Strollerderby

Green products that don't work

Posted by Brett Singer

Dirty dishes don't get cleaned using 'green' dishwashing liquidIt would be great if all of the au natural products flooding the market were actually effective. Unfortunately, that's not the case in my experience. After showing you three that we use and like, here are three that we don’t like, but in one case we use it anyway:

1.    Dishwashing liquid: I have never seen a cleaner of any kind less effective than this. I think it would actually be better to run the dishwasher without any soap at all. The dishes come out with a film that seems chemically, despite the fact that this stuff is supposed to just the opposite. I would mention the brand but we threw out the bottle in disgust.

2.    Recycled paper towels: I'm all for the lack of dyes and scents, but these things just don't work. They absorb such a tiny amount of liquid that you need to use three or four of them, which sort of defeats the purpose. We do, however, use them anyway.

3.    Recycled toilet paper: Again, all for the no-dyes/no perfumes/recycled paper thing. But scratchy paper on my tush? No way.

Are there any green products you tried using but stopped because they just didn't work?

image: foodonthebrain

Read more:

Green products I use and like

Volleyball hasn’t come a long way, baby

More stuff YUPPIE parents like

Return of the son of stuff YUPPIE parents like

Five things my son taught me about living green

Baby Penis Album only five bucks

Budget Baby: 10 More Ways to Live Green for Less

Egyptian woman gives birth to septuplets because she wanted a boy

5 reasons it's a good thing I had boys

10 Things Adults Don't Mind (that Kids Try to Avoid)

More Kids Stuff I like that my kids don't care about

5 things that would make parents' lives easier

It all started when Mary needed a laxative


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

pqbon said:

Ummm, how about including the product/brand info for these products you don't like?

August 19, 2008 3:32 PM
 

Brett Singer said:

I would post them, but I don't know the specific brands. The paper towels are from various manufacturers but are always brown. Same with the toilet paper. The dishwashing liquid was a store-brand but I don't know which store.

August 19, 2008 4:05 PM
 

Casa Wasabi said:

I (also) don't remember the brand, but I was trying all natural stain remover for a while.  hahahahahahaha.  What a joke.  I've learned that you NEED chemicals to get stains out of clothes, especially when there's a toddler involved.  And if there is a superpioneerwoman out there that gets stains out with, like, saddle wax and a broom handle, save the advice - I don't have time to deviate from my system.

August 19, 2008 4:15 PM
 

dcfullest said:

I thought 7th generation's dishwashing liquid for dishwashers was absolutely horrible.

I have yet to use a Method product that wasn't great.

August 19, 2008 4:18 PM
 

Bunny said:

The best organic approach for stain removal:

Wear dark colors. Works like a charm.

(I really have never understood why people feel compelled to wear white and khaki all the time. What's the use of a pair of pants if I can't sit on the floor, the grass, or some steps? and why would you put a young kid in something that won't let them sit on the floor, the grass, or some steps?)

August 19, 2008 5:08 PM
 

Marsh'sMom said:

I've had the same experience with the seventh generation dishwashing liquid.  I now use the Palmolive ECO brand (phosphate free) which probably isn't as friendly as SG, but does a better job (no film).  It's still not as effective as the chemical laden stuff.  As for paper towels and toilet paper, I found a brand at Costco called Sunrise by Marcal that I'm really happy with (http://www.marcalpaper.com/).  The price was great too.  I've never seen it outside of Costco though.

As for laundry detergent, I've tried 7th Gen and wasn't thrilled.  I now make my own by using half Arm and Hammer Washing Soda powder and half grated FelsNaptha laundry bar soap.  It works for general laundry cleaning and is super cheap because you only use 2 tablespoons per load.  For stains though, I usually have to use a conventional stain remover before washing to get it out.    

August 19, 2008 6:27 PM
 

tracy said:

I too, tried the organic dish washer stuff and I had to run the thing three times before I gave up [which wasn't very "green" of me...] and my dishes too had a strange white film. Oh well! Back to my cinnamon dish washing pellets that make everything sparkle.

August 19, 2008 8:04 PM
 

LogicalMama said:

Mrs. Meyers laundry soap is awesome and when you use your 20% off coupons at Bed, Bath and Beyond, it's worth it.

ALso, I agree with Marsh's mom about Palmolive ECO+. It does work well and the others don't work well at all, but I am sure Method would work great b/c they are a great company with good alternatives.

As for toilet paper and paper towels-- I rarely use paper towels and fully believe that everyone should use recycled regardless. It's just what we need to do. I mostly use towels that I've been using forever and I wash them, but it works for us. We live minimally. Trader Joes makes a great paper towel that is 100% recycled; 80% post consumer recycled.

Regarding toilet paper, I've tried non-recycled that is scratchier than anything I've tried. I feel it's our responsibility to use recycled TP and again, Trader's Joe's makes a good one, as does Green Forest!

It's our obligation to the future of the planet. If everyone adopts an attitude of "I deserve better than this....," we are gonna screw ourselves!

August 19, 2008 8:54 PM
 

Ashers mom said:

The Ecover dishwashing tablets are awesome!  

August 19, 2008 10:09 PM
 

dhsredhead said:

We use Ecover, Sun and Earth and ECOs products for washing dishes and clothing. I have been happy with all three. For toilet paper we use 7th generation, we did not like another brand whose name I cannot remember, but my partner also does not like super soft toilet paper. We use 7th generation paper towels, I also like Sunrise, they sell them at a super market here. The only two things I can think of that were eco-friendly and did not work for us were g-diapers and desert essence deodorant. For stain removal we use Dr.Bronners soap. We have clothing that was smoked damaged from a fire that I soaked in Dr. Bronners and all of the smoke stains came out. I also use it to clean my daughter's shoes too. Another good thing for stain removal is to wash the item more then once. I thought my daughter's favorite outfit was ruined forever until I let her wear it anyways and it went through the wash another cycle, the stains are almost completely gone now, the same with several pairs of pants I wear to work. It's also important to wash things in cold water.

August 19, 2008 11:15 PM
 

chyna823 said:

I've tried a few "green" dishwasher powders, and most of them suck. But the Shaklee dishwasher powder works wonderfully, and instead of Jet Dry as a rinse aid, plain white vinegar works just as well.

August 20, 2008 12:05 PM
 

Cassie said:

We have never used paper towels.  Waste of money and resources.  We use cloth towels instead.  They last for years. I never use rinse aid either.  The last thing we need is more chemicals in our bodies.  Anyone here know what is in it?  You should, it does not rinse 100% off and your feed it to your kids.  We use 7th Generation dishwashing liquid and it does a good job cleaning the dishes.  If there is a film on your dishes your water is hard or you are using too much soap.  Most people fill up the little cup all the way.  You only need to fill it half way and I never fill up the tiny cup.

August 20, 2008 1:17 PM
 

mommashay said:

I totally agree.  I have yet to find a dishwasher detergent that actually works, including Method's tablets, 7th Generation, and Planet.  But thanks to some of the comments I will try Ecover or Mrs. Meyers.  I hope you are right!  No paper towels have been worth it but Nature's Balance toilet paper is pretty good and you can get it at Safeway/Vons for the same price as all the big brands (for those of you who are like me and don't live anywhere near a Whole Foods or Trader Joe's.)

August 20, 2008 2:29 PM
 

Brett Singer said:

These are really great tips, everyone, thank you for sharing them.

One thing: we actually use the Seventh Generation toilet paper, and have no complaints.

August 20, 2008 3:58 PM
 

LogicalMama said:

My complaint with Seventh Generation is the price!

August 21, 2008 3:27 AM

About Brett Singer

Brett Singer is a writer and father living in Manhattan with his wonderful wife and two terrific sons (referred to here as Thing 1 and Thing 2). He writes about music for the Boston Phoenix, parenting for Babble and daddytips.com, and other topics for anyone else who will have him.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage