Strollerderby

Puppy Mauls Baby Left In Swing

Posted by Amy S.F. Lutz

You may not have noticed, but we've been trying to cut down on the unnecessarily gruesome stories here on the 'Derby.  Teens have been decapitated by rollercoasters, toddlers have drowned in swimming pools and we haven't even mentioned them.

But is there such a thing as "necessarily gruesome"?  Stories that, despite their disturbing nature, raise basic and important childrearing points?

For example, this case:  yesterday, in Tulsa, Oklahoma, a two-month-old boy was mauled to death by a six-week-old black labrador puppy.  Those aren't words you hear very often in conjunction with dog attacks:  "six-week-old puppy" and "black labrador."  Pitbulls, sure.  Sweet, family-friendly black labs?  Not typically.

The fact is, it's just not safe to ever leave any dog alone with a child, no matter how sweet and family-friendly.  

And where were this baby's parents while their son was being attacked?  In the home, as was the child's grandmother.  But the baby had been left alone in a swing - where the adults presumably considered the baby safe.  

Babies should never be left alone, not in a swing, or carseat, or any piece of equipment that can be tipped over, or provide a tempting target for siblings or pets.  I don't know . . . you really want to blame this on the fact that the parents were young and therefore irresponsible - Mom is only 17.  But how many of us can say we've never left our babies sleeping in the swing to take a shower, or to help get an older child ready for school?  

Sure, these tragic cases are extremely rare.  But I have to imagine it's worth waking the baby up, taking him out of the swing and letting him cry for ten minutes in a safe place like his crib if your attention is needed elsewhere, rather than have to live your entire life knowing that your child's death was completely preventable.

 

Related Post:

Maybe These Pitbulls Are Dangerous


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Karen said:

This is just horrible for all involved - and this is just a thought.  If the puppy got to the child in a swing, couldn't it have gotten to the child through crib railing (maul but not kill, maybe), Moses basket, or co-sleeper?  Is there ever really a safe place to have a child and a puppy out of eyeshot?  It could have happened so fast, being in the same room might not have even been enough, I'm afraid.  

July 29, 2008 3:43 PM
 

Oana said:

Can you link to the original story?

July 29, 2008 4:05 PM
 

Kelly said:

I was surprised you did not link to the story in Coppell, Texas about the two children drowning...I would have loved to have heard everyone's thoughts.  Apparently I am wrong in thinking that maybe there was something not right about that entire story.  I mean how exactly is your one year old (I have one right now) out of your sight long enough to get to a door, out a door and to a pool to fall in a drown!?

July 29, 2008 4:10 PM
 

Sweb said:

Our dog was only 2 years old when we had our baby and when I had to shower we either used a baby gate (placed so the dog couldn't jump over or go under) or I would put the baby in the crib and shut the bedroom door. Although we never had a problem with the dog it made me feel safer with that added precaution.

July 29, 2008 4:19 PM
 

aaustin said:

I read, when I was pregnant with #1, so it would've been 3 years ago, that babies in swings can "activate" the predator instinct in dogs - something about the motion of the swing mimicking prey running away or darting back and forth or something.  As a result, we were always very careful about the swing with our wonderful German Shepherd mutt, who was generally too busy napping to notice the baby.  

Here's an abstract that may or may not refer to the original article I read:

www3.interscience.wiley.com/.../abstract

There's more info about halfway down this page:

www.doggonesafe.com/newsletter%20vol002%20issue02.htm

What a heartbreaking story.

July 29, 2008 4:23 PM
 

Tyler said:

That's sad. My landlord has a chocolate lab pup (along with a 9 year old black lab) and I can see how it would be able to maul a baby. It's always so energetic, nippy and bouncing around.

July 29, 2008 4:37 PM
 

LogicalMama said:

Dogs also have an instinct to comfort pups in distress, therefore if a baby is crying, they may attempt to console it the way a dog would to another dog (especially if the baby/child is considered part of the "pack").... try to carry the baby in it's mouth and stimulate it so it knows it's not alone..... a sad truth, really, the dog is attempting to "love" it but the wrong thing happens. The bottom line is that you can't leave young'uns with any kind of dog, really!

July 29, 2008 7:09 PM
 

Megan said:

I found a link (one of many). What an awful thing to happen.  :(

www.kswo.com/.../story.asp

July 29, 2008 7:17 PM
 

Jan Karlsbjerg said:

I disagree with much of the above. The bottom line is that shit happens and you can't (and shouldn't) be looking directly at your baby at all hours of the day. Even if you did look at the baby, something might happen anyway. There are no guarantees in life.

Have a baby, worry about them for the next 40 years.

July 29, 2008 7:17 PM
 

Ginger said:

There's something very strange about this story.  To be sure, it's tragic however are we supposed to believe that a pup can maul a baby to death with adults in the household?  No one was supervising the baby?  No one heard a thing?  I hope there's a full investigation into this, to determine if the pup actually killed the baby or if the baby died some other way and the pup got a hold of it afterwards.  

July 29, 2008 9:17 PM
 

feefifoto said:

Is there any sensible reason to have a new puppy in the house when you have a new baby?  Shouldn't taking care of the baby be a top priority, not taking care of the baby while training a new dog?

July 29, 2008 10:01 PM
 

elizabeth said:

I'm with Ginger...

Something sounds fishy. Being a dog person, I have a very hard time believing that a black lab puppy can coordinate itself enough to maul a baby when the pups can hardly get out of their own way. A little too convenient that the baby was silently being mauled in one room while the parents were in the other....completly unaware?  

July 30, 2008 7:45 AM
 

Cissy said:

My question is - where are all the smart people? From what I garnered from this story, they were planning to euthanize the puppy. What? You euthanize an evil pit bull that has been trained to attack, but a 6 week old lab is doing what all lab puppies do - they chew things. He didnt know it wasnt okay to chew on the baby. Where was everyone who was supposed to be watching the baby and/or the puppy? Has the whole world just gone mad??

July 30, 2008 9:19 AM
 

Emmy said:

Please stop with all the pitbull prejudice!

Here are some good intuitive words to teach your pets, even if you don’t have children:

ow (back away)

off (get off the bed/couch/person)

gentle (don’t touch)

down (lay down)

I have a pitbull and he is great with kids. We started teaching him these as soon as possible. All dogs can get worked up and it’s the owner’s responsibility to know how to get them under control.

Oh, and my well trained, people friendly pitbull is also big enough to body block my neighbor’s untrained black lab, whose favorite game is knock-down-the-pregnant-lady.

July 30, 2008 2:37 PM
 

Jessica said:

I'm sorry, but I just don't buy the fact that a six week old puppy killed the baby. A 6 week old barely has its eyes open and doesn't even have teeth yet. How could it possibly jump up into a swing and maul a baby - all totally silently? That last link says it could have been a pug. Now that I could see. But of course it's not as sensational of a story...

July 30, 2008 4:27 PM
 

Jen said:

I am not convinced that this puppy did ANYTHING to harm this child. Have you seen these parents? This grandmother? They look like they were probably in the house smoking the pipe, if you know what I mean. I've raised labs my whole life, and I have NEVER seen a 6 week old puppy exhibit any such behavior. I have to wonder if these parents did something to this child and then tried covering it up by saying 'the puppy did it.' Puppies don't do this sort of thing, especially labs.

July 30, 2008 11:21 PM
 

Kari said:

This story is very sad.  I think the article could have been written without the reference to pit bulls, though.  I would be just as shocked to hear about a 6 week old pit bull puppy mauling an infant in a swing as I still am that a 6 week old labrador did.  I have seen aggressive puppies that young, but I don't think I have ever seen one who could maul a baby sitting up that high (you've got to think that the baby's feet are at least six inches off the ground).  I could see it happening if the baby was on the floor or on a couch.  I'm curious to see if they ever release information about where the dog bites were on the child's body.  I watched a video where they showed the other dog in the home, an adult pug, being dragged away with a catch pole...and the "killer" black lab puppy being cradled in the person's arms.  Why wouldn't it be the other way around if they were so certain the lab was the attacker?  I am pretty bent that they would euthanize the puppy without so much as an investigation into the cause of death.  This entire situation is not only sad, but fishy.

July 31, 2008 12:48 AM
 

mamanomnom said:

I agree that this is difficult to believe. I understand that when you leave a child unsupervised bad things can happen, but I can't imagine that the child would have been silent if it were being bitten by a dog. My baby screams if there's a clothing tag itching her. Wouldn't the baby begin screaming hysterically the moment it got bitten?

It seems like this is a case of trying to determine whether it was gross negligence (ignoring a hysterically crying baby in the other room), or outright child abuse and murder (killing the baby and blaming the dog to get out of trouble).

July 31, 2008 1:39 PM
 

mark m said:

police aren't stupid,I would think a full investigation will be launched.This story is VERY fishy.A SIX week old puppy couldn't even reach a child in a baby swing.

July 31, 2008 2:57 PM
 

Kari said:

I don't disagree that police aren't stupid, but I do think that they "jumped the gun" on the euthanization of the puppy.  Within hours, the lab was put down.  It will be weeks before all investigations are done with this situation.  I do think that a six week old lab could reach a baby's toes if they were in a swing, but I have a hard time believing it could reach much more than that.  But, again, the puppy did look a little older than six weeks in the photo and I read in another article that they gauged the puppy's age to be between 2 and 3 months old upon euthanization.  :(

July 31, 2008 3:55 PM
 

Stoakland said:

Here's an idea for keeping baby and dog separate while parents are in the shower:  crate teh dog.  Give him a treat, and he'll love being in his safe place -- and the baby's safe then, too.

July 31, 2008 7:45 PM
 

Kari said:

The puppy definitely should have been crated...for safety and housebreaking issues.  And, these folks weren't taking a quick shower, which I can see leaving an infant in a swing for a short amount of time, in a room nearby.  The grandpa left and put the baby in the swing, father left shortly afterwards around 8 or so...baby found dead after 10.  The mother and grandmother were asleep in the opposite end of the home the entire time.  So many mistakes made in this situation.  I hope they have learned some lesson from all this.

August 1, 2008 1:19 AM
 

Tinkerbell said:

I can certainly believe the stupidity of the 'puppy couldn't do it' posters on this page.  In my experience 'dog lovers' include the most truly expendable people in our society, and if their kids get eaten by puppies ' who would never hurt a fly ' well - lets just call it positive eugenics and get on with our lives.  

August 1, 2008 1:25 PM

About Amy S.F. Lutz

Amy S.F. Lutz's work has appeared in dozens of literary journals, including Cream City Review, The American Poetry Review, Puerto del Sol, and Mid-American Review. She and her husband have five children. Amy and her sister chronicle their adventures in communal living in their blog whoelsewantstoliveinmyhouse.com

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage