit cards.

I just feel like this part of her life is so important. I can always go back to work in a couple of years. In the end, the argument that won me was the idea that no one ever sat on their deathbed wishing they had spent more time working, but how many say they wish they had spent more time with their family?

April 9, 2009 9:51 PM
 

AKI said:

I've been thinking a lot about this... my daughter just turned one and we're considering number 2.  one close friend decided she'll likely stop working after #2, and another is considering leaving a great job after #1.  

My husband and I have talked a lot about it and really feel like my part time schedule (3 days plus a few hours while I'm home with her) is best for us.  The income is great - esp in this economy - and theres also knowing that I'm not going to have a tough time reentering the workforce when she goes to school.  I also think it's important for kids to see mom working - to know she does have a life outside of them yet the kid is still the most important thing.  And I also really like our daycare - I think it's great that she spends time with other kids, learns from other people, and is stimulated in ways I wouldn't think to try.  I'm her best caregiver but by myself I can't do it as well as the proverbial village...  Good luck making your decision... i feel like for me balance means that when I'm away from her I want to be with her but that I also wish I had some bigger projects at work (that I can't take on due to my part time schedule)

April 9, 2009 10:19 PM
 

Em said:

I enjoy reading the situations of other moms struggling with this decision, but my situation is different.

I'm the primary breadwinner, so it was never an option for me not go to back to work. But even if it was an option, I wouldn't be able to give up work 100%. I love working, I love interacting with adults and solving tough problems. And yeah, some (much?) of my self worth is tied to how I do at work. So, if I didn't have that, I would be unhappy, even though I miss my son when I go to work.

In an ideal world, I'd work from home two days a week. More than anything, it would save me the 2+ I spend sitting in traffic. But, that's life. :)

April 10, 2009 9:49 AM
 

Carla said:

It's great to read so many moms struggling with the same issue. I think it's a harsh reality about motherhood today that not many people really present to first time moms.

Currently, both DH and I work full time. We are extremely fortunate to have schedules which allow us to not need childcare; she's always with one of us. So the childcare expense is not an issue. Our daughter is 21 months and we'll be welcoming baby #2 mid-May. I have planned to take 3 months off for leave and then come back to some kind of flex schedule through the end of the year.

I know I'm lucky to have an employer who is willing to consider all the wonky schedule proposals I give but in my heart of hearts I still just want to be home. Just like some women know they need to stay at work in some capacity for their sanity and to be the best mothers they can be, I know I need to be home to be the best mother I can be.  

With our second baby on the way, I don't see how I can possibly be the mother I want to be while I work. I think I would feel differently if I were in a job that I felt passionate about but it's just an income - don't get me wrong nothing to complain about but nothing to feed my soul. It doesn't justify my leaving my family everday for something that doesn't fulfill me.

All I can say is to be willing to explore alternative schedules with your employer. If you can still commit to delivering the same quality of work then it's a good situation to present. It sounds as though your job might be well suited for a work at home/telecommuting arrangement or some kind of compressed work week.

Good luck to you and all the other ladies who replied =)

April 10, 2009 10:03 AM
 

jb said:

When we found out we were pregnant, I was at a point with my job where I wasn't feeling challenged or happy and was ready for a change.  Plus when we did the math of putting a kid in daycare, I realized that what I would take home wasn't worth the time away from my child.  I do sometimes think though if I had a job at the time that I loved, would I have made the same decision even if the money issue was the same?  I definitely believe that for some moms, working is a way to be a better mom.

So far I have loved being home.  The first few months were definitely the hardest.  My son was born in October, and winters in Iowa can be very long.  But now that he is mobile and interactive I am loving every minute.  I think the thing that was most important in our decision was how supportive and engaged my husband was and is.  He makes sure to give me my "me " time what ever that may be.  I have met other stay at home moms that I have a lot in common with, and we have a weekly play date and a monthly girls night out.  And currently my me time is exercising, which really keeps me sane.  As long as you have a strong support group, it can be a very rewarding time!

Good luck!

April 10, 2009 10:18 AM
 

Noelle said:

Oz, does your office subscribe to The Chronicle of Philanthropy?

April 10, 2009 11:15 AM
 

Susie Felber said:

This is so hard, and I couldn't begin to tell you what to do.  Except, if you were 100% sure about your spouses employment, I'd take a sharp turn toward staying home, at least for a year or two.  Or work part time, even if the $ you net is no greater, just to keep a hand in the world.  I know the fantasy, but many moms who say goodbye to working world get mega lonely and sad after the first thrill of bread making wears off.  Plus your oldest isn't a full-on toddler yet.  Although you love him to the sky, trust me, you'll probably want some time away when he goes into the two's.

I never thought I'd want to stay home, but when it was time to go back to work, and I did not want to.  It was awful, and the nanny was making tons of money and was incompetent.  

But I fought hard and got to work from home after a few months.  It's excellent, the kid can go to day care but with no commute and some flex hours, life is as good as it could be.  Plus my husband is out of work as of Jan. so I am amazingly grateful I still have a job I love, with benefits.

April 11, 2009 1:24 PM
 

Marsh'sMom said:

Like all the other moms who've commented, I agree that there is no right answer.  I worked from home for the first 8 months after my son was born and paid my sister in law come to the house during the day to watch him, which was ideal.  However, when she couldn't do it any longer, I had to make a decision.  After doing exactly what you're doing now--trying to weigh pros and cons, I ended up staying home.  

Parts of it are great: seeing his every milestone, not having to worry about getting time off when he's sick, knowing that I'm the one teaching him things, not having to tivo Oprah :), but there are drawbacks as well.  If you don't watch yourself, you can fall into the I'm only a mommy/wife period and forget to do things just for you.  When you're working you get guaranteed baby-free time.  At home, that's not the case.  You have to make a point to plan for that time (especially if your husband is doing shift work).  Otherwise, it's easy to get burnt out.  It took me about six months to figure that out.  Now I make sure that I have alone time (or friend time) planned often.  And I've started working on a novel, which gives me some mental stimulation outside of reading about Sandra Boynton's Hippos.  So, I guess my advice is to choose the option that will give you the best shot at being balanced.  

April 12, 2009 11:30 AM
 

coolteamblt said:

Staying home was a pipe dream for me, not a viable option. My husband and I barely make ends meet paying for daycare. My son can't even go to a 'center', we pay a stay a home mom a pittiance to take him four days a week, and even that stretches us kind of thin. It works for us, but I miss him so much. We had the option when I started back from my six-week leave for my husband and I to work opposite schedules and only need one day of daycare, but I turned that down. We would have had no time together as a couple, and we're relatively newly married. Being pregnant was a monstrous strain on our relationship, and I felt like we needed time together as a family unit to keep it together and functioning. I'm actually looking for a part time job in the health-care field. My SIL is able to work about 24 hours a week and stay home part of the time with her son; I would love an arrangement like that!

April 12, 2009 2:57 PM
 

Florcova said:

I really enjoy reading the different responses your are getting.

My situation is the following, I stopped working right after my son was born. I am a bilingual elementary school teacher so I'm not worried about finding a job once my kids start school. I don't miss work that much, plus my salary wasn't great so it did not make a lot of sense for me to go back to work just to spend more than half my salary on day care and be away from my son for 10 hours.

I love being at home with my baby and now that I'm pregnant again, I don't think I'd have the energy to work full time and take care of a toddler when I'm at home. However, I have to admit, that sometimes being at home is boring. I'm not missing any of my son's first... but unfortunately sometimes the highlight of my day is Oprah or talking on the phone with a friend. I try to keep myself busy with classes and outings, but after working for 12 years, I don't always enjoy being a stay at home mom.

I miss my salary too, we don't need it to pay the mortgage or food, but as a family, now we really watch what we spend and we try as much as we can to lead a frugal life.

I know I'll go back to work in a few years and I'm sure I'll look back and think...boy.. those years at home went by so fast.

I know I'm lucky that I don't have to work outside the house and I can take care of my son but sometimes I wish my days were more fun, less tedious, and more mentally challenging!

April 12, 2009 8:20 PM
 

knockedup said:

Thanks, all, for your comments.  It's interesting to read about all of your unique experiences.  I guess I'm still planning to go back to work at this point, but I'm trying to think of ways to explore flex scheduling.  

April 13, 2009 11:00 AM
 

ChiLaura said:

I understand (the best I can, as I've only stayed home with the kids) when moms say that their work provides an outlet for them and lets them be "better moms" when they're with their kids. At the same time, "better" according to what standard? Okay, if you're screaming at your kids all day and hitting them because you hate being home so much, and need to work, that's one thing. But I'm guessing that most moms or dads aren't like that. Sure, you might be more impatient at times if you're home all day, or you might tune out the kids for a bit while you take care of on-line banking during the day so that you can enjoy alone-time or husband-time at night, but even so, I think that there is an immeasurable benefit to kids having a parent around all/most of the time. Kids need to learn how to deal with someone who is impatient of frustrated with them, don't they? Isn't that a vital life-skill? Shouldn't they also have time when they're not being stimulated by adult interaction, learning to amuse or sooth themselves instead? I'm not trying to excuse bad behavior, BUT I do think that there is something to be said for kids learning that the universe doesn't revolve around them and that they can take care of themselves from time-to-time as well. Unless you're holed up at home ALL THE TIME (okay, this will probably be the case for the first little while after #2 arrives, but I'm talking about after that), your children will interact with other adults (running errands, park, neighbors, grandparents) AND with other kids, so there is room for building social skills as well.

I think that in Steven Leavitt's "Freakonomics" he talks about staying-at-home paying off in the long run (as in, not so much when your kid is 5, but when he is an adult/young adult). I think that this should count for something.

Good luck joining the 2 under 2 club! I'll soon have 3 3.5 and under; I'm trying to think of it as an adventure. =)

April 13, 2009 1:42 PM
 

ChiLaura said:

I should say, I hope that didn't sound too harsh. I don't think that moms who work outside the homes are terrible moms. If a part-time dream job fell into my lap, I would be hard-pressed to pass it up (I've never wanted to work full-time). I don't envy you this dilemma at all! I just think that a stay-at-home parent is the ideal for children, even when there are rough days, and I think that's what's best for the kids is the most important thing, not necessarily what's best for the mom.

April 13, 2009 2:34 PM
 

erin said:

good questions.  mostly do what you think will be best for your family, maybe you could work 3 days/week and some from home? don't know how flexible your work is.  I'm in charge every week day from 7-7 and sometimes it's a looooong day. The only real kid free break I get is nap time and some days for what ever reason if a nap doesn't happen, no break time for mama. I don't know how I am going to survive 2 kids!  I am thankful P goes to school 2days/week for a few hours.  I agree, the time away makes me a better mom.  Maybe if you stayed at home you could get your kids in a similar program....

April 13, 2009 6:01 PM
 

ricky said:

well, what I can say is that, with our internet technology today, mom can work at home. Maybe just need to study a little, some seo or website development, or affiliate marketing.

April 14, 2009 5:38 AM
 

ricky said:

well, with the internet technology, there's a lot of work for moms that can be done at home. just need to study a little seo, web development or affiliate marketing.  

http://www.rickydeez.com/

April 14, 2009 5:40 AM
 

Suddenly SAHM said:

The decision was made for me...I was laid off while on maternity leave! Ha ha!

April 16, 2009 8:19 AM
 

GP said:

If you can afford it, I say, stay home and try to carve out some part-time work. That's the plan around here til my daughter's in kindergarten. Everyone has to do what's best for them, but, I say, treat yourself to a "five year sabbatical" and make it not only about your babies, but about you, too.

April 16, 2009 5:41 PM
 

angel said:

First of all, I LOVE this discussion - I'm expecting my first in June and can only take a few weeks off from work (I mean, through FMLA I could take more if I wanted, but it's all unpaid, so I can only take what my vacation/sick/personal will cover).  We've been freaking out about lining up childcare, and I just love reading all the different solutions/dilemmas/thoughts that people have been writing about.

One thing though - I just wanted to point out in response to ChiLaura's comment (and not in a harsh way, but just as a way to shed light on something you may not have considered) is that sometimes, what's better for the mom IS what's better for the child.  I suffer from depression, and I know that if I were to stay at home full time - for a variety of reasons that I won't get into in depth here - it would make me much more prone to depressive periods, and I don't think it's best for me to be taking full time care of a baby if I'm in that state.  There are obviously things I can do to help myself not get into that state or to tread water as I work to get out of that state, and one of those things is having a job (again, for a variety of reasons).  So...it's not always just about needing a break from the kid, it's often about needing what you need as an individual to cope with life in general, and those needs are often amplified when a baby comes into the picture, IMHO.

April 17, 2009 1:04 PM
 

Mhristie said:

Wow!  I'm so happy to see such a balanced and non-judgmental discussion of a topic that often devolves into, "You're a bad mom!"  Good job, ladies!

I'm not sure that this is an issue for everyone, but what helped me decide to stay home is that I felt that I could "do" both being a mom and working, but I could only do one well.  I loved my job as a teacher, and I had decided to be a teacher in part because I felt it would provide flexibility for me when I decided to have kids.  However, I usually worked 12-hour days, not including the masses of grading and sponsoring student activities on weekends.  When I was expecting my first, I realized that this would have to change.  Rather than scaling back my work performance and being mediocre, I decided I would devote all my energy to being a mom for a few years and be proud of the memory of myself as a dedicated teacher.  Now, being a mom is my job--it fulfills and challenges me in the same way that being employed did.  I try to set goals for myself and my children so that we're not just marking time, and so that I don't feel like I've given something up to be here.  There are boring rainy days, sure, but I haven't regretted my decision at all.

April 19, 2009 2:22 PM
 

dhsredhead said:

I stayed home for the first year after my pregnancy and a few months before because of some physical complications with working. I started working again mainly because my partner lost his job, when we had just purchased a house and a new car that we needed to pay for. He quickly found another job, but I continued to work. I know some moms really enjoy the stay at home mom thing, but it was extremely boring for me. Probably for my daughter also. I took the time we had for granted, now I spend much more quality time with my daughter even though I work full time. She also loves her babysitter and I am happy she is interacting with other children for most of the day. We are also able to save money now that I am working which we were not able to do before. Honestly, I think the SAHM, working mom debate is sad. We as mothers can be both. Work only represents 8 hours of my day. My daughter gets the other 16.

April 20, 2009 11:37 PM
 

kathy said:

I went back to work 4 months after each of my sons was born and have worked full-time ever since. I might have stayed home if we could have afforded it (meaning, still keep the same standard of living and not having to cut back) but like one of the commenters in the beginning, I like being able to take very nice vacations, send my boys (who are now 13 and 10) to summer camp that they love, go out to dinner, etc. I know that if I had stayed home, I'd probably be overweight, addicted to soap operas, and pretty much waste my days away. I wouldn't necessarily play with my kids or do special things with them. But with working, I value my time with them much more and can really enjoy it.

Good luck with your decision.

May 7, 2009 3:28 PM

in

About the Blogger

Oz Spies

Oz Spies in Denver

Oz Spies lives in Denver, Colorado with her husband, a firefighter; their son, Axel; and a slightly obese dog and cat. She has a MFA in Creative Writing from Colorado State University.

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage