Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Britain Joins U.S. (and France?) in Saying No Alcohol During Pregnancy

Ahhh the Brits.  The nice people often accused of bad food, excellent architecture and poor taste in allies have finally ruled against moderate alcohol consumption during pregnancy.  Rachel Weisz
better watch where she quaffs that next brew.  Unlike the Aussies, who lately have determined that drinking in moderation is still acceptable, the British government has decided to rule against even occasional consumption during pregnancy or when trying to conceive a child.  Warning labels to this effect will be added to wine, beer, and spirits.  Shockingly France, the poster country of wine with everything, is apparently also considering warning labels.

Not surprisingly, wine growers and others representing alcohol interests, argue that the pregnancy warnings are overkill and point out, rightly, the new warnings contradict existing Department of Health guidelines, which allow occasional usage as not damaging to the fetus.

Despite the terrible outcomes associated with drinking heavily while pregnant (fetal alcohol syndrome), most women admit to consuming alcohol at some point during pregnancy.  So total abstinence may be the absolute safest course of action, but I'm with Rachel Weisz on this one.  I think it's better to have an occasional glass of wine after the first trimester than try and follow a rigid regimen of total abstinence. And now apparently we'll both be "pilloried" in England and the States.


Comments

 

Renee said:

I'm all for moderation, and I'm not about to berate someone for the (very) occasional drink during pregnancy.  But there are also very good physiological reasons for total abstinence during pregnancy.  For instance:  

Alcohol readily crosses the placenta, and is found in the same concentrations in both maternal & fetal bloodstreams.

But the fetal liver cannot break down alcohol, so it persists in the fetal bloodstream much longer, increasing the duration of exposure.

Although the worst effects (such as Fetal Alcohol Syndrome) are seen with heavy, repeated exposure, effects continue to be seen at lower doses.  At this point there is no known threshold below which you see absolutely no effects of alcohol exposure.

At least in the US, the medical community (e.g. American Academy of Pediatrics, American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, Surgeon General of the US, March of Dimes, etc.) is unified in recommending total abstinence.

Of course, every woman needs to make her own informed choice, and moderation may be fine for many women.  But you should at least be aware that there are genuine risks involved.

March 20, 2007 1:45 PM
 

Sheri said:

When I was pregnant many years ago with my first (1989), I asked my OB if I could have one drink for my 21st birthday.  She told me yes and then told me no more.  She said drinking in moderation wouldn't harm the baby, but moderation differs from one person to another.  For one woman, moderation might be 4 glasses of wine a day, for the next, it might be 4 glasses of wine a month.  It was easier to just say--just say no.  

And Renee is right, no one knows just how much alcohol can cause problems.  

I did take communion and went to a wine tasting with my third, but I think I had one taste of wine.  

To each his own, but why risk it.

March 20, 2007 6:14 PM
 

Whit said:

My wife was actually told by the nurse that she should have a small glass of wine at night to relax during the 3rd trimester.

Most women I know have said the same thing.

The people that freak over it are generally men.  We've been beaten with the idea that it is the worst thing a woman can do while pregnant that we go a tad overboard.

Personally I was glad when my wife took the advice, it helped her relax and it didn't make me feel as bad about doing keg stands in the livingroom.

March 20, 2007 10:10 PM
 

Grammy said:

Wow! Times have changed.  When I was pregnant (35 years ago) my doctor told me to have a glass of wine or a beer every single night.  He said this reduced stress in the mom.  I am not a big drinker so I didn't take him up on that but I would have if I had been a drinker.  they also used to tell us that beer was a healthy drink.  Times have changed.

March 21, 2007 3:32 PM
 

Strollerderby said:

Folks in England aren't sure, but they've been telling pregnant women to stay away from them anyway (what

March 21, 2007 9:21 PM
 

Strollerderby said:

Folks in England aren't sure, but they've been telling pregnant women to stay away from them anyway (what

March 22, 2007 10:58 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage