Strollerderby

A Guy’s Take on Stay at Home Moms and Dads (Part 1: The Cons)

Posted by Cole Gamble

Recently my wife went back to school and finished up a bachelor’s degree in psychology. She was thrilled. I was thrilled. Even the damn pets were thrilled. The party, however, ended abruptly when Nicole realized she was, with her still hot from the oven degree in hand, entering the most hostile job market in generations. That’s when she introduced an intriguing proposition. “Hey, how about I keep the kids at home for awhile? If I can’t get a job now, I might as well take them out of child care and be a stay-at-home mom.” This was coming from a woman who started her college career on an education degree track, but then realized she didn’t like kids. This was different though. These were our kids, and your own kids are always infinitely lovelier than other peoples’ kids.

 

Throughout Nicole’s stay-at-home adventure, we’ve learned a lot about her personality, our kids’ personalities and the realities of staying at home with kids. Here are some of the lessons we learned, starting with the cons. In part two we’ll cover the pros and at the end I’ll let you in on what eventually happened to Nicole and how staying at home (I've heard SAH parent is the term for those in the know) has worked out for her.

 

The Cons:

 

Loneliness

Workplaces feed you daily social interaction with adults that we probably all take for granted. Once their daily routine revolves around the kid(s), many stay-at-home parents find themselves isolated. Some turn their child into their best friend, which at times puts the child in a peculiar situation as mommy or daddy gradually engages Jr. in too grown-up talk.

 

Loss of Identity via Loss of Career

I personally try not to define myself by my work (there are just too many more important aspects of personality), but I cannot deny all of us in the workplace to some degree merge our work into our self-esteem and identity. When you break that source of identity off, you can definitely feel that loss. People also crave the positive feedback one gets from the workplace and approbation is not something you usually get out of a screaming toddler or diaper full of crap.

 

Hard to Get Back to Work

Many parents find it’s tough to rejoin the job market after a sustained sabbatical.

 

You Can’t Provide the Activity and Socializing a Good Day Care/Preschool Can:

Hey, you’re a super stay-at-home parent. You go above and beyond the call of duty; you’re a total parenting rock star. Nonetheless, you still can’t compete with a child care program when it comes to activities and socializing. Good programs jam pack your child’s day with fun and educational projects.  Also, you can’t underestimate the value of exposing your child to their peers on a daily basis. Interacting with other kids is essential for a child’s emotional and intellectual development. Yes, you can get them out of the house and around kids at the park, but you probably can’t offer them a whole class of kids working, playing and learning together every day.

 

Loss of Income

Yep, you do save money on child care when you keep the kids at home, but more likely than not that saved money isn’t as much as the income you lose by extracting yourself from work.

 

How About Losing 1 Million Dollars?

That's the amount economists say  the stay-at-home parent who relinquishes a career may lose about $1 million over the years., when you factor in benefits and pensions. Yee-ouch!  

 

Housework and Child Care Can Be Boring and Frustrating

Okay, hold your tomatoes, don’t throw them just yet. I’m not saying parenthood is boring, I’m just saying the diaper changing and tackling endless loads of laundry can be tedious and wearisome. A lot of this is about personality. I know women (and guys) who gain a great deal of satisfaction from mopping the floor and wiping noses. But just because other parents enjoy it doesn’t mean you must as well. You have to be honest with yourself.

 

 

Okay, enough doom and gloom. Let’s move on to the positives of staying home.

 

Click here for PART 2: The Pros.

 

 

More by this author:

Banana Dildos and the 10 Worst Toys and Gifts This Christmas (part 1)

Gangsta’ Muppets: 12 of the Best Kids Show/Rap Mash-Ups

The Worst Baby Products Ever (Part I)

Desert Island Disks – Kid Music Edition

10 Things You May Not Know About Pregnancy (and might shock you)


The 26 Most Disturbing Kids Movies Ever
+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Knitty said:

I sincerely doubt that most mothers who stay home with their kids are forfeiting 1M dollars.  I mean, get real!  Unless your job is something very lucrative, you're probably not making all that much during the years before your child goes to school if you take into account daycare (especially for multiple children), meals purchased out, gas to get to the job, professional clothing needed, etc.  A parent who stays home to care for the children but also cooks from scratch, bakes bread, gardens, etc. can actually save his/her family a tremendous amount of money.  Additionally, most parents who stay home while the kids are little return once they're older... so once again, no way are they forfeiting a million bucks.  

December 4, 2008 12:23 PM
 

Cole Gamble said:

I know, a million dollars sounds astronomical but that is the figure the study came up with.

December 4, 2008 1:10 PM
 

another_mom said:

If you're not talking about spending, it's very easy to lose a million dollars in salary (before taxes, at least).  Some simple math: a woman stops working at age 30 when she is making $45,000 a year.  Multiply that by 30 years (assuming she retires at age 60), and you have $1.35 million.  That doesn't even include pension, benefits, or any pay raises.  

December 4, 2008 2:02 PM
 

Sukey said:

A good read on this topic is The Price of Motherhood by Ann Crittenden, a former New York Times reporter and a Pulitzer Prize nominee.  The economic sacrifice, or what she calls the "Mommy Tax", is stunning.  However grossly unfair, baking bread just doesn't bring home the bacon.

December 4, 2008 2:26 PM
 

Cole Gamble said:

maybe you could sell the bread.

December 4, 2008 2:58 PM
 

gpgirl said:

Great post. We went through all of these questions before I decided to stay home with our son. For me, it is a great decision, but I do understand the costs.

One thing is that I really did not enjoy the job I had at the time I had my baby, so it was easy to leave. I was in a fairly high position, so in that sense it was difficult because of the loss of a high income. However, I was expected to work long hours and be available at all times. With the hours I was working, I would literally never see my son during the week. (He would wake up after I would have to leave and would go to bed before I came home.) That was just too much for me.

If I wanted to take a lower position with fewer hours, that was not allowed either. In the end, this is probably good for me, because when I go back into the workforce I'll be able to take a position that requires fewer hours, even if it pays less, and that will be OK with me. (I am totally one of those people who were ready to leave the rat race!)

I should mention that I was in my late 30's when I had my son, so I felt like I already accomplished a lot when I quit. If I was younger, I might have felt that I was missing out on something. This is just the case for me, I know everyone is different.

Also, I totally believe the loss of $1 million. It is not just the money you are not making while staying at home, but the potential earnings lost by being out of the workforce, and then coming back to a lower paying job.

December 4, 2008 6:46 PM
 

Mike Adamick (Cry It Out!) said:

Great post! I can totally see the million dollars easy, what with salary, bennies and deflated 401k contributions and gains. And the boring, yikes. Have you ever played chutes and ladders 57 times in a row? I like your take on identity -- it's so much more than just what we do for work.

December 5, 2008 11:47 AM

About Cole Gamble

Cole Gamble’s writings on the crimes of Willy Wonka, man-eating beds and tales from his cringe-worthy life appear here on Babble, the humor site Cracked, The Daily Beast, The Huffington Post and Salon. He is working on a book entitled, Conquer Everything! A Self Help Book to Destroy All Other Self Help Books and Grant You Mastery in Everything.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage