Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Are "Kids" Animated Films Getting Too Grown-Up?

Posted by Alisyn

Shrek 3, Meet the Robinsons, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Ratatouille - those are the names of just a few of the animated movies slated for release this spring/early summer, and honestly, I wouldn't consider taking my child to one of them.  While the slick animation and colorful characters might hold her attention for a few minutes, I know most of the plot would go right over her head, the innuendo would be lost on her, and she would be trying to crawl back into my uterus every time the villain came on screen - there's always a villain. The movie ads and promotional tie-ins follow us everywhere,  whether we're at Target, driving past (okay, through) a McDonalds, or browsing in the bookstore.  We're supposed to want to see the movie - we get it. 

I know how it works; I know that "kids" movies have to appeal to the adults accompanying them to the theater on some level, or they wouldn't do well - but when did attracting mature viewers become the focus of the the youth movie machine?  And what does that mean for kids? 

Well, it means they're exposed to mature-themes situations like, violence (Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles), subtle drug references (Shrek 3), sexual innuendo (Ratatouille), and child abandonment (Meet the Robinsons), for one thing.  I guess that's cool.  Some may argue that they'll learn about those things sooner or later, which is true.  But why explain Mr. Incredible's mid-life crisis and implied infidelity to your 4-year old over a $5 bag of popcorn?  Why take little Billy to a movie you know he's not going to fully understand or enjoy, since the eeeeeeeeeeeevil adversary scares the living shit out of him every time he slinks into the frame?  Why not wait until little Susie hits kindergarten before she has to wrap her head why Lightening McQueen's is freaking out over his lack of corporate sponsorship?

I understand the need and desire to chill out at the movie theater with the kids.  It's nice to have that kind of quiet time together, and the exciting anticipation of the film's release makes the night you finally go to see it together really special .  And some kids really do like and "get" the plot lines - in my experience it's been the older, slightly more mature grade schoolers.  I fantasize about the time when our whole family can hit the town for dinner and a film that everyone understands and enjoys.  I'm hoping that Disney Fairies movie will be watchable for the under 6 set, but word is there's a violent, destructive hurricane, and a scary dragon.  Sigh

How do your kids react to the animated films in theaters today?  Is your family first in line at the theater for a new release, or do you steer your kids clear of the "kids" movies they're supposed to like?  Have you been able to find a middle ground when your kid wants to see a movie you don't think is appropriate for them?  Have you taken you little one to a "kids" movie, only to have to leave half-way through?
 


Comments

 

crunchy said:

Unless it is something I reeeeeelly want to see, I tend to wait a bit....I also tend to wait till they hit dvd.

I like to see what the real buzz is on the shows...but I also base it on my kids reaction to the trailers.

May 19, 2007 11:48 AM
 

doodaddy said:

Is this anything all that new, though? Abusive wicked stepmothers, an fawn orphaned by a horrific fire, Zsa-Zsa Gabor as a mouse: a lot of classic "kids" films have pretty adult images and themes.

The blatant scary stuff worries me a lot less than the insidious messages in most of today's animated features: thin-waisted, large-busted "princesses" who seek happiness by landing a handsome prince. There are precious few "hero's journey" stories, and most (all?) of those are centered around men.

Plus, most of the new digital stuff is such crap. *cough that sounds like "Magagascar"*

Dd.

May 19, 2007 1:41 PM
 

STL Mom said:

My daughter (age 6) spent half of "Over the Hedge" in my lap because she was scared that the bear would eat the little animals.  However, at home, on the small screen, she happily watches all sorts of superhero shows (Justice League, Teen Titans, Batman) without fear, and she has even watched some PG 13 movies with her dad (i.e. Spiderman).  Being in a movie theater seems to make a movie especially intense.  

When is Miyazaki making another movie?  We've practically worn out our DVDs of "Kiki's Delivery Service", "Spirited Away" and "My Neighbor Totoro".  Now those are movies that kids and adults can enjoy together.

May 19, 2007 10:04 PM
 

Alisyn said:

Miyazaki is big in our house, too!  Have you watched 'Whisper of the Heart,' 'Howl's Moving Castle,' or 'Princess Mononoke'?  Sounds like your daughter would be able to handle the more mature ones like Nausicaa, Porco Rosso and Castle in the Sky, too.  

A new one is scheduled for theater release in 2008.  Woo hoo!

May 19, 2007 11:16 PM
 

Anne said:

Amen!  This is a huge pet peeve of mine with kids' movies.  All my 3.5 year old wanted out of Curious George was monkey antics, for pete's sake.  Heck, it's all I wanted out of the movie -- I certainly didn't want to try to field questions about office politics, which is what I got from her.  

We're a big Miyazaki house too, because of the wonderful stories and themes and because they actually have -- gasp! -- girls! as lead characters!  who aren't princesses!  Who knew it was possible?

And I do think that the more classic fairy tale bad guys are different, although we're also avoiding those movies until she's a little older too.  I don't know what I think the difference is, though.  Maybe they're just more one-dimensional?  And less visually scary?    

May 21, 2007 6:13 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • drool.icio.us

    The top million must-have baby products.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage