Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Bratz Dolls Make Barbie Look Reasonable

slutty bratz dollA marketing study was released recently that showed that mothers were looking to toymakers to make more wholesome and conservative toys for our little girls. While, I agree with the results, a study done by AG Properties (Care Bears, Strawberry Shortcake etc.) is most likely skewed. (Keep in mind, they also only interviewed mothers, not fathers.)

Mir (from Woulda Coulda Shoulda) wrote a fantastic piece on BlogHer called "Sorry, sweetie... Mommy thinks that doll's too skanky". Mir writes about how she had decided long before she had kids that her children would never own a Barbie, and now she is faced with dolls that make Barbie look wholesome.

Look, we all know Barbie is slutty. I know my Barbie got around. She was always making out with Ken and the Donny Osmond doll that my friend Alison had. I can't even imagine what kind of nastiness these Bratz dolls would get up to, especially now that we have some Misfits action figures (yes, I have a Jerry Only Ken doll).

I was in Target with my niece two weeks ago and she said "My Mommy and Daddy say I can't play with Bratz dolls because they wear too much makeup." I say well played brother. The five year old knows they are inappropriate without having to discuss sleaziness.

Anyway, Mir's post stirred up quite the conversation over on BlogHer. Do Bratz dolls get you riled up too?

 


Comments

 

Grammy said:

I am 50+ and I had one of the first Barbies on the market.  However, I never thought I would look like a Barbie and I never thought she was slutty.  She was a high fashion girl.  We loved them and they did NO shape our idea of what we should be or become.  I think Barbies have changed since I was a kid.  I think the media have turned her into a marketing maniac to attract kids attention.  That is realy too bad.  I do want to say that my Barbie secretly slept with Ken and even got PG by him with a little help from clay.  She had a baby out of wedlock too.  Although I think I married them...

April 16, 2007 11:55 AM
 

RachelZ said:

The Bratz dolls creep me right out.  I refuse to have one in my home and I am hoping against all hope and reason that they go away by the time Jillian is big enough to get one as a gift or, worse - to want one.

I don't think Barbie gave me any kind of body-image complex or made me feel inferior in any way.  In fact, I think maybe having Barbies fed my God-complex and that's why I love my Sims so much now.  I could make Barbie do damn near anything I wanted, and THAT is power.

The Bratz dolls just make me afraid that they're going to come to life one night and run around the house on their stumpy non-footed legs and spell things wrong.

April 16, 2007 1:32 PM
 

Andrea said:

Our child life specialist (she assists kids cope with hospital stuff through play and distraction) REFUSES to give out Bratz dolls as prizes to our patients.  She decided that after she realized that Bratz dolls have thong underwear.  At least Barbie's were molded plastic granny-panties!

April 16, 2007 3:32 PM
 

creative-type dad said:

If somebody gave a Bratz doll to my daughter, I'd send it to rehab.

April 16, 2007 3:45 PM
 

nancy said:

My daughter had one or two when they first came out. She never was obsessed with them and in fact, hardly ever played with them. I don't even know where they are right now (the bottom of a landfill? Perhaps...)

I wonder about the thrill of the forbidden, though...would a kid who was categorically denied a Bratz doll end up coveting them MORE, or is indulging in them a good way to ensure they will be thrown under the bed and forgotten?

April 16, 2007 5:12 PM
 

Suburban Turmoil said:

Eh.  Bratz Schmatz.  We have them and my three-year-old loves to play with them, but only because my stepdaughters loved them when they were 10-12-- and I would've been a total ogress to tell them at that age that they couldn't play with a Bratz doll because they might, you know, want to LOOK like one.  Please.

Now my girls are 13 and 16- We watch the Pussycat Dolls reality show and the Coyote Ugly reality show together sometimes- and talk about what skanks those girls are and how we would NEVER wear that outfit and that makeup and that hairstyle.  And those girls look just like Bratz dolls.  So I think that assuming your child will want to look like a Bratz doll because she plays with one is ridiculous.  I had dozens of Barbies growing up- It never occured to me to try to LOOK like a Barbie.  That would've been weird.

The critical mistake, I think, is happening when moms let their daughters dress like skanks for a dance recital or a modeling class at a Club LibbyLu.  Put the makeup and the gogo outfit on her and that's when the gears will start turning in her little brain.

April 19, 2007 2:36 PM
 

Strollerderby said:

Larry Birkhead pimps his daughter. Barbie has her own car. A real car. And Alec Baldwin ... well, do

April 21, 2007 1:09 PM
 

Strollerderby said:

I'm happy to talk about sex with my kids. Masturbation, penises, vaginas, why Bratz dolls are sluts .

April 23, 2007 1:37 PM
 

Trusted.MD Network said:

It seems to me that the major marketers might be missing something. Yes, they are hell-bent on age-compression, but I'm sensing a change in consumer attitudes. What follows are a list of blog posts, web sites, and reports that indicate...

July 2, 2007 8:05 PM

About Sarah, Goon Squad Sarah

I have three year old twins and a slight football problem. You can always read more about it at Sarahandthegoonsquad.com . That's right. You heard me. All Hail the Hypnotoad!

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • drool.icio.us

    The top million must-have baby products.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage