Strollerderby

No Kid? No Playground for You.

Posted by Miriam Axel-Lute

Have you ever gone to a playground without a kid? Perhaps as a playful evening date, pushing each other on the swings? Or as a parent-to-be, watching and thinking about how to manage squabbles between children? Or as a single parent looking to meet other parents, but without your kid in tow that day? Or just pausing on a walk to enjoy the sight and sound of joyful children playing?

No more. At least not in Central Park. Because, you know, you might be a child molestor.

Dr. Marty Klein, a relationship counselor, international trainer of counselors, and never one to shrink from a controversial position, is the one who noticed this, and he rips into the illogic of it with characteristic vigor, arguing that while it's hard to imagine how this could actually make kids safer, it sure does fuel the atmosphere of overblown panic over putative "sexual predators" lurking behind every bush. He notes that such an atmosphere not only makes people generally feel less safe, but creates fertile ground for policies that both kill notions of due process and restrict perfectly healthy expressions of adult sexuality.

I'd add that it also leads to children growing up in such a fearful world with such terrified parents that they never experience freedom or learn to be independent and take calculated risks, a world where they are driven even short distances to school because it would be "dangerous" for them to walk, even though the biggest risk for a kid on the way to school these days is where they dart across several lanes of traffic from the car to the school door. Not to mention obesity.

Stranger molestation is awful, but unlike molestation by family members or family friends, it's super, super, super rare. I agree with Dr. Klein: our obsession with it is creepy and not likely to be making anyone safer.

More by this author:


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Erin said:

Are you serious? This is one of the most ridiculous posts I've seen on Babble and that's saying something. Playgrounds are for kids, period. Grownups can and should go elsewhere in parks to drink, smoke, touch themselves, etc. ALL of which I've personally observed in NYC playgrounds from single adults. I see you don't live in NYC so I'm not sure why you think you're entitled to comment on this, but how about taking your daughter to my local playground in Brooklyn for awhile and see how you feel about the old man sitting on the bench then.

December 2, 2008 10:45 AM
 

gpgirl said:

I'm not sure the only reason for this law is to avoid sexual predators. I live in San Francisco, and we also have this law, but I always thought it was to avoid having homeless people camp out in the playground, and leaving their, let's say, waste behind.

I agree that we are way too scared to strangers who are sexual predators, which are very rare. However, I agree with Erin - there are other things adults do at a playground that just are not appropriate for children.

I'm pretty sure if a little old lady was sitting in a playground and sweetly watching the kids, nobody would call the cops to have her removed.

December 2, 2008 11:45 AM
 

Twintown said:

I'm with the pp's on this one.  I live in Indianapolis, and while it's not exactly the urban hub that NYC is, I can appreciate this law.  I've seen single adults at our parks/playgrounds and Childrens Museum, and it can be pretty creepy.  I actually notified museum security once about a man by himself, who wound up in literally every exhibit we did.  I really felt, after the first three times I noticed this, that I had to keep the twins closer to me.  When approached by security, he left in a quick-fast hurry.

A couple out enjoying themselves at a park?  Not so suspicious - it's a free date!  The man standing by himself in the bushes staring at random kids?  I'm calling security.  

December 2, 2008 12:04 PM
 

diera said:

I agree with the previous poster; I think it's less about the child predators and more about the homeless people who might be hanging around drinking around of paper bags.  I am all against the culture of fear, so I get the good doctor's indignation, but in this case I don't see the big deal of saying that the playground is for kids and the adults with them.  It's when the whole PARK is supposed to be only for kids and kid-safe activities that I'd get upset.

December 2, 2008 12:06 PM
 

Janice said:

I live in San Francisco, too.  The maintenance person at one playground told me not to let my kid in the sandbox without shoes because he routinely finds needles.  Several of the playgrounds in the neighborhood have been badly vandalized.  I think that's the main reason for the sign, to keep the playgrounds physically safe for the kids.

Which is not to say fear of predators is unfounded.  When I was a little girl a man tried to molest me at the playground.  This was back in the '70's when we were allowed to go alone.  So fear of predators at playgrounds is not hysterical.  It's a reality that they are out there.

December 2, 2008 2:23 PM
 

Knitty said:

Oh simmer down, Erin.  First, the blogger does not have to live in NYC to have an opinion on a policy there.  And as for your paranoia for the "old man" in your park, maybe you ought to check your prejudices there.  It's about 1000000x more likely that he's simply enjoying watching the little ones than hatching the sort of nafarious evil the media has led us to believe every stranger is secretly cooking up.

December 2, 2008 2:24 PM
 

BBBGMOM said:

Oh god.  When I am an old lady I hope none of you calls the cops when I rest for twenty minutes on the bench by the playground after my morning walk.  Jesus H Christ.  

December 2, 2008 3:29 PM

About Miriam Axel-Lute

Miriam Axel-Lute is a freelance writer, editor, poet, and urban planning junkie. She lives, works, and gardens in Albany, NY, with her two partners and daughter.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage