Strollerderby

Woodlan High School Student In Trouble For Editorial Preaching Tolerance

Posted by JasonAvant

An open letter to Woodlan High School Principal Edwin Yoder:

Dear Mr. Yoder - Do you like apples? Hold that thought. I read, with great interest, this article detailing your actions following the publication of a column by sophomore Megan Chase. Seems that you weren't happy with the piece, calling it inappropriate and reprimanding the school's journalism teacher for allowing the students to run it without your approval. (It's interesting that you chose to allow a piece on teen pregnancy to run in a previous issue, but a piece calling for straight students to be tolerate of GLBT students was "inappropriate.")

This pissed me off, for a number of reasons. I was thinking of a snarky rant about close-minded conservative homophobes holding positions of authority in public schools, and how sad it is that such ass-backward moralists hold sway over impressionable kids who need to hear from their peers that hate is not OK. But then I thought, gee, what would really piss you off? And it hit me, the time-honored way of dealing with people like you, who gain such satisfaction over muzzling the voices of people whose opinions don't conform to your own.

There are, according to this site, 728 students at Woodlan. Ms. Chase's article was presumably read by some of them. Strollerderby gets - best guess here - a few thousand hits a day. And a few hundred websites link to this one, meaning that there's the potential for several thousand additional readers to click on a particular piece.  Ms. Chase's column - very appropriate for kids of any age, in my opinion, and a nicely written one at that - is printed in full in the article. And we Godless gay-lovin' liberal parent bloggers, we do love linking to stories about bigots who try to impose their narrow-minded beliefs upon those who have little choice in the matter. So rather than quash her piece, as you intended, you've given Ms. Chase a very, very large audience. So I'll rephrase the question from paragraph one. How 'bout them apples?


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Peter said:

I'm struck by the line "school officials do not have an issue with the topic but with the lack of balance and thoroughness in the opinion piece."

I've only been in journalism for about 10 years, but isn't "lack of balance" what makes it an opinion piece?

February 23, 2007 7:28 AM
 

Whit said:

Nice one Jason!

The principal is an idiot.

February 23, 2007 12:26 PM
 

Strollerderby said:

Welcome to this, the first installment of our weekly roundup of Strollerderby's best. Realizing that

February 24, 2007 3:51 PM
 

Trent Forrest said:

  Mr. Avant,

  Opinions should always be allowed of everyone, and somebody who is not a Christian should have the same voice as those of us who call ourselves Christian.  However, because I hold strong moral convictions, should I not have a voice?  I am a very conservative Christian; who still has gay friends; however, I will never tell those friends, they are right in their lifestyle.  There is a difference between loving somebody and accepting everything they do.  Telling somebody they are morally wrong is not hating them.  I can love and fully accept somebody without pretending to agree with what they believe.  Do you really think I should change who I am so that those who have different convictions can remain the same?  I am not willing to lose my convictions in order to be friends with anyone.  It should work both ways.    

   You are right.  Ms. Chase's article is a very well written article.  I was very impressed.  I graduated in 06 from Woodlan and I know that Dr. Yoder goes overboard from time to time. It appears to me that he did overstep his bounds in this case; however, do NOT put me and my other "closeminded, homophobe, ass-backward moralist" friends in the same stereotype as those who make a habit out of overstepping their bounds.  It seems to me, you're commiting the same closeminded crime as Dr. Yoder.  

February 25, 2007 10:25 PM
 

Anonymous said:

eyoder@eacs.k12.in.us

March 2, 2007 11:23 PM

About JasonAvant

Jason Avant is the Founder and Managing Editor of DadCentric, a groundbreaking and popular blog that, according to his agent, provides an offbeat look at events and issues that affect today's fathers. He also writes for Maya's Mom, and his personal blog, Pet Cobra. Jason lives and works in San Diego, Calif. with his wife and two-year old son. His hobbies include surfing, skateboarding, muttering under his breath, haggis tasting, macrame', and writing short descriptions about himself in the third person.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage