Strollerderby

Beware of Dangerous Slings

Posted by Amy Kuras

 Once used mostly by hippies and crunchies, slings have become an extra trendy way of carrying babies and toddlers.

But as convenient, cool and snuggly as slings are, they may not be the safest choice to carry a baby. According to the Consumer Reports safety blog, standards setting organization ASTM International is starting the process to create standards for sling carriers, at the request of manufacturers.

Improper use or ring failure can result in bruises, fractures or other injuries when a baby falls out of the sling, and the Consumer Products Safety Commission has found a risk of "positional asphyxia" when a baby's head is too far forward in the sling and their airway is cut off. CPSC has recalled slings in the past, including, last year, the Infantino pictured.

According to the blog, "Most of the sling carriers demonstrated at the ASTM meeting seemed complicated to put on and prone to user error. Clear instructions and perhaps video demonstrations might help prevent mistakes."

Hah, I say. The brand of sling I use has video demonstrations right on its website. Do you know what they use to demonstrate? A doll. Which is smaller, lighter, and a hell of a lot less wiggly and floppy than any infant I've ever met.  

What worked for me is always putting the baby in the sling over a soft surface like the couch or bed, so if I do slip up their fall will be cushioned. Also, I tend not to use the sling a lot until they are a little older and have more head control. And getting a friend who both uses the same kind of sling you do and has a lick of sense about positioning the baby in it is really helpful, since "complicated to put on" is a bit of an understatement for even the simple pouch sling I use.



+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

JaySaint said:

Good grief. I have that Infantino sling sitting next to my front door waiting to go to a neighbor with a new baby. What a relief that I read this post tonight.

I love slings, but will admit that I usually clutch my baby with both hands anyway. I mostly use the sling to help distribute his weight. But that might be because I'm a crazy first-time mom.

April 10, 2008 10:19 PM
 

bookmama said:

I was all set to use a sling until our baby arrived, and then even though I followed the directions, she looked totally uncomfortable in there and I was afraid I was going to suffocate her. And if I waited until she was a little older, I think it would have been really uncomfortable to carry her because they sort of hang off your neck and my upper back and shoulders were sore enough with my giant milk boobies! So I switched to a different kind of carrier (the ergo) and loved it. It even has an infant insert so you can use it right away.  

April 10, 2008 10:40 PM
 

mommamarie said:

I found a website with a ton of useful information on good, easy to use slings, correct positioning, and other helpful hints: http://www.thebabywearer.com  

I love being able to leave the house confidently without needing a stroller!  

April 10, 2008 11:57 PM
 

tiffer said:

Slings hurt my back!  The ergo carrier is way better.

April 11, 2008 7:08 AM
 

Renee said:

Just so folks know, the old model of the Infantino sling which is pictured in this post was recalled, but as long as you have an Infantino sling which states "2007 NEW model" or later production date, it is perfectly safe.

From personal experience, however, I can attest that the INfantino sling is not the most comfortable thing in the world, and when my little one didn't have a lot of head control, it would push her neck into a funky position, so I didn't use it regularly until she was 4 mos old.

April 11, 2008 11:03 AM
 

Mom2Two said:

I had the Infantino sling and I hated it.  I had much better luck with the Maya Wrap, but it did take a lot of practice to learn how to use it properly.  Once I figured it out, I could breastfeed hands free.

April 11, 2008 2:08 PM
 

mamaloo said:

I am a long time sling/carrier user and I would never carry a baby like the woman pictured above. It's just not safe to be so far down in all that fabric and it's not positioned correctly for mother's comfort (riding too low).  

I think babies, especially newborns, who are carried should be carried in a Kangaroo Mother Care (KMC) fashion: tummy to mummy. Put the baby upright against your chest and cinch your sling till it holds the baby that way in the same position baby would be in if she were just sleeping on your chest while you watched a movie. Don't cover the baby's head, though you can pull the fabric up around her ears to help support the head, and you will be carrying the baby safely.

April 11, 2008 2:59 PM
 

AllisonWonder said:

Hey, Mom2Two- any tips for using the Mya wrap? My little guy hates it- he's very "hold me in your ARMS, mom!"

And getting his floppy little body in is hard to do...

April 11, 2008 4:47 PM
 

Cassie said:

I used a hip carrier by Walking Rock Farm for my toddlers and a Bjorn when they were floppy babies.  Putting the weight on your hips is a lot easier than on your shoulders and back. I used teh WRF hip carrier until my youngest was about 30lbs and had no problems and I am only 5 feet.  

I think they should recall those plastic bags people put on strollers when it rains.  I wonder how many kids get brain damaged from breathing CO2 in those things.  I mean, plastic bags have a warning on them not to put kids in them dont they and people buy them just for that purpose.  I would rather my kids get a bit wet than smother.  Stupid.

April 11, 2008 4:54 PM
 

km said:

Cassie:  You are so right about those plastic covers.  I hate those things, and pretty much thought I was the only one!  Seriously, my kids are water-proof, and it's not like we're going for a six-hour hike when it's raining out.

Also on my "hate list" are those grocery cart seat liners.  My mother-in-law has bought 3 of them for me (I am only now pregnant with my third kid), and can't understand why I would want the boys exposed to "unnecessary germs."  Okay, first of all, they're not rolling around in hospital waste.  Secondly, they've had less colds, etc. than their cousins, who influenced m-i-l's idea to buy these things in the first place.

Sorry, I'll stop the rant now.

April 11, 2008 9:47 PM
 

MamaT said:

The Infantino sling-rider that says "new 2007 design" is just fine for use.  The previous ones were recalled. I actually used it, and it was nice, but I wouldn't recommend it because the baby will grow out of it so quickly.  

Pouch slings are the way to go in my opinion.  I have a peanut shell that I've used since he was 1 month, and still use it at 12 months. I also have an Ergo which I looooooove.  It comes with an instructional video and I can't say enough good things about it.

Really?  Just use common sense. Look at your baby. Looks like their head is too far forward?  Readjust.  Don't readjust without first getting a firm hold on your baby. Shopping carts are not the safest things in the world to put your little ones in - they aren't inspected for safety, and often parents wander away from them.  And then carseats placed precariously on top of carts?  Doubly unsafe.  Also, babies that go from crib to bouncy seat to carseat ... flat heads!

The sling really helped during the first months when my little guy wanted to do nothing but be held and nurse.  www.thebabywearer.com has lots of helpful advice.

April 12, 2008 12:42 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage