Strollerderby

Kids are Fat Because of...Politeness?

Posted by Karen Murphy

fat kidBack when we were kids, the "fat kid" was the exception. And unless the "fat kid" was also the "smart kid" or the "funny kid", he was also the kid with no friends. Which is a lot of peer pressure on any kid. And likely it either made those fat kids slim down eventually or go into therapy (or both). Was that a better system, in the end, than the acceptance and political-correctness we have now? In other words, did teasing create healthier kids?

Today, there is safety in numbers. Increasingly sedentary, kids today are fatter than in previous decades, and they have plenty of supersized adult role models to look to. Fatness, despite our constant cultural striving for thinness, has become far closer to the norm than ever. "It’s interesting ... that whereas being overweight was once socially risky, now it’s more or less just one of the norms of student life."

Not that I'm necessarily suggesting that we encourage our kids to get all Lord of the Flies and reduce their fatter members to puddles of blubbering blubber, but what about it, really? If kids (and parents) knew there was a steeper social price to pay for scarfing down a steady diet of Doritos and Twinkies, would they start to think more carefully about lifestyle choices? Could a whole social revolution begin right in the classroom, when just-teased kids go home and demand a change?

Or would that just set kids up for a lifetime of perceived failure and ridicule? 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Lion and Magic Boy » Blog Archive » it's all in the hips said:

Pingback from  Lion and Magic Boy  » Blog Archive   » it's all in the hips

October 8, 2007 9:27 AM
 

Kate said:

Uh... as someone who was one of the fat kids (also a smart and funny kid, but it's extremely difficult to get young people to look past the outside...), peer pressure did little other than to make me feel like the world is a crappy, horrible place full of crappy, horrible people.  

Once I got to high school, and was finally in an environment where people valued my intellect over my appearance, I lost a ton of weight.  So to answer your question- NO.  It does not make kids slim down when they are the victim of horrible teasing.  

I don't know a single child who is fat because they want to be fat, or because they think it's fun to be fat because others in their class are fat.  And while I was the fat kid, I was not so because I was sedentary or because I (how did you put it?) "scarf[ed] down a steady diet of Doritos and Twinkies".

I knew that there was a steep social price to pay, and it didn't make me think, "Hmm,  I should ride my bicycle for three hours instead of two everyday so that I will be thinner." or "I should quit eating dinner, too (since I already don't eat lunch because I'm embarrased to eat in front of my classmates, and I don't eat breakfast because I wake up sick to my stomach, dreading going to school), so that I can lose weight."  I thought, "WTF is wrong with this world?  I'm a sweet, nice, funny, active, smart kid stuck in school with a bunch of jerks who make fun of me for something that is virtually out of my control."  

Eesh.  This was really hard to read.  Sad.  Really, really sad.    

October 9, 2007 2:38 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage