Strollerderby

Keeping Twins Together Can Be Good, Group Says

Posted by Amy Kuras

 Parents of twins or other multiples have a lot to deal with – between fending off annoying questions from the well-meaning but curious ("Are those triplets? Did you use drugs?" from random strangers) to the very real issues of parenting two or more little people who are the same age but otherwise distinctly different people.
One big issue is the idea of mandatory separation in schools. Many districts require that multiples be in separate classes, as a way to reinforce their individuality and reduce the "exotic" factor that still comes with twins and can distract everybody.

However, there are lots of parents who are not too into the idea. Many of them say that theirs kids have never been separated, and that the strong bond they have makes them  happier in school and should be honored. A New York mother, Kathy Dolan, founded the website TwinsLaw.com in 2006 after fighting to keep her own twins together in school. They've worked in 15 states for legislation to allow parents, not school administrators or teachers, to have the final say about whether their children are kept together or apart. Massachusetts is the latest to weigh legislation, and laws have been passed in Minnesota, Texas, Georgia and New Hampshire.

This article from the Boulder Daily Camera discusses the issue  in a rather more balanced way. Some kids love being with their sibs,while some were thrilled to make their own friends.

 My college roommate has triplets, and reports that now that the kids are 10 and in fourth grade everybody at their school has kind of gotten over" the triplets factor sand they are able to just be who they are instead of being "one of the triplets." All three kids have been in different classes year to year.
Do you have multiples? Would you like them to be together in school or apart?


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

corina said:

I have an 8 year old and 20 mth old twins. My twins are same sex fraternal so I don't feel the same "pressure" that the parents of identical twins might feel to encourage individuality.They couldn't already be more different. I don't believe that separating twins is a good idea when they first start school. School is a challenging transition and to lose your lifelong constant companion at the same time, would be quite traumatic.  I believe that whether or not to separate siblings should be decided on a case by case basis, primarily by the parents with the input of the teachers. As long as my children are doing well academically and emotionally, I would prefer them to be in the same  class for the first 1-3 years of school because of the practicalities....I am hoping to catch a break!LOL

December 5, 2007 10:59 PM
 

catem said:

My twins are also same sex fraternal girls that are 20 months' old and look/act nothing alike, too...and I agree about keeping them together, at least in the beginning or until it's clear that separation would be better.  Bottom line, I second the "parent's choice" vote.

ps - these days twins are not such the novelty as there are so many, so perhaps it's not as "exotic" as it once was.

December 6, 2007 2:07 AM
 

leigh said:

my twins are turning 5 today and they are identical. we live in nc. and i think it would be good to keep them together because my littlest one looks up to her sister and gets nervous when she's not there..

December 6, 2007 7:50 AM
 

kristen said:

I have boy/girl twins who are in preschool.  We'd like to keep them in the same class for at least the first few years of school.  They are very different personality-wise, but definitely draw comfort from being able to look across the room and see each other.  This probably is more of an issue for those of you with identical twins, although our twins are the only twins in their entire school, which is pre-K thru 5th grade.  Many teachers and students just say, "Good morning, twins!", and we have to ask them to call them by name, which I think is a problem.

Ultimately, I think it should be up to the parents to make this call, as we know them best.  Most parents do want to encourage independence in our multiples, but it should be on our terms, when we feel it won't be detrimental to their growing process.  

December 6, 2007 10:39 AM
 

rebecca said:

I guess everyone's experiences are different.  I am an identical twin and I am forever grateful that our parents insisted that we be placed in different classes, had different hair styles and were never dressed the same.  I believe that it helped us to develop our own, unique identities and interests.  Twins often have problems with social integration (this is still something I struggle with, and I'm almost 30!), and it would have been even more difficult to suddenly have to act as separate individuals upon entering the adult world without some earlier experience with boundaries and sense of individuality -- I cannot even imagine the trauma of suddenly going off to separate colleges, working at different jobs or moving in with a partner if there had been no physical and intellectual separation before that point.  

December 6, 2007 10:50 AM
 

Valorie Delp said:

My twins are same sex fraternal twins who look and act pretty similar--yet are of course unique as well.  We homeschool so it's really not an issue but I really feel that this is a decision best left to parents.  I don't think that there is ever a one size fits all prescription in situations like these.  To say one decision over the other is better for all twins is fool hearty IMO.  

But as a parent of both singletons and twins, I can say that the bond the twins share is entirely unique to being twins.  They are socially, completely different than their siblings were/are in terms of their ability to relate and empathize with one another. Their bond is unique unto themselves and while they're close to their siblings it's different.  

They are happy to be together and they are happy to be seperated actually. . .depending on the activity. . .but I always leave it up to them.  I think for us, forcing them to be seperate just for the sake of being seperate wouldn't serve them well.

This is btw, a great article! ;-)  

December 6, 2007 11:41 AM
 

Mom2Two said:

It wasn't that long ago that the celebs in the photo requested they be called Mary-Kate and Ashley instead of 'the Olson twins' because they are two unique people and should be treated as such.

I don't have twins, but I agree with those who think it should be a decision made on a case by case basis.

December 6, 2007 1:19 PM
 

Alisa said:

I think my twin actually posted above thread :)

I am also very thankful that we were allowed to develop at our own speeds and in separate spaces as children. And even though we live completely different adult lives, we speak almost every day and live only blocks apart from each other. Our bond was not disturbed by encouraging our unique personalities.  

December 7, 2007 11:48 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage