Strollerderby

Babywearing: A Sling Wrap-Up

Posted by Karen Murphy

sling baby carrierSlings are hip now, no longer hippie.  I own, uh, eight of them.  But that doesn't make me hip, just obsessed maybe.  Anyway, babywearing has a long history.  Used for centuries in many countries and cultures, in recent years in Western cultures it was mostly in the purview of those annoying attachment-parenting-practicing parents (Yes!  I am one! sort of!) and championed by Drs. William and Martha Sears as a cure-all to practically anything that could possibly ail a baby.

So I get that wearing your baby, carrying it around all day, helps them feel comfortable and nurtured, and gives you time to get stuff done.  I get that.  The problem is, until fairly recently, babywearing gear was butt-ugly.  When my older son was born, being the Good Mommy that I was trying to be, I asked The Ex to bring home a baby carrier.  I had in mind something sleek and simple, like a Baby Bjorn.  But no.  I got a powder-blue Ugly Snugli.  Which I could not bear to be seen wearing in private let alone in public, so that child ended up in the stroller.  Which he adored.

The next baby got the Baby Bjorn.  I knew what I wanted.  Before that, I got all teary from reading too many issues of Mothering and bought a New Native Baby Carrier, which was much better-looking, in my mind, than those ginormous padded ring slings (which many mamas swear by!  which is wonderful!  I just couldn't get past the thing screaming HELLO LOOK AT ME I AM WEARING A BABY AND A LOT OF PADDING at me, plus when I borrowed one and tried vacuuming for 30 minutes with my daughter in it I wished later for a chiropractor, so let's just say it didn't work for me), and I loved how it folded up so small! so handy! so packable!  And I used it a lot at the grocery store.  But then she got the Bjorn and really found her niche.  (I found out later that sling proponents say that the Bjorn-style carriers mess up a baby's hip development, and I have to say I'm a little bothered by the sight of very young infants in one, with their poor little dangly legs and wobbly heads.)

The next and final baby had the advantage of having all the kinks worked out on his siblings.  This baby was going to have the best!  Plus he was small so the sling thing worked for a long time.  Our favorite, from its portability and adjustableness (that is too a word!  if I say it is!), was the Maya Wrap Pouch.  Similar to the New Native, yet adjustable in length so it fit my son in a variety of situations (coats on, coats off, various wearers, etc.), this one got a lot of use.  Another great sling was the Didymos, basically a long length of fabric tied around you and the baby in various configurations to create different wraps for different babies' needs.  This one is very comfortable when you're wearing it and holds the baby securely, but there's a huge learning curve in the various ties and wraps and it can be a bit daunting.  Plus the Didy is a bit pricey, though there are lots of alternatives.  A wonderful and easier-to-learn alternative is the Asian-style carrier, very beautiful and also comfortable, worn front or back.  I got a custom Mei Tai from Free Hand Baby that I adored (I told you I was a bit obsessed), and found it easy to tie and comfortable, and my son really liked it.

Daunted by all the choices?  The site that helped me the most was Peppermint.com, which has this great guide to choosing the best sling for you.  Still don't see anything you like?  How about this totally freaking expensive cashmere sling from Oopa Baby?

 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

nancyt said:

Thank you so much for an excellent, informative post. I have a five-week-old, and I'm currently going crazy carrying him around all day WITHOUT a sling, yet I've felt completely daunted at the prospect of trying to choose one and then being stuck with it. This post is precisely what I needed!

March 6, 2007 10:12 AM
 

Alisyn said:

I still use my camouflage "Over the Sholder Baby Holder" with my 22-month-old, and so does my hubz.  I think the OSBH has been discontinued, but it's very similar to the ring sling.  Slinging my babies was the best thing I did for them, after breastfeeding, and buying a sling is always my #1 recommendation for the thing new parents need the most.  

Great post, Karen!

March 6, 2007 10:38 AM
 

Sheri said:

I got the Baby Bjorn with the extra back support for our 3rd child.  It was great because I didn't have to worry about using our double stroller (bus) for a few months.  Quinn just laid his head on my chest and slept like a lil angel.  I have friends who swear by the OSBH, but after paying a mint for the Bjorn, my dh wasn't gonna get me yet another sling (I have the one with the clip too, I was always afraid Nate or Quinn wouldn't get enough air or they'd tumble out.)   But I love the Bjorn and recommend it!!!

March 6, 2007 12:13 PM
 

Grrrlfriend Jess said:

Hello, my name is Jessica and I'm also a slingaholic. I love love love my Hotslings because they are comfy, easy and oh-so gorgeous. I also the soft and sweet Peanut Shells by Goo-Ga and my ultra-gorgeous brocade mei tai by Rosie Baby. These slings are the key to mama-sanity. I am convinced of it.

Hotslings - http://www.hotslings.com

Peanut Shells - http://www.goo-ga.com

March 6, 2007 12:18 PM
 

CairoMama said:

Mothering Magazine had a great article in the Jan/Feb 2007 issue titled "Babywearing 101" for anyone looking to buy a baby carrier.

I love the Beco and Ergo carriers. They are both two-shouldered carriers with waist and chest straps. They can be used to wear your baby in front, on the side and on your baby. They are both very easy to use. These carriers wiith save your back and shoulders. They are much better than the Bjorn and can be used longer.

The Ergo is cotton canvas and comes in a small range of classic colors and one print. www.ergobabycarriers.com.

The Beco has wonderful prints and is a little lighter and small than the Ergo. www.ecobabies.com

March 6, 2007 12:26 PM
 

Nancy said:

My baby hated the Bjorn. I found Peppermint.com (great site!) and ended up getting a Rebozo. It's been wonderful. My baby loves it and it's so versatile; it was also easy on the wallet. There is definitely a learning curve with using it, but there are a few websites that have really good instructions. I don't know how I did anything with my first child 18 years ago without a carrier.

There is a website that shows you how to make your own Rebozo:

http://www.borntolove.com/frugal-column9.html

March 6, 2007 12:47 PM
 

ZeitgeistMama said:

Ooh ooh! I love singing the praises of my Moby Wrap - it's one of those long, wrap it all crazy around you slings, but once you get the hang of it, it's incredibly comfy. I brought my son to work with me for the first 5 months and he basically lived in the sling on me the whole time- very Kangaroo style. The jersey material is soft, stretchy, and very subtle in black - it looks like a ballet wrap shirt more than a giant patterned sling. http://www.mobywrap.com

March 6, 2007 1:06 PM
 

Karen Murphy said:

You guys are mentioning all the slings I wished I had remembered when I wrote!  Yay, thanks!  (Ergo, Moby Wrap, etc.).  

BTW, here's a link to a great set of videos on sling tying:

http://www.mamatoto.org/Default.aspx?tabid=173

March 6, 2007 1:19 PM
 

tip said:

I live in Austin and the summers are long and HOT!!!!

I have a Bjorn that I used for my first baby (who is now 4) and he adored it. However, the info about Bjorn's affecting hip development has me concerned. And also, babies really do look more comfy in a sling.

However, the Bjorn does seem the best option for hot weather. I would hate to be wrapped in fabric in the summer and I worry the baby would overheat.

Do any of you recommend a sling for a baby and very petite mom who will have to endure 100F (and higher) weather next summer.

Another question, are slings ok for the Mom's back? The Bjorn seems to have better positioning for back support, because it is centered rather than angled.

March 6, 2007 1:37 PM
 

Laurel McCarthy said:

I just wanted to let y'all know that one of the best ways to choose the right carrier for you is to meet up with other moms who can show you theirs, so that you can try them on before investing lots of money buying online.  See if your area has a NINO group (stands for Nine In Nine Out), they have monthly meetings of babywearing minded parents.  

If there's no NINO group in your area, or that's not your thing, consider finding a babywearing educator.  There's a listing at www.wearyourbaby.com (the Mamatoto site) under "Get Help."

Another awesome online resource is www.thebabywearer.com - in addition to lots of great articles and a review database, they have an active forums board with answers to any question you might have!

To answer Tip's questions about slings:  a good sling will distribute the weight pretty well across your back but it can't equal the distribution of a 2-shouldered carrier like the Bjorn, ERGO, a mei tai or a wrap.  

The ERGO is a great alternative to the Bjorn and can hold a child well into toddlerhood.  It can also be used a back carrier and doesn't have the hip issues that the Bjorn has.  

Slings also come in lots of different fabrics.  For very hot weather, you might want to consider a mesh or solarveil sling, such as those at www.kangarookorner.com.  

HTH!

March 6, 2007 3:39 PM
 

Laurel McCarthy said:

Oops, I forgot to post the link for NINO - it's http://www.nineinnineout.org/

March 6, 2007 3:45 PM
 

tiffer said:

I LOVE my Ergo carrier.  I spent a lot of money on different slings and a baby bjorn.  But I have a 24 lb 7 month old!!!  So, I needed something that could distribute the weight better than the others.  I don't even feel like I'm holding him when I have him in the Ergo.  The slings didn't distribute the weight very well...and let's just say the chiropractor is making a lot of money off me right now because of it!!

March 7, 2007 11:26 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage