Strollerderby

A Guy’s Take on Why You Shouldn’t Circumcise (and Why You Should)

Posted by Cole Gamble

To cut or not to cut: that is the question. Any parent about to have a boy faces this quandry. In ancient times circumcision was a must. Lack of proper hygiene made foreskins a liability. This is the modern era, however. The old slice n’ dice routine is more choice than mandate. Some of you made your decision the second you discovered the sex of the baby. “I’ll chop the sucker off myself if I have to.” Some of you were a bit more hesitant. The same problem saddled my wife and I two years ago. One of us was very pro-circ (wife) and the other less so. For full disclosure’s sake, I myself am not circumcised and it doesn’t bother me one iota. So I laid out my case to save the foreskin. Here’s is what I told my wife:

 

Penis Styling as Fashion

 

Save the religious exception, most parents chose to cut because they simply think it’s a more fashionable look. The line I got from my wife was, “Girls like them better.” To which I replied, “You married me, didn’t you?” At which point she added, “Oh, but yours is…special,” patting me on the head reassuringly. Um, nice save. My father in law tossed in his two cents: “The boys in the high school showers will make fun of him.” “Oh really?” I said, “Well then my son can just say, ‘Dude, you’re the one staring at my penis.’” Face it, parents circumcise because they want their boy to be like all the others. They’re shaping their child to conform from birth. Is that what you want, a conformist? Do you want to a kid who is a genital sheep, or do want one who rocks the system with a penis with personality?

 

Great Names

 

All the euphemisms for circumcised are played out. Bald headed soldier. One eyed snake. Yawn. Think of a cut penis as a wellspring of inspiration for new names. Like “The Sleeping Bag” or “Mr. Turtleneck.”

 

Men with Uncircumcised Penises Have More Pleasurable Sex

 

Okay so you’re not giving a lot of thought to your child’s future sex life. Fair enough, but many experts believe that circumcision leads to lessened penile sensitivity because the foreskin is jam packed with nerve endings. It is even said that an un-snipped penis is better for the woman as well. Leave the foreskin alone and, believe me, your son will thank you years from now. Not that you would ever, ever, ever want him to.

 

Possible Surgical Risk

 

Any and all surgery (and circumcision is surgery) comes with risk.

 

It Is Not Too Much Trouble to Care For

 

This was the big argument my wife trotted out. “You don’t want to clean it everyday, do you?” Turns out you are not even supposed to touch the thing until the boy is three, and by then it pulls back naturally and you clean it just like you would a normal penis. So there, you penis scrubbing fanatics!

 

Read Part 2: The Pros of Circumsicion

 

More by this author:

 

 

 The 26 Most Disturbing Kids Movies Ever

7 Classic Kid's TV Shows Clearly Conceived on (Bad) Acid

12 Pregnancy Myths

The Sh*t List: 10 Bizarre (or Terrific?) Potty Gadgets


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

JeanneSager said:

A penis with personality? All I can think of is the little dancing frog with the top hat from the WB doing "he's got personality, lots of personality. . . " You crack me up.

October 6, 2008 12:59 PM
 

Jewess extraordinare said:

UGH!  As usual Babble provides all bluster and opinion and no actual research of any kind.  It's a big decision, but don't let others bully you.  

My view - It's not necessary and as a Jew, I'm not sure why non-Jews do it.  But, don’t listen to extreme elements of anti-circumcision groups. Think about it calmly and rationally.    Choosing circumcision is not barbaric.  It’s not akin to female genital mutilation.  If your husband is circumsized, don't allow others to bully you into thinking it will destroy your little boy's future sex life - has it destroyed the sex lives of your husband? I'm guessing if you have a son in the oven, your sex life is probably not that bad. The idea that circumcision damages the male sex life is an imaginative assumption.  

Know your stats.   It’s becoming far less common that it was in the last generation to come of age.  So little Liam, Aiden or Oliver will likely not be the only boy in the locker room with a foreskin.  (Even if he plays third base for the Schwartzman Deli Bobcats, he still might not be the only one)

I’m not sure you can do this if you aren’t Jewish... but if I wasn’t and wanted one for my son, I would choose a Jewish style circumcision.  And I was shocked when I saw what some hospitals do.  Drugs and apparati.  Very scary.   I’ve been to many a bris (a Jewish circumcision ceremony) and it’s not that bad.  Yes, the boy cries.   The boy is usually back to sleep by the time the smoked salmon is gone.  I’ve never heard of a single problem - though I’m sure others could name one.  In my grapevine, it has never come up.  Thousands of years of experience have to count for something, right?

October 6, 2008 1:20 PM
 

Jennifer Margulis said:

We bucked more than 5000 years of Jewish tradition and decided not to circumcise our son. Thanks for the blog post about this!

October 7, 2008 12:26 AM
 

Jennifer said:

I have 2 sons with different fathers, I opted to let the father's make that decision, and each opted to make the same decision their parents made for them; so I have one son with and one son without the snip.  In the future I would recommend letting them make the choice when they're old enough, after all it is their equipment. I like the "natural" penis better myself.

October 7, 2008 1:49 AM
 

coolteamblt said:

As a pregnant woman with no strong opinion on it, I'm letting my husband choose for our son. He's strongly pro-circumcision, which is making my parents hysterical. Oh well, he's not their son.

October 7, 2008 8:59 AM
 

Iga said:

I love this article. Usually it is a cultural issue. I know that most Hispanic males are not circumcised. My husband and I are Polish and we are expecting baby boy. We plan to leave it the same as his fathers' (meaning "natural"). I just think it makes sense for son and father to look the same in that area. I do not worry about school showers. I hope he will be assertive enough to respond to that in an effective way.

October 10, 2008 2:44 PM
 

Cristi said:

When I was pregnant with my oldest son, hubby and I assumed we would have him circumcised. After he was born, we just couldn't put him through it.  He's now in his twenties and says he's glad we didn't.  He says he wasn't the butt of shower room jokes and hasn't had any health issues because of it.  We didn't circ his brother either.  It is how men are meant to be.

October 11, 2008 2:35 AM
 

Zsofi said:

Don't circumcise, it truly lessens the pleasure for the guys. It's wonderful and nice the way God created it! I like to play with it:)

October 11, 2008 8:01 AM
 

juanita said:

i think- if a man really haves the issue (not snipped) he'll take care of it later in his life...it my baby's body, not mind..i shouldny make any changes to his, beforehand.

October 11, 2008 2:25 PM
 

mrs mutasa said:

i hear its healthy to cut the foreskin. i am expecting a baby boy and i will let the daddy make the decision to go ahead with it or not to. the dad isn't circumcised and i doubt if he wants our boy to be cut. i personally wouldn't want my little man to go through the pain...

October 13, 2008 6:20 AM
 

Christy said:

Coming from a woman... cut it. A penis is ugly enough without having all of that extra skin.

October 13, 2008 4:15 PM
 

amy said:

boys are born w/ foreskin for a reason.  it's there to server a purpose.  i say leave it. we didn't circumcise our son and have had no problems with it. who cares what it "looks" like.

October 13, 2008 8:24 PM
 

Kurt Cobain said:

The author is a self-centered idiot.  Thankfully for his baby, his wife set him straight.

You are doing your baby a TREMENDOUS disservice if you don't cut it.  There is no doubt that girls prefer it cut.  Also, he conveniently understates the tremendous medical benefits of cutting, and completely ignores hygiene considerations.  CUT!

October 14, 2008 4:58 AM
 

Peter Peter said:

Trust me cut or uncut, men are enjoying sex PLENTY!!!

October 14, 2008 10:25 AM
 

Cam said:

For all the pro-cutters: Oh come on, it's not your decision to cut it off. I couldn't care less if you're the parents or not. You're cutting off a piece of your child's body, without their consent. Would you cut off one of their fingers? Their toes? Clip part of their ear off? I think not. Leave their penis alone.

October 17, 2008 6:58 PM
 

my dick is cut said:

holy shit....cut it please it looks so fucking ugly with all that fuckin extra skin...just cut it girls like it better..wait until your kid gets his first blowjob or handjob and the girl just pulls down his pants and is like.. ew.. just wait.

October 20, 2008 12:04 AM
 

Cole Gamble said:

Thank you, my dick is cut, for your thoughtful and eloquent statement. Your full of crap, by the way.

October 20, 2008 12:54 AM

About Cole Gamble

Cole Gamble’s writings on the crimes of Willy Wonka, man-eating beds and tales from his cringe-worthy life appear here on Babble, the humor site Cracked, The Daily Beast, The Huffington Post and Salon. He is working on a book entitled, Conquer Everything! A Self Help Book to Destroy All Other Self Help Books and Grant You Mastery in Everything.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage