Strollerderby

Tired of Changing Diapers? Try Elimination Communication

Posted by Karen Murphy

baby potty I admit, when I first heard about Elimination Communication (EC) several years ago, I was skeptical.  Really skeptical.  Okay, maybe I even said, "Ewww."  After all, what was this about?  Rushing to hold your infant over a potty, based on intuition and certain cues?  I'm a big believer in non-verbal communication, telepathy if you will, and in fact I've communicated with my own children that way when they were pre-verbal, using it for instance to know when they were hungry or thirsty (and don't many parents do that?  Think about it; I'm sure you have done this too), but, uh, the peeing and pooping?  It's one thing to mistake "I want that block" for "I'm thirsty", but....the pee.  And the poop. 

But what about the diapers?  They're expensive, and lots of people have issues with the bleaches and gels and dyes that kids are wearing next to their kid-bits for longer and longer periods now, judging by the ever-increasing diaper sizes that are now available (soon!  In Extra Jumbo Jumbo!  New retro designs, great for the dorm!), and aren't we filling up our landfills with these things, each one with a half-life of about 400 years, collectively containing enough ammonia and methane to increase global warming at least ten degrees?

So...should the hipster parent be thinking about having their babies go commando?  Apparently, this concept is not new, nor is it confined to super-crunchy AP parents. Parents in many parts of the world who don't have easy access to disposable diapers have been doing this for years. According to this article, "for most [EC parents], it's another way to stay in tune with their babies, just as they pick up cues the child is hungry or tired. They emphasize that it's a process, not a goal of training a child within a certain time frame." Okay, but what about the parents who work outside the home?  And what is this about holding a potty under the child while he nurses?  And what about the split-crotch panties uh, pants for babies? 

If you're interested in this concept, there is a wealth of information available about it, but be aware that the experts advise that there is a "window of opportunity" for beginning EC that only extends to about five or six months of age. After that, it's Huggies all the way. Sorry, Charlie.


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

RachelZ said:

I only WISH I had the kind of free time necessary to follow the baby around all day and catch the pee.  And the poop.  But if I did, I myself would never have time to pee.  Or poop.  Or eat and drink in order to make pee.  And poop.

Who ARE these people and how do they have this kind of free time?  Do they ever leave the house?

January 20, 2007 8:48 PM
 

tiffanykapri said:

I practice EC with my 5 month old daughter.  I know it sounds  like a crazy concept but it really makes sense to me.  I did it to some extent with my son from about 4-10 months when I kind of let it slip, but still offered him opportunities to use the potty almost everyday. I really think that it helped make his "potty training" at age 2 so easy.  We really had any accidents when potty training and it was pretty much over in a week or so.

Now, I've been EC-ing my daughter since she was about 3 months.  I am VERY laid back about it.  I started just taking her after naps (most infants pee right after a nap) and now I can read her cues pretty well.  She still wears a diaper all the time and uses it frequently. I don't count catches or misses at all- for our family, it's just all about offering the opportunity and having her always be aware that peeing and pooping goes in the potty.

Trust me, I do not sit at home all day with a potty under my baby.  We live in NYC and are frequently out and about. I really don't do it outside of the house much at this age.  EC is as much work as you make it.  It just didn't make sense for me to have my kid rely exclusively on diapers for 2+ years and then expect them to use the potty all of a sudden.  

January 21, 2007 7:21 PM
 

Karen Murphy said:

Wow, Tiffany, you found a way to make this work for your family.  That's amazing.  You're a braver woman than I.

January 21, 2007 8:19 PM
 

selfmademom said:

My former nanny was a huge proponent of early potty training.  I was very excited- someone ELSE could help me try this whole potty training thing, and at an early age?  was sold.  Unfortunately, I think she got a little lazy and it never materialized.  Now he's passed the window of opportunity, according to the article. So I guess I'm stuck with diapers a little while longer.  oh well. maybe with #2.  No pun intended.

January 21, 2007 8:32 PM
 

Kaz said:

Hey, I'm all for EC if the parents want to do it... The thing that is a little ditressing about this post is that it offers it as the only alternative to disposable diapers...

Okay, okay, I know this post was really just to talk about EC, and the disposable thing was thrown in there to make a point, but...

It would have been nice to at least see a mention of cloth diapers or other alternatives, such as gDiapers at least thrown in.

Otherwise, I am like most - if you can do this with your kids, more power to ya!

January 22, 2007 1:14 PM
 

Barbara said:

my daughter is two months old and we have we're doing the communicating (we make the sign for potty when we change her or she poops), just not too successful on "catching" the eliminating. She's in G-diapers most of the time.

January 27, 2007 9:15 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage