Babble

a magazine and community for the new urban parent

Strollerderby

Slumming It - Literally

Posted by Amy S.F. Lutz

I'm much more better off - financially speaking - than my parents were when I was growing up.  So my number one fear, for my own kids, has always been that they'll grow up spoiled brats, with no appreciation for everything they are lucky enough to enjoy. 

Maybe taking them on one of the growing number of organized slum tours - now available through the most tragically, poverty-stricken areas of India, Brazil, Mexico and South Africa - would open their eyes.

Welcome to "poorism" - as its critics call it - where, for a small fee (Indian tours go for 300 rupees, or about $7.50) tourists get intimate with open sewars, exposed electrical wires and beggars.  For souvenirs, they get to snap photos of children digging through garbage dumps.  

If you're thinking, ick, you're not alone.  Many tourism professionals believe these excursions amount to little more than exploitation, a new way to give Westerners a smug sense of how great their lives are.  

To be fair, it seems the intentions of the tour operators are less mercenary than that.  Some hope to change general perception of these neighborhoods by showcasing work by local artists and inviting tourists to participate in festivals and other rituals.  Others stress the economic benefits the tours bring to the slums, by hiring locals as guides and allowing craftspeople to sell handiwork to tourists.  One Mexican tour requires participants to help make sandwiches and fill water bottles for the needy they visit.  It's all an attempt to humanize a problem that, whether we go and check it out in person or not, won't go away. 

Still, I can't see how my children would identify with a group of people they need to be taken by a tour guide to see, like animals on a safari.  It's a tough question:  how do you teach children to be grateful and generous, without feeling superior?   


Comments

 

Gracie5 said:

I think you can teach children to be grateful and generous by giving them the opportunity to help others through "service work."  Teach them to respond when they see a need, whether it is raking the leaves of an elderly neighbor, taking care of you when you are sick, working in a soup kitchen, or maybe, when they are old enough, going on a work trip.  No doubt there are Habitat for Humanity projects going on in whatever town you live in, so you don't necessarily need a lot of time or money to get involved in service work.  Going abroad is also wonderful, if you can afford it.  Of course, parents should set an example for kids by making this kind of giving an everyday part of life.  

These tours sound horrible, for the most part.  And I have to say that I don't know why someone would pay to go on a tour to see poverty in India - it is everywhere, and can't possibly be avoided.  

March 11, 2008 2:22 PM
 

Madeline Holler said:

How about parents "touring" their own cities. In every city I  have lived, there's some famous street or neighborhood that divides it. The financially secure rarely cross the divide, speak in hushed tones about when they do and calculate the risks of stopping in for dinner at one of the restaurants in the run-down neighborhoods. Oh, and certainly NOT with the kids.

Anyway, getting out in your own city gives you a chance to talk about some of these issues. And I doubt they'd feel superior, probably more curious than anything.

March 11, 2008 3:34 PM
 

Kate said:

I think that the best way to teach your kids about poverty and our responsibility to help those around us is to let them see you working to help others. There are so many volunteer organizations that will accept help from families. I am working in the slums in India right now, and we have seen a few families that come to pitch in. It is great for the kids, as they can not only see the poverty, but they can play with kids their own age who are in terrible circumstances. It helps them learn that people are the same everywhere, rich or poor. If your kids see you enjoying your wealth without caring about how others are forced to live, they are never going to learn anything but apathy from you.

March 13, 2008 10:13 AM

About Amy S.F. Lutz

Amy S.F. Lutz's work has appeared in dozens of literary journals, including Cream City Review, The American Poetry Review, Puerto del Sol, and Mid-American Review. She and her husband have five children. Amy and her sister chronicle their adventures in communal living in their blog whoelsewantstoliveinmyhouse.com

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage