Strollerderby

Is TV Bad For Kids??

Posted by Cole Gamble
BabyTV.jpgWe all do it, let our kids watch TV.  Well, accept you Amish, with your luxurious quilts, delicious fried chicken and inability to read these very words.  Sure, we limit the kids to Noggin and Sprout, but I think most parents still wonder what effect that television watching is having. Yeah, the value of Baby Einstein, for instance, is not quite as advertised. But is it all really bad for baby? Well now the results are in… I do like how this article begins, “Here's an issue your parents never had to consider: the great babies-and-TV debate.” Was I born during the depression? Did my parents have to curb my “radio fever” as I glued my ear to the crystal set for new episodes of “The Shadow”?  Maybe the author means parents didn’t have to debate it back then because in the seventies parents were just jerks. The particulars of this piece, and whether or not TV will rot your child, boil down to this:  Kids under 2 won’t learn a thing. If you’re pumping them full of “educational” shows, you’re just spinning your wheels.  TV won’t hurt them either.  Granted, all things in moderation, but there is no evidence that TV will cook your child’s brain.  It’s for you, not for them.  You are not doing the kids a big favor by popping in a DVD while you pop a tranquilizer.  Pacifying the kids on Dora is all about you, so be honest with yourself.  The part I found most interesting was the section on background TV and how it may affect attention spans.  Throughout my entire childhood there was always a TV on.  Even now when I go to my dad’s house for dinner the TV is playing right over my shoulder.  When I have chores around the house, I often turn on the TV like other people put on music.  Now and then I catch myself in the act and feel and it’s rather sad.  I have what I consider a low ability to concentrate, and though this anecdotal evidence isn’t a smoking gun, I wonder what effect all that ambient TV had on me.  At the very least, I think a constantly blaring TV could be distracting a child from more imaginative play. What do you think? Is your TV on morning, noon and night?  Are your kids addicted?      

 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

LeighS said:

Actually, many people out there, myself included, DON'T let their children watch TV at all, in fact, we don't even own one. But I fully agree with you: it IS all about the parents. And maybe that's OK. But people have to assuage thier guilt somehow, so what better way than trying to rationalize something with the all-powerful promise of being smarter? Does it help get dinner on the table? Maybe, in fact, probably! But Sesame Street does not teach your kid to love books, it teacher him or her to love TV. And it is "except the Amish" not "accept the Amish" in your second sentence.

March 12, 2008 12:01 PM
 

bookmama said:

I'm Amish because I don't allow my child to watch tv? I take "acception" (haha) to that.

March 12, 2008 12:21 PM
 

mcglory13 said:

Yep, Amish here too. Glad they apparently made an acception for the internet (just trying to see how many puns with that we can work in before it's corrected).

March 12, 2008 1:09 PM
 

Crazy Baby Lady said:

I will admit ours is always on as background noise though the kids barely pay attention to it. I just can't stand the quiet. And i am totally willing to admit it's all for me.

The tv does go off for meals, during naps, and story time. otherwise it is on.

March 13, 2008 1:59 AM
 

stephanie said:

My 20 month old shows absolutely no interest in any TV other than the 2 signing DVDs we have. Baby Einstein leaves her cold, but she'll watch the signing DVDs every day. I have to say I disagree that she can't learn anything from TV--she has and uses more than 2 dozen signs she learned primarily from these DVDs. It's great for her, and us, that she can communicate more than she would be able to otherwise, as she hasn't started speaking yet.

There have definitely been times when I wish she'd watch more TV!

March 13, 2008 7:15 AM
 

AllisonWonder said:

LeighS- thank you. I was going to say something about the accept/except thing, but I didn't want to be the only one.

March 13, 2008 10:50 AM
 

Amanda said:

I'm not sure what was meant by "You are not doing the kids a big favor by popping in a DVD while you pop a tranquilizer."  but I found it to be somewhat offending. My daughter is 5 months old and YES I do let her watch TV..( while i get her food ready, etc. just because you let ur kid watch tv doesn't make you an irresponsible parent nor a drug addict.)and at this stage of her life she easily gets bored with stuff...making it complicated to get anything else done if she's not occupied...I personally won't let her watch DORA or DIEGO because spanish is not in our culture and i don't want her speaking to me in spanish and I not have a clue what she's saying. I know schools/colleges require it... but I'll be taking that up with the schoolboard when she starts school... If i dont homeschool.... but anywayz... she loves to watch Winnie the Pooh, Carebears, and anything with dogs, or lots of colors.. I don't let her sit infront of the TV all day, and when no ones watching TV.. it's turned off..

I agree with stephanie... We too, just started teaching Kaelynn signs.. she loves the DVD because of the babies on there and I personally think everyone should learn at least the basic signs... it's great to be able to communicate before they can talk.

I think it's ok to let them watch TV as long as you limit what they watch and how long they get to watch tv for

April 10, 2008 1:30 AM

About Cole Gamble

Cole Gamble’s writings on the crimes of Willy Wonka, man-eating beds and tales from his cringe-worthy life appear here on Babble, the humor site Cracked, The Daily Beast, The Huffington Post and Salon. He is working on a book entitled, Conquer Everything! A Self Help Book to Destroy All Other Self Help Books and Grant You Mastery in Everything.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage