Strollerderby

The Mommy Wars: Angelina, Madonna and Me

Posted by Alisyn

You know what I hate?  The Mommy Wars.  Stay-at-Home vs. Working moms.  Attachment vs. Waldorf vs. "I got spanked and I turned out fine!" moms.  Homeschooling vs. Unschooling vs. Charter schooling moms.  Oh, do you not feel welcome among any of the aforementioned warring mom factions?  Okay - how 'bout if we add to the fray a new and completely media driven battleground: Adoptive Celebrity moms vs... uh, other adoptive celebrity moms.

Sunday's Daily Mail, a British tabloid, reports that the world's most famous adoptive mom, Angelina Jolie, is unhappy with new adoptive mom Madonna's decision to quasi-adopt a semi-orphan from Malawi, a country in which there is no legal adoption process.  The paper quotes Jolie as saying "Personally, I prefer to stay on the right side of the law.  I would never take a child away from a place where adoption is illegal."  (Human rights groups are still investigating whether Madonna used her 1 million pound "donation" to the orphanage where 1 year-old David lived, to bypass laws prohibiting foreigners from adopting Malawians).

 Yeah, the Madonna thing is totally fishy.  My guess is that Angelina probably felt some sort of obligation to stand up and stay "there's a right way and a wrong way to this this, people," because, let's face it - she is the global face of adoption. But the bottom line is that, because of Madonna, conceited and misguided though she may be,  there is one less African child living in an overburdened, underfunded orphanage.  Because of Madonna, there is one more young African man in the world with unlimited opportunities and a loving home and family.  And everyone knows it. 

Now, I do not defend Madonna's shady dealings - but, seriously?  What is more important,here?  Even young David's biological father, Yohane Banda, who relinquished his son since he could not afford to care for him says "As David's father, I have no problem with (the adoption).  What I want is a good life, a good ecducation for my child."  The very same article that claims that Angelina is "attacking" Madonna quotes her saying "I have been horrified by the attacks (Madonna) has been subjected to.  All that should count is the happiness of little David."

Ouch!  Quite the scathing commentary, eh?  What a bitchfest.  CATFIGHT!!  Come on.  Give me a fucking break.  The Mommy Wars are raging - we know.  Vegetarian Moms hate/resent/insert-angry-verb-here Hamburger Moms - we know. Adoptive Actress Moms totally kick the asses of Adoptive Musician Moms - we know.  We know because bullshit mainstream media publications tell us all the time. 

But the war stops today if we stop it.  The Soccer Moms and the Baseball Moms become friends today, if we want it.  The M.I.L.F.s and the Mom Jeans coexist peacefully - happily! - if we make it happen.  And we can.  Because we're moms.   Because whether you are a birth mother or an adoptive mother, a celebrity or struggling single mom, you're a mom.  We are caring for the children of the world, and we are amazing.  And though that simple fact is not enough to sell magazines or self-help books, it's enough to change the way the world looks at us, if we believe in it, and in each other.  Cheesy but true.  


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

jacksjill said:

I agree. Why can't we all just get on with the business of parenting-and all the rest of our lives- and stop spending so much time and energy and resources envying, judging, and comparing ourselves to each other.

January 8, 2007 1:22 PM
 

biologyfool said:

"Malawi, a country in which there is no legal adoption process."

I don't think that's entirely accurate.  AFAIK, there's a legal adoption process, you just need to live there (or get a court to  get you out of the requirement).

All adoptive parents should be worried about potential illegal adoptions since it jeopardizes the adoption process.  Who cares if one less child is in an orphanage, if it results in a country shutting down their foreign adoptions program.

-Brian

http://onthefly.wordpress.com

January 8, 2007 1:48 PM
 

Rachael Brownell (Redsy) said:

Well and brilliantly put, Alisyn!!

January 8, 2007 2:59 PM
 

ahawes said:

Hasn't Mia Farrow been adopting a lot longer than Angelina Jolie?

January 8, 2007 4:59 PM
 

mamazilla said:

personally, i don't think all mommies and/or daddies have to be friends with each other necessarily.  i think we just need to mutually respect each others space.  

for example, i don't really want to be friends with a mom down the street who is openly racist (to other caucasians).  but, she's my neighbor.  she has lovely children who my children like to play with.  and she's never said anything racist to me (i'm asian).  i'll still help her when she needs it.  i'll talk/listen to her when we pass each other on the street. however, if and or when she does say something, that will certainly change the dynamic between us.  

also, i just wanted to put in my worthless $.02 re: the madonna/david adoption.  in a dateline interview, madonna said something like, “in american orphanages, children get all their basic needs met. they have clothes. they have food. they have medicine. they have adults that look after them. there is nothing like this in africa... it’s a state of emergency....”

so, i saw a video of david’s orphanage, "home of hope". i expected to see heartbreaking footage like another video i saw of homeless children from north korea.

instead, i saw smiling children who were clothed, who had what looked like a lot of food and though most of the footage is of the children, there were adults in the fore & background caring for them. i read another article about the orphanage and apparently it is one of two exceptional orphanages in malawi.

so, of the thousands of malawi orphans who truly live in the dire straits, who are in need of basic things for survival - immediate medical attention, clothing, food, shelter, love - madonna chose david - a child who wasn’t an orphan at all, who wasn’t ill and was cared for at one of the most exceptional orphanages in the country?

i'm not against international adoption.  i just think other avenues (besides the two (staying an orphan v. international adoption) that are discussed) need to be explored and encouraged.

January 8, 2007 5:29 PM
 

Strollerderby said:

Remember how Madonna and Guy Ritchie said buying a baby helped their troubled marriage ? That welcoming

May 9, 2007 12:36 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage