Strollerderby

Teaching Evolution as Theory not fact

Posted by Brett Singer

David Campbell teaching evolution in FloridaAn article in last week's New York Times discussed a major hot-button issue in schools across the country: evolution vs. creationism, or its offshoot, intelligent design.

It's a long article, and certainly worth reading. I won't try to summarize the whole piece in this post, but the big surprise for me was that it was less about two competing theories/beliefs, or even about science versus religion. It was about a teacher who, in my opinion, has the patience of Job.

That teacher is David Campbell, who teaches Biology in Orange Park, Florida. The story the article tells is not of him fighting with parents, the school board, or local churches. Actually, he's not fighting with anyone. This quote sums up his attitude nicely:

"He scanned the faces of the sophomores in his Biology I class. Many of them, he knew from years of teaching high school in this Jacksonville suburb, had been raised to take the biblical creation story as fact. His gaze rested for a moment on Bryce Haas, a football player who attended the 6 a.m. prayer meetings of the Fellowship of Christian Athletes in the school gymnasium.

"'If I do this wrong,' Mr. Campbell remembers thinking on that humid spring morning, 'I’ll lose him.'"


His main concern is not "proving" anything one way or the other. It's teaching.

"'Faith is not based on science,' Mr. Campbell said. 'And science is not based on faith. I don’t expect you to ‘believe’ the scientific explanation of evolution that we’re going to talk about over the next few weeks. But I do expect you to understand it.'"

That, to me, is the bottom line. Campbell's students, although they probably don't think so, are incredibly lucky to have him.

image/source: NYTimes

Read more:

Two women found guilty of illegal midwifery

Are your kids aware of the election?

They Say: no link between autism and measles vaccine

Palin family online - real or fake?

McCain, Palin oppose teen pregnancy aid and sex education

Toys R Us Says Government Safety Standards Not Good Enough

Teaching Abstinence Doesn’t Work: Palin’s Preggo Kid.

Dad arrested for leaving son at McDonald's

Green products that don't work

For a good marriage, women need to stay home

33 year old mom wins silver medal, saves son from leukemia



+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Alice said:

Oh yes, we have one of the wrost education systems in the industrial world.  Lets make our kids dumber.

September 7, 2008 4:38 PM
 

leahsmom said:

I think this is actually an interesting approach - especially when you have children who've been raised to believe that science and fact do not actually support the theories many of us insist they do.  I really appreciate this teacher's effort to create a bridge between the two sides here, and to make sure the children are informed about the other side - which is the best way to make sure they can make informed choices about what to believe. I am so tired of comments and attitudes that simply continue to perpetrate a divide rather than seeing if there is any commonality - and I applaud Mr. Campbell for his approach.

September 8, 2008 8:59 AM
 

Brett Singer said:

@leahsmom: yep, me too. The teacher, according to the article, is a churchgoer, so its not a religion issue (at least not to him). Besides, algebra is against MY religion, but I still had to take the class :-)

September 8, 2008 9:07 AM
 

paanta said:

This sort of soft touch may be a good way to get kids to at least understand science, and hopefully once they understand it they'll realize that they need to move to a slightly more symbolic interpretation of religion.  Of course, that's exactly what a lot of fundamentalist parents fear...

There's no common ground between religion and science.  They're diametrical approaches to understanding existence.  A scientist who believes in anything close to a literal interpretation of the bible either needs to ignore facts OR believe that God is deliberately attempting to trick us into thinking the world is several billion years old as a test of our faith.

September 8, 2008 10:04 AM
 

tiffer said:

Sounds like a smart guy.  Good way to approach it.  

September 8, 2008 1:42 PM

About Brett Singer

Brett Singer is a writer and father living in Manhattan with his wonderful wife and two terrific sons (referred to here as Thing 1 and Thing 2). He writes about music for the Boston Phoenix, parenting for Babble and daddytips.com, and other topics for anyone else who will have him.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage