Strollerderby

Breastfeeding: Cross-Nursing and the Return of the Wet Nurse

Posted by Patti

Breastfeeding's renaissance over the last several years is starting to play out in an interesting way. As parents are bombarded by information that indicates that breastmilk has magical powers, some of them are taking it to a more extreme level and cross-nursing with the babies of family and friends. As the popularity and availability of milk banks rise, so too has the availability of one of the worlds' oldest professions: the wet nurse.

Time Magazine covers this issue in a pretty non-judgmental way, though I suspect their photo of a woman breastfeeding her toddler (shown at right) will probably generate a shitstorm all by itself, never mind how the idea of women breastfeeding other people's babies is going to play out in middle America.

I'd have done it. It never came up in my circle of friends, but if it had, I wouldn't have batted an eyelash. I can think of five or six people whose babies I'd have cheerfully nursed, and who I'd have allowed to feed my babies without any compunction. And now those five or six women are out there reading this and either thinking "Ew!" or "Aw!", and I couldn't begin to tell you who's thinking which. But I'm not particularly brainwashed by the idea that breastmilk is the end-all, be-all of nutrition. I just really liked breastfeeding, and I particularly enjoyed the feeling of connection it brought my children and I. Cross-nursing a friend's child wouldn't have brought me any closer to their family, but it would have been a totally appropriate symbol of a closeness that already existed. And seriously, I was good enough at it that if I'd realized there was a possibility to do it for a living, only the restrictions on my cocktail intake would have stopped me.

If you missed it, check out Jennifer Baumgardner's sweet essay about cross-nursing published recently in Babble.


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Alisyn said:

Agreed.  I can think of several friends' babies I would have nursed - and several who I would've been totally comfortable allowing to nurse my own babies.  I love the idea of cross-nursing, and wish I'd had the opportunity to do it.  

April 23, 2007 3:50 PM
 

JulieT said:

I don't know--it just seems icky, although I couldn't really specify why.

April 23, 2007 4:01 PM
 

Taylor said:

All the cross-nursers I know are in middle America ... so, look out for sweeping generalizations!

April 23, 2007 5:01 PM
 

Patti said:

Perhaps I should have said "mainstream America", as I meant to imply a cultural location, not a geographical one.

April 23, 2007 5:04 PM
 

danish said:

I nursed my cousin's baby (she is 2 days older than my baby) because I was babysitting one afternooon, and she was fighting the bottle, and screaming her head off.

My husband took our baby out of the room.  I felt really weird, as if I was cheating.    But the poor girl was starving.  I figured, they did it in the old ages, and we are blood relatives.

My cousin didnt mind, in fact, she was grateful.  But somehow if she had done that for my son, it would have squicked me out.  Go figure.

April 23, 2007 5:13 PM
 

Molly said:

Come on!  We drink milk from cows for christ's sake!  I think that's much more disgusting than having our children 'share' breast milk.  I'd have no problem with someone I knew nursing my daughter and I'd be comfortable nursing other children other than my own.  I see this becoming much more of a norm in another decade or so.  

April 23, 2007 8:28 PM
 

Melanie said:

I would have loved to have helped out other moms like that - I had tons of milk and nursing came really easy to me and my son.  I loved breastfeeding, and I was sad when I had to stop (medication reasons).

April 23, 2007 9:18 PM
 

Naomi said:

There was a lawsuit in Australia some years ago when a woman discovered another mother had breastfed her child  (without permission).  

Ditto on the last post -- in the early newborn days I was terribly engorged, had waaaay too much milk, and would have welcomed another child to help me out a bit. Pumping just isn't as efficient. I remember looking at my three-year-old and thinking, "I wonder if she would remember how?  Nah...."

April 24, 2007 7:37 AM
 

Lisa K said:

My sister nursed my son when I returned to work after six months leave.  He had been premature and wouldn't take a bottle, and she was nursing her daughter as well. I don't know why we were at first embarrassed to let others know; but learned that other family members had done the same.  I owe my sister a lot; my son thrived and grew to healthy proportions, and has such a close bond with his Auntie, his "mommy-Tina".

And, No, we're not middle Americans.  

April 24, 2007 12:07 PM
 

erin said:

I think it is wonderful that your sister could help your baby Lisa!  That is great that it worked out.

I always have too much milk and I gave all of my frozen pumped milk to someone who didn't produce enough milk for her baby.  She was grateful to be able to supplement with breastmilk.  Then later when I had a problem with yeast and thrush in my baby, I realized I shouldn't share my milk any more.  You just have to be careful!  I know that milk banks won't accept donations if you have even had a tylenol in the last 8 hrs.  and they pasteurize the milk and everything.  probably kills all those good antibodies!

April 24, 2007 5:25 PM

About Patti

Visit my personal blog at childbearinghipster.com

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage