Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Weekly Check-Up: Did Your Family History Give You Second Thoughts About a Family?

Posted by Kelly Mills

genesLast week I was in a dressing room, and I overheard the salesperson in the next room talking to a customer. (What? No, I wasn't spying, they were talking loud and I was trying to distract myself from the fiasco that is trying on bras.) The salesperson was talking about her grown daughter, who struggled with drug addiction. "After she went into rehab I learned it can be genetic and skip generations," she told the other woman. "My mom was an alcoholic, but I'm not. If I had known about the genetics I never would have had children." "Oh, you don't mean that," clucked the woman. "Oh yes I do." said the salesperson firmly. 

I've been thinking about this ever since. Nowadays the nature versus nurture debate has morphed into something that recognizes the two factors--genes and environment--are utterly intertwined. And this issue hit home because, well, in addition to wide feet and fine hair, alcoholism and about 17 different mental illnesses (depression is the biggie) run in my family. Oh, and alcoholism and depression also run in my husband's family. That's a mean genetic cocktail.

I thought about this before I got pregnant, but obviously it didn't deter me, perhaps because I've managed my own manifestations of these things. But it worries me for my child. Often. 

So now I'm wondering if anyone else paused before procreating because of what they could pass on, and how people manage the concern once the die has been cast.  


Comments

 

LeighS said:

I have a friend that deliberately chose not to have children because she feared they would inheirit her mother's extreme mental illness. But I would guess that all families have a hideous medical history somewhere along the line and sometimes I think you have to take a little leap of faith. If anything, awareness of a potential problem can lead to seeking help earlier.

October 25, 2007 8:58 AM
 

Claire said:

The genetic diseases ARE frightening, perhaps most so the ones which science does not currently have any plan of action. My mother watched her own mother die a slow, confused death from Alzheimer's. My grandmother ceased to recognize her gradndchildren, her own children, and eventually the language which she had spoken for the last seventy years, reverting in her final year back to her childhood languages of Canadian French and Yiddish.

The thought of watching my own mother go through this, as she almost inevitably will in fifteen to twenty years, gives me great pause. The hope for MY children is that science will have found a solution to save them this pain with me.

My own mother has (as the previous poster suggested) preemptively gotten nursing home insurance, assuming she could need ten years of care or more, and continues to push herself to learn new skills (she just graduated from business school at the age of 58) to delay the onset of the disease.

October 25, 2007 9:16 AM
 

clip59 » Weekly Check-Up: Did Your Family History Give You Second Thoughts … said:

Pingback from  clip59 » Weekly Check-Up: Did Your Family History Give You Second Thoughts …

October 25, 2007 11:36 AM
 

Jennifer said:

Yes, genetic history is one of the reasons we chose adoption.

October 25, 2007 7:45 PM
 

Larissa said:

My mother's side of the family is riddled with alcoholism and gambling addition.  My mom herself is a textbook adult child of an alcoholic.  My father's side is no picture of positive mental health.  Both my brothers have off the charts ADD (do I, who knows?  Girls don't get tested as frequently...)

My journey to motherhood was a deliberate act of healing.  I realize that there are risks for my kids given the family histories on both sides (my husband has diabetes, depression & deaths from heart disease in his background).  

However, my life has been an object lesson in the cycle of abuse & dysfunction - I spent my childhood miserable, my adolescence repeating the mistakes, my early adulthood scared by the fact that it was so easy & automatic for me to do that and my married life (the last 10 years) have been an act of deliberate growth, healing and flourishing.

My kids will be at risk for the same foibles my and my husband's families were prone to.  But if we can be open and forthright with them about the risks, model healthy relationships and coping strategies and keep ourselves plugged into their lives as they grow, hopefully we can mitigate any "nature" flaws with "nurture" strengths.

October 25, 2007 8:08 PM
 

Mom2Two said:

If we were at risk for serious genetic diseases like cystic fibrosis or those sort of defects that are almost always fatal at an early age, yes, we would take that into consideration.  But a family history of alcoholism or drug use isn't a strong enough reason, to me, to not have children.  As the poster above me said, it's possible to model healthy lifestyles and hopefully block those sort of addictions from ever happening.

October 25, 2007 8:24 PM
 

Weekly Check-Up: Did Your Family History Give You Second Thoughts … | hgdomain-names said:

Pingback from  Weekly Check-Up: Did Your Family History Give You Second Thoughts … | hgdomain-names

October 26, 2007 8:58 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • drool.icio.us

    The top million must-have baby products.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage