Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Couple Who Adopted Girl Wants to Give Her Back

Posted by Madeline Holler

Some decisions are irreversible: amputation, for example, or gambling away an entire paycheck. Oh, and adoption.

But a Dutch family living in Hong Kong doesn’t seem to think so. They are working to give back the Korean-born daughter they adopted seven years ago when she was four months old.

The reason?

By their estimation, the girl isn’t fitting in with their lifestyle.

The father, a diplomat, and his wife, who adopted the girl after failing to conceive, handed over the girl to Hong Kong social workers last year. The family, which now includes two biological children, has lived in Hong Kong since the girl was three. The couple claims the girl was struggling to adapt to their culture, including food.

The girl has been in foster care in Hong Kong for a year, while social workers search for a permanent home for her. The territory’s Korean community wants her with them, but the girl doesn’t speak Korean – she speaks English and Cantonese. And this is where I get confused. The article doesn’t mention whether she speaks Dutch, which is presumably the language her adoptive/abandonive family speaks. Also, the girl is neither a Dutch citizen, nor a Hong Kong resident. So, was she adopted officially or not? This all seems messed up.

However, before you get all outraged and judgy, know that this has been hard on the couple. The diplomat is struggling to cope with their decision and .... his wife was having therapy.

"It's just a very terrible trauma that everyone's experiencing" the father says. Um, yes!

There has to be more to this than a kid who won’t eat Gouda cheese and wear wooden shoes. What, though, I have no idea.


Comments

 

Lisa said:

I'm sorry, but don't most kids have difficulty adapting to their parent's culture and food.  Sheeesh!  What? They've never met a kid who eats only chicken nuggets (and not ones stuck together or touching any other food dammit) and certain fruit (again, sliced just so and not touching anything else).  

the one that's going to need therapy is this little girl.  My heart breaks for her.  And I thought for sure this would be about an American family.  I guess the Dutch can be jerks too.  

December 11, 2007 2:58 PM
 

Meg said:

This makes me absolutely sick.  It really sounds like the problem is that the parents don't like her not matching their perfect family, not her dislike of clogs.  Poor little girl.  I can only imagine how lost and unsure she is.  

December 11, 2007 3:51 PM
 

anonymous said:

I'm afraid this says it all: "The father, a diplomat, and his wife, who adopted the girl after FAILING TO CONCEIVE, handed over the girl to Hong Kong social workers last year. The family, WHICH NOW INCLUDES TWO BIOLOGICAL CHILDREN... "

Guess they don't need the backup anymore. Assholes.

December 11, 2007 4:27 PM
 

PAgent said:

This pretty much makes me sick to my stomach.

December 11, 2007 5:21 PM
 

Jackie said:

I'm just speechless. And I have to wonder, given the political controversy surrounding international adoption - Guatemala closing its doors, Vietnam-US visa problems, and the bitter Russian editorials after several adopted Russian children were harmed by their American families in recent years - what impact is this going to have for families struggling to adopt overseas now and in years to come?

Jackie

aPARENTly Speaking, www.ibabuzz.com/aparentlyspeaking/

December 11, 2007 6:11 PM
 

friskycat01 said:

What selfish assholes! And if they have had her since 4 months then she should be acclimated to their family (and their food?!). Not that that makes a difference in the fact that these are horrible people. Obviously they were just bad parents and they blamed the poor girl for not fitting in. I bet they would shove their biological children back in the womb if they could.

December 11, 2007 11:50 PM
 

HDCS said:

Since when is this an option?? Well, I'm just glad to have proof that Americans don't hold the monopoly on pure, unadulterated douchebaggery any more.

December 12, 2007 2:34 AM
 

GetMoreAbortions said:

When are people going to take the biological hint that if they can't conceive, it is clearly because they are not cut out to be parents?

December 12, 2007 10:27 AM
 

alisonica said:

The most recent issue of Newsweek talks about adoptive parents  whose children have some serious problems and how they are unprepared to deal with them (problems stemming from abuse the children experienced with their birth parents and/or in the orphanages). So if I had read this yesterday, I would have been outraged, sickened, and agreeing with all the commenters that these people have shown themselves to be selfish assholes, today I want to know more before passing judgment. Better that they give this girl up if the alternative is they abuse her and kill her in a moment of rage (as did the women profiled in Newsweek).

I'm not saying this is right, I'm just saying there has to be more to this story than just "she doesn't like tulips."

December 12, 2007 6:01 PM
 

CC said:

This happened to a friend of mine.

Her first set of adoptive parents gave her back to the agency because she was "too ugly". It really says that in her file.

How selfish can people get?

December 12, 2007 7:09 PM
 

Autumn said:

I really do not think that they would disrupt for frivolous reasons.  For all we know the child is psychotic or has harmed the other children.  What I do know from being a member of the adoption community is in every case of adotion disruption it is the best for the child.  If they parents do not want them they need to be placed with parents who do want them.  It is much worse to be raised by people who do not love you.  With some luck this child will find her real family at last.

December 12, 2007 9:55 PM
 

a said:

Family's former Indonesian servant who raised the girl told a British media that the girl was a "normal girl".  This girl was just flat out neglected, and now the parents are blaming her.  

December 14, 2007 10:19 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage