Strollerderby

No Good Choices in Child Care Debate

Posted by Amy Kuras

It’s a familiar paradox to every parent who works outside the home – childcare costs so much that sometimes it just makes more sense to stay home, even if that’s not what you would really prefer to do –and that’s if you can find a spot in a halfway decent center.

So I thought this brief blog post from the Seattle Post-Intelligencer’s Working Dad, Paul Nyhan, to be interesting. He stated that on average, child care center directors – that is, the people running the show – make 35 percent less than kindergarten teachers. You know the people who have the most direct contact with the kids make much less. And 17 percent of all family-owed child care centers have closed in the last five years.

Something like half of all kids are regularly in child care, he states – although I don’t know if that number includes just kids who are in full time daycare or those who go to Grandma’s every afternoon or preschool two mornings a week.

He points out a fundamental disconnect between supply and demand – that child care workers often don’t make a decent wage, but parents struggle to pay for it. I wonder why that is, although I have a few theories.

One is that child care has traditionally been women’s work, and we generally undervalue anything traditionally done by women, like teaching and clerical work and so on.

And I think it’s also a fundamental discomfort in this county with the idea of women’s economic power. There’s a strong cultural bias against middle class women who work outside the home if they have young children, but the feds mandate only a paltry three months unpaid maternity leave. Other countries offer one year, paid, minimum, so mothers of babies don’t have to go back to work right about the time they are beginning to feel somewhat good at the baby care gig.

All I know is, I envy my friends who have on site child care at their jobs, or free and loving grandma care. Because for the rest of us, the choices suck.







+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

gpgirl said:

I know some other countries over a year maternity leave, but not as many as we think. I know in France, you get 4 months leave (and yes, it is paid). However, they do have state-subsidized child-care. In addition, an employer has to let a woman with a young child work part time if she wishes. (She can reduce her schedule as low as 3 days a week, with salary adjusted of course.) I think this really is the key. I decided to stay home with my son (here in the US). However, there was no middle ground for me. I worked a job with long hours, and I saw other moms struggling and being made to feel like slackers if they worked less than 10 to 12 hours a day. If I continued working, I would never see my son during the week. (Yes, literally, never. He wakes up after I would have to leave for work and goes to bed before I normally came home.)

Of course, I was extremely lucky that we could afford to get by on one income. For the people I know who go back to work, either they can barely afford day care or, if they can afford more, they hire a nanny. I think this is why salaries at day care remain low.

December 15, 2008 5:58 PM
 

Sparkiy said:

Stories like this make me glad I found a good affordable daycare one block from work, but I still wish I could stay home longer.

December 15, 2008 7:22 PM
 

Mary said:

Can I ask an honest, dumb question? If I'm paying $3,200 a month for daycare and the people running the place aren't making any money, where does all that cash GO?

December 16, 2008 2:36 PM
 

sghn said:

@ Mary: A lot of that money goes into insurance. I worked in a K-5 after school care/summer day camp years ago, and the director carried a liability policy that would pay out up to 2 million. She pointed to the day care scare stories of the 1980s as part of the reason for the size of the payout - despite being extremely prudent in her hiring, she needed the policy for licensing.

December 16, 2008 3:01 PM
 

Avimom said:

@ Mary:

If it's an accredited center, the accreditation process itself is very expensive.  In addition, to meet licensing requirements' child-staff ratios, you have to have alot of staff...your tuition has to be spread out among many staff members.  

December 16, 2008 3:32 PM
 

Manjari said:

And let's not forget that a private day care is a business. Some of that money has to be profit.

December 17, 2008 12:02 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage