Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Nothing is Safe: Baby Bottles Found to be Toxic

Posted by Karen Murphy

baby bottles plasticSo you've just thrown out your baby's plastic toys, but those bottles are safe, right?  Wrong!  It turns out they contain and leach out a chemical called bisphenol A which is used to make clear plastic.  Five popular bottle brands were tested:  Avent, Dr. Brown's, Evenflo, Gerber and Playtex, and ALL FIVE were found to leach bisphenol A at levels considered high enough to cause harm in numerous laboratory animal studies (sorry, mice, so sorry, but then again, thank you).   Bisphenol A has been linked by scientists to cancers, impaired immune function, early onset of puberty, obesity (WTF? Does everything cause that?), diabetes and hyperactivity.

Is nothing safe or sacred?  Apparently not. I think I'll go hide in a hole somewhere now.  So what's a parent to do?  The bottles are all poison?  Even many breast-fed babies use bottles sometimes.  Well, there's glass.  That's still pretty safe, aside from the obvious breakage-and-stepping-in-shards factor.  And there IS "safer" plastic.  There's more information here at the site of Environment California, a group working to require product manufacturer labeling and reforms in chemical manufacturers' policies (but I still couldn't find which plastics were considered "safer").



Comments

 

Annie said:

I used glass bottles every day for a year, six bottles a day plus two or three mini water bottles, and in all that time I only broke two.  I loved them.  They looked cleaner and felt cleaner than plastic.

This story makes me really bloody angry.  The money that these firms make they should damn well make sure that their product is safe.  I don't want "safer" plastics, I want SAFE plastics.  If it is not safe then don't make the bottles. I'm waiting for the announcement now that the teats are unsafe, or spoons, or bowls.

February 28, 2007 7:43 AM
 

Leah said:

From everything I've read, plastics #3 and 7 are bad.  Plastic #5 is good (doesn't leach anything nasty.  You can see what the numbers are in the little recycling logo on the plastic - even my plastic spoons have that (and they're #5, I was so happy).

This was one of those news stories that really made me happy that my baby hates bottles with a desperate passion.  Usually it's a little annoying (I can't go anywhere for very long, even though it doesn't bug me, it would be nice to have the theoretical option!), but now I'm kinda happy about it.

February 28, 2007 7:55 AM
 

RachelZ said:

GAH!  Like I said before, EVERYTHING can kill you.  

So harsh dishwashing soap and hot water can speed up the leaching process. Great.  I'll just dip them in bleach instead.  However, I would like to know what the actual rate of leaching IS and how long it takes before the chemicals leach to such a level that they're dangerous.  They never tell you THAT in these stories, do they?

February 28, 2007 8:45 AM
 

Karen Murphy said:

Another option is stainless steel, but I don't think they make bottles out of that.  Kleen Kanteen makes stainless steel sippy cups now, though, in addition to their growing line of stainless steel water bottles.  Yeah, I'm a fan.  And I think I would have looked into glass bottles.

February 28, 2007 8:58 AM
 

ColleenP said:

The one brand of baby bottle that I have found "safe" from bisphenol-a is Born Free.  Their bottles are made out of a new, safe, honey-colored plastic called Polyamide (PA) that is free of Bisphenol-A.  Their website explains it all:  www.newbornfree.com

February 28, 2007 9:01 AM
 

Karen Murphy said:

Yeah!!  Thanks Colleen, I knew somebody'd come through with this info!

February 28, 2007 9:11 AM
 

Mark said:

Another "safe" brand of bottle is the MAM Ultivent series by Sassy. These are the bottles we plan to use with our daughter, and they're a bit less expensive than the Born Free bottles. Online at www.mambabyusa.com and www.mambaby.com

February 28, 2007 12:16 PM
 

Julie Kang said:

I started my newborn off with the Born Free system, but have recently switched to the Playtex Disposable system.  The liners are Plastic #4.

February 28, 2007 12:38 PM
 

airwick said:

I'm curious though ... is this a case where the amount of chemical that the poor little mice received was proportionately something like 500 times the amount that would be necessary to cause harm to a baby?  That is to say the average mouse weighs about 20 grams (go Google) that is 0.04 lbs.    

What I'm saying is - sure, the levels were high enough to cause harm in mice.  But mice are really, really small - when you put the same quantity of stuff inside of a human, it gets diluted much more.  So you would need much more of that same bad stuff to actually cause the same amount of harm in the baby human as in the mouse.

So is it a good thing that the chemicals are there, no ... but is it necessarily a bad thing ... no ... more research needs to be done to prove that the levels of chemical released are actually enough to cause damage in humans.

February 28, 2007 2:54 PM
 

Sarah said:

Luckily a SF Bay Area company Adiri will be introducing a 100% Polycarbonate-free bottle in the next few months. This bottle is uber hip and easy to use, the nipple is shaped like a breast, and it's SAFE. Expect to be able to buy it in June. See the following for images and more info:

http://www.adiri.com/products_html/expecting.asp

February 28, 2007 3:05 PM
 

Terri said:

re: mice are tiny.

Actually, what's so alarming about these data is that the mice are given "extremely low doses" of Bisphenol A. The man at the helm of this movement is Frederick vom Saal at U of Missouri.

February 28, 2007 8:32 PM
 

anylaurie said:

I just ordered the babymama bottles. Thanks for the links.

Laurie

February 28, 2007 10:14 PM
 

Strollerderby said:

Parents have enough to worry about these days as it is, especially parents of newborns. But here's one more: experts are advocating that you refrain from using poycarbonate baby bottles and sippy cups . Yikes! We've mentioned this before , but

August 1, 2007 11:54 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage