Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

In Defense of Judgmental Mothers

Posted by Madeline Holler

She takes a lot of crap, Judgmental Mother. Or maybe you know her as Sanctimommy or, more generically, “that asshole who offered unsolicited parenting advice.”

Andi over at “Poot and Cubby” (would it be judgmental to say that blog name makes me shudder?), calls Judgmental Mother “HOB” -- Hateful, Opinionated Bitch or, alternately, Horribly Obnoxious Bitch. And Andi runs in to HOB everywhere. Understandably, Andi thinks she's a real menace.

Not only does HOB judge Andi for dressing her child too warmly (typical HOB), she thinks the baby is going to fall out of the sling (typical aging HOB). I don’t need to recount the details, because you have your own experiences with the gal (or, sometimes, guy). We all do.

For me, she told me my baby would suffocate in a sling, while I strolled through the airport; he said that my 1-year-old needed shoes (didn’t notice the double-layer of socks) one cold spring day in D.C. She proclaimed my 2-year-old ready to use the potty (I was changing her diaper at the science center), and that I shouldn’t highlight a 4-year-old’s hair (we don’t. Good genes.)

I seethed about these incidents loooooong after they happened. (And for any of you who had to hear my rant – real sorry. I must have seemed a tad defensive.) But that was then. I’m sure I’ve been HOBed loads since, but somewhere along the line, it stopped bothering me. And I actually think – from a much broader perspective – is kind of cool if not a little misdirected.

Recently, a parent at my daughter’s preschool cried, “oh, aren’t you chilly!” to my toddler, who was wearing a skirt without tights and quite possibly a short-sleeved shirt. In  December, sure, but it’s Los Angeles County. She’s a cold-weather kid by heritage, so 67 degrees doesn’t merit the parka and multiple layers of her native peers. Anyway, the morning shirt battle is one we stopped waging months ago so if it's February and you see spaghetti straps, you'll understand. In any case, I smiled at the lady and signed my daughter in.

I’m pretty sure I would have been savagely pissed off at the self-badged sweater cop had this happened early in my mothering career. But I gotta tell you. Right now? Nearly 7 years and two kids into it? I could give a shit less. In fact, I’m oddly comforted.

So the lady had never seen a bare-legged kid withstand Southern California's punishing winter weather. She spoke up! I kind of like that. Maybe she’ll speak up too if she sees something shitty going on at that preschool (which, except for drop-off hours and monthly tuition, I know soooo little about). Maybe she’ll look out for my kid in other situations, not just wardrobe ones, like if a teacher is mean to her or if she’s pissed herself and not immediately changed.

A person who butts into someone’s business regarding socks or slings or snowsuits – or breastfeeding or immunizations or signs of autism -- would certainly say something to a parent slapping around kids at the mall. It takes a loud-mouthed, judgmental, butting-in type to want to call someone out on a perceived danger with the big stuff. Sometimes (often?), they’re going to cross a line in the smaller, none-of-their-business stuff too.

I’d rather cheer on the one and just smile ignore the other. I'm not saying we should usher them in as True American Heroes. I'm just saying there is something good below all that undermining. So I won't let it get to me. I've got enough to make me angry. You know, like my kids.


Comments

 

anonymous said:

I'll respect someone willing to step in when they see a parent doing something dangerous or illegal. But someone who tells me my son has autism when he's doing his zombie face? Can suck it. Someone who tells me my kid isn't dressed warmly enough when he's a furnace like my husband? Can suck it. Someone who tells me I ought to stop breastfeeding already? Can eat my ass. And I'm going to say so. Does no one's mother teach them basic manners anymore? (Not that my responses are polite, but...) Because I think it's rude as hell to offer unsolicited advice to a stranger who doesn't look like she needs your help. I didn't realize until I became a parent how many people are out there for whom it is a personal mission to share their wisdom. "I know better!" they seem to think. "I MUST share!" Share somewhere else.

January 15, 2008 12:46 PM
 

andi said:

Hey, thanks for the link.  Sorry the blog name made you shudder - it's how my daughter used to say "Poop and Cookies" and back when I started my blog it seemed like that was pretty much the summary of motherhood for me.

I generally don't have much of a response when people offer me assvice, but for some reason this particular situation really bothered me.  I guess I'm still taken aback that strangers still find it necessary to say things to mothers that are none of their business.  Like the commenter above, I would totally understand someone saying something about a child in a life-threatening situation, but if it's something trivial it would be awesome if they would just keep their Judgy McJudgerson comments to themselves.

January 15, 2008 2:54 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • drool.icio.us

    The top million must-have baby products.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage