Strollerderby

The "Lindsay Lohan of Scrapbooking"

Posted by Adrienne Martini

Who knew that the land of croppin' moms had an unseemly underbelly? 

The scrapbook makes her life look so gosh-darned beautiful, what with all of the die-cuts and journals and sepia-toned baby snapshots, that it's hard to believe that there might be undercurrents of whiney judgementalness.

Eh, not really. It seems that anywhere that women gather -- and I say this as a woman, mind you -- there is bound to be a little bit of holier-than-thouness. Just look at Strollerderby's own recent bout with the petty tyranny of the perfect mom

But still - scrapbooking? Is there a more benign and bland hobby?

Turns out, there's a whole roiling undercurrent of nastiness that 20-something scrapbooker Kristina Contes stepped into when she entered some of her pages -- like the one at right photographed by Carolyn Cole -- in a contest. Coe admits that she did inadvertently break a rule of the event but what followed got nasty. Some comments about her work ranged from  "my 4 y.o. does better with stickers" to "after you have viewed her work you know she has no class."

Nice.

It's nice to know that even scrapbookers get their panties in a wad, isn't it? Or isn't it? 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Sheri said:

I scrapbook.  I'm not a scrapbook      or anything.  I like the idea of leaving something sweet for my kids when they get older.  They love looking at their "books" and one hopefully they will appreciate their mom's "benign and bland hobby."  I cross stitch too.  

What kind of hobby would you suggest for a 40 yo mom with 3 kids (ages 18,3 and 5 years)????  Skydiving???  Underwater basket weaving????  Urban car surfing????

January 19, 2008 1:42 PM
 

Adrienne Martini said:

I cross stitch, too, and knit. As much as I enjoy them, they are fairly benign hobbies. I've never had a knitting rumble or smack-down like the scrapbooking world seems to have directed at Contes and other younger scrapbookers who they feel are doing it wrong. So in that way, yeah, cross stitch and knitting are fairly bland, too.

Now, if you want to skydive or weave underwater baskets or surf on city cars, knock yourself out. But I think your hobbies are great for you - even if I don't understand all the hoo-ha over Contes and think that it's kinda silly.

January 19, 2008 3:14 PM
 

Tokyo Rose said:

Why is a hobby like this "bland"?  Because it doesn't involve high speeds or crash helmets or exotic places or fights or peril (aside from papercuts)?  Or because it's the domain of women and associated with married women with children who stay home and raise kids?  Could it be that it's not the hobby that's bland and benign, but our perception of the supposed majority of its devotees?  Is someone perhaps a little dismayed with her lot in life and projecting a value judgement onto a pastime that is not really inherently one thing or another?

I scrapbook.  I've done it since college, and I'm not that far out of college.  I'm not married and don't intend to be any time soon, and I don't have kids.  My mother and I go through old photos and she tells me stories, and my father helps me with layouts.  We often wind up throwing paper clips at each other and laughing hard enough to have to put the scissors down.  I also do competitive ballroom and social dance, and I go hiking in the Sierras and visit Asia and sing dreadful karaoke and break hearts right, left and center.  Nothing bland or benign about any of that, is there?

January 20, 2008 12:33 PM
 

Tokyo Rose said:

PS: I listen to "This American Life" archived podcasts while I scrapbook, so that I have something interesting to say when I'm finished.  That way no one can tell me my brain is in atrophy mode when I sit down at my scrap table.

January 20, 2008 12:40 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage