Strollerderby

Autistic Girl Kicked Out Of Girl Scouts

Posted by Brett Singer

Magi Klages, an 8 year old autistic girl, was kicked out of a Girl Scout troop because the other kids were afraid of her.This is messed up.

Magi Klages, an 8 year old autistic girl, has been a Girl Scout since she was 6. According to ABC News, her "Brownie troop grew too large". So they put her in a smaller troop with only four other girls, all of whom have special needs.

She was kicked out on the first day after she "threw a fit...biting herself and running out of the circle." The troop leader told Magi's parents that she was a "danger" to the other members and would no longer be welcome.

Her mother, Michele Klages, is understandably upset. Michele says that Magi was, at worst, only a danger to herself, and that reactions like Magi's are not unusual for autistic children.

A Girl Scouts of America spokeswoman, Michelle Tompkins, said that Magi being kicked out of the troop was "terrible". A spokeswoman for the local chapter of the Girl Scouts (Wisconsin Southeast) did not respond to ABC News, according to the article.

The Scouts and Magi's parents are looking for a new troop for Magi, which is probably for the best. But it seems extremely unfair to boot the little girl out after the first day. I'm not saying the other children weren't scared; I wasn't there of course, but I can imagine the situation and I'm sure it was uncomfortable. But the first day? I'm not saying there should be a "three strikes" policy or anything like that, but give the kid a chance. According to ABC News, "the Girl Scouts has been historically open to anyone and prides itself on its anti-discrimination policies." I guess not everyone got the memo.

Source: ABC News via Disabled Politico (thanks to a reader for the tip!)

Read more:

Denis Leary Puts Autism Comments In Context

Girl Diagnoses Herself With Autism

Can Music Help Cure Autism?

Kindergartners Vote An Autistic Classmate Out of the Class

They Say: More Children Have Allergies

Rare Condition Makes Boy Look Like Werewolf



+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Knitty said:

You would think that a Girl Scout group created specifically for children with special needs would be understanding of said needs.  I have my doubts about how frightened the other children were -- at age six, plenty of "normal" children are still throwing the sort of tantrum described.  It sounds to me like they just have the wrong person running this troop.  

November 28, 2008 2:21 PM
 

sarah said:

admittedly, this is terrible - but to play devil's advocate, girl scout troops are run by volunteers (often parents) with little training.  If the volunteer running the troop can't manage a kid's behavior, the troop often disbands because the leader leaves and no one new steps up.  

November 28, 2008 5:37 PM
 

UPSET BY LIES said:

Maybe you should get all the facts before jumping to conclusions.  Shame on you.  Do your research.

November 28, 2008 9:46 PM
 

nic said:

Of course they did.  When I was a brownie my mom was told they quit doing it after my first year, which was a bald face lie.  I just wasn't as popular as the other girls.  Ever hear the song "One of these things is not like the other"?  It's just human nature to discriminate, what ever the degree may be.

November 29, 2008 1:47 AM
 

Knitty said:

What exactly are you objecting to, UPSET BY WHATEVER?

November 29, 2008 2:50 AM
 

UPSET BY LIES said:

This story that you are reading about is not true. It's amazing how people are so willing to believe one person's story without even getting all the details.  It's completely one-sided.  Perhaps maybe the media should do the research on the rest of the girls and exactly what happened.  Don't you have to wonder why the troop leaders would make the decision they did?  Just once ask yourself that.  There may be other circumstances that surround this story.   It's sensationalism at its finest!

November 29, 2008 7:22 PM
 

Kate said:

This story is so sad. The girl scout troupe that I grew up in was probably one-third special needs girls. We went camping every year and the whole camp was full of girls who couldn't walk being pulled in red wagons by girls who could. We had dance parties with girls dancing on their feet and in their wheelchairs. We had autistic girls, girls with cerebral palsy, girls with learning disorders, a little of everything. It was absolutely wonderful, and my time as a camper and, later, a counselor, changed my life. I'm now an adult, and my husband and I just finished a six month stint as  volunteers at an orphanage in India for special needs boys. I wouldn't have had the skills or the heart for it if not for my time as a girl scout. This whole situation is just heartbreaking for me.

November 30, 2008 3:58 AM

About Brett Singer

Brett Singer is a writer and father living in Manhattan with his wonderful wife and two terrific sons (referred to here as Thing 1 and Thing 2). He writes about music for the Boston Phoenix, parenting for Babble and daddytips.com, and other topics for anyone else who will have him.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage