Strollerderby

Smackdown: Sex Before Twenty? Hopefully Not My Kids

Posted by Shannon LC Cate

I am not a believer in abstinence-only sex "education."  I think chastity balls are unrealistic at best and creepy as all get out at worst.  I have no interest in telling girls and women that having sex diminishes their value as a human being.  It's pretty obvious that whatever complications sex may entail can be avoided by avoiding sex.  One hardly needs a class in school to figure that one out.  All I can assume then, is that these abstinence-only classes, virginity pledges and the like are really about moral judgement and shame.

Being against moral judgement and shame, I'm all for real sex education. I want my kids to know all there is to be known about sex and its consequences, about relationships and how to recognize a dangerous one and how to maintain a healthy one.  I'd like my girls to know all of this information, file it in their brains and then not use it until they are out of their teens (like I did).

First of all, some may say this is a pipe dream, that teenagers do and will have sex.  But actually, less than half (46%) of teens between 15 and 19 have had "sex" at least once.  For nineteen year olds, the figure is still only 70%.  That's a far cry from "everybody does it."  And while I do believe every child should be prepared with the knowledge and healthcare access that assumes teen sexual activity, I hope my children don't choose to engage in serious sexual relationships (or, for that matter, fleeting ones) before they are at least 20, even with proper contraception at their fingertips.

Why?  Because sexual relationships--especially first ones--tend to be highly energy consuming and emotionally draining.  Sexual relationships assume (I am talking here only about voluntary sexual relationships) a serious investment of interest, time and concern in another human being--the sexual partner--and I'd like my girls to be a little more self-centered in their youth.  I want my girls to have ample opportunity to explore who they are, what they love about themselves and about life before they get bogged down with Hollywood's version of love--a romantic, sexual relationship.  I fear that too much time and energy spent on a sexual partner will rob them of time and energy they could be spending developing real knowledge of themselves; real love for themselves.  And I think it's this kind of knowledge and love of self that can make for better relationships when they do happen.

In this day and age, in the socio-economic class my girls inhabit, people don't settle down until their mid-twenties or later.  There is just no need for serious courtships and relationship practice in high school.

Girls and women learn fast enough that society values them most for what they can offer others.  And while I want my girls to be generous, I want their generosity to flow from a full place within themselves, a place I'd like them to take some time to fill.

See Also: Smackdown: I Don't Care if my Daughter Has Sex as a Teen


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

chochomom said:

You make some excellent arguments Shannon, but I think that this should extend to boys as well. Boys need to learn about themselves, and expend their energy on developing their characters rather than doing dumb, and sometimes fatally dangerous, things to get a girl. Despite their bravado, sexual relationships affect them just as much as it does the girls. I believe there is some research to that shows this too, but I'm too lazy to find it right now :)

The best way to prevent your daughters from being pressured into things that they are not ready for is to address the other side of this equation as well.

January 22, 2009 10:29 AM
 

Knitty said:

"There is just no need for serious courtships and relationship practice in high school."

LOL... you're kidding, right?

January 22, 2009 12:42 PM
 

Shannon LC Cate said:

chochomom: I have no double standards.  I just don't have any boys myself.  If I did, I'd feel the same way.

knitty: no, really.  I just don't think kids need to "go steady" at 16.  Personally, I didn't even go on a first date until college (no big reason except that I didn't know anyone I wanted to date before that).  I have one divorce and one good marriage to show for it.  Not much different than a good portion of the population.

January 22, 2009 1:03 PM
 

Abstinence Rules said:

My and husband and I were both virgins when we got married at 25 yrs of age (in the mid-90s). It can happen.  And, no, I wasn't locked up in my bedroom.  It was one of the BEST decisions I've ever made in my life.  

January 22, 2009 1:15 PM
 

PhoenixRising said:

Shannon, I can't disagree with the notion that high school romance is too time consuming and draining for kids.

However, I think that many of today's teens are responding to their natural, God-given urge to have sex in ways that fit less with my family's values than the high school romance: by establishing 'hook-up' or friends with benefits relationships that are less like practicing for marriage than the dating rituals we were expected to undergo in the 80s.

I'm not sure that I want my little girl to head off to college with a handful of sexual experiences and no practice in managing her time and energy in a relationship--which is what I'm seeing my teen cousins doing. Their parents are happy because the girls didn't date in HS. I'm not so sure that's a victory for anything I want to fight for, knowing what they did instead.

My kid just turned 9 and is in love with tall dark and handsome. He stands 17 hands, weighs 1400 pounds and can clear a 2'6" pole with a foot to spare. If this romance continues for 6 more years we'll be past the trouble, I hope.

January 22, 2009 1:55 PM
 

Shannon LC Cate said:

Just to clarify, I'm fully aware that I won't be in control of my kids' sexuality.  I don't believe we can "make" them choose one thing or another.  I just hope they choose a certain thing.  It's almost silly to argue about what kids should do, since they will do what they want.

January 22, 2009 2:00 PM
 

Barb said:

From my experience in college, the girls I knew who were more sexually inexperienced in high school went crazy in college. The freedom of living down the hall from boys, in addition to not having parents to report in to every night was too new for them; I saw a lot of them making bad choices and getting hurt (emotionally) over it. Not that this is how it is for every girl, or that girls who fool around more in high school don't make these mistakes, but in my experience, it was the "high school prudes" who were more wild.  

I feel like it's more important to teach our girls to be smart about their decisions than to have expectations that they'll be afraid to admit they didn't live up to. I think having a lot of rules, "You can't date seriously until you're 20," just makes girls more rebellious when they're given a little bit of freedom.

January 22, 2009 2:14 PM
 

Knitty said:

I'm laughing because while you clearly don't think teen dating is important, I can guarantee your kids are going to feel differently.  And I really can't think of a better way to make that teen relationship the most important thing in their lives than mommy trying to discourage it.

January 22, 2009 3:11 PM
 

Shannon LC Cate said:

knitty, see comment above.  I already concede that I can't control my kids' sexuality.  And I didn't say anything about making rules.  I said I HOPE my children CHOOSE a certain way.

And you can't guarantee teen dating will be important to my kids.  It wasn't important to me nor to many, many of my close friends.

You're talking to someone who isnt me.  I realize there's a certain script out there about teens and sex, but if you'll read what I've written carefully, you won't find it.

January 22, 2009 3:18 PM
 

theresa said:

Totally with you on sex education (should I say education about sexuality?) should be far more than abstinence based. Most current classes either in schools or churches offer little. Some are pathetically inaccurate and incomplete. The best education I found is believe it or not, at the Unitarian Universalist Church. In their 8th grade curriculum, they cover all of the bases...decision making, healthy choices, relationships, just about everything. Clearly not an abstinence only program.

And I agree about the kids who have little to no information. Going off to college is incredibly risky for those kids. They are not only experimenting sexually but they are easily more at risk for abusive type situations.

-theresa (teacher of raging hormonal 7th graders and former resident director of dorm)

January 22, 2009 3:22 PM
 

Life in the Bend said:

I didn't date until I was 17 because I just wasn't that interested in anyone. I've often been glad that I had those years of high school to develop on my own without the influence of "relationships". As it happened, I ended up marrying my second boyfriend ever, who I met at eighteen. We dated long distance through college and, again, I'm grateful that I had those college years of having a social life in which I was free to socialize without being connected to a boyfriend.

You're right that we can't control the choices our kids make, but I would be perfectly happy if my kids didn't date until college!

January 22, 2009 4:05 PM
 

Melly said:

I don't know.   Like a commenter said above, the girls I knew in college who had never dated in high school seemed to make the worst choices.  Choices including losing their virginity just to say they did, being in really bad relationships, etc.  I had a stereotypically lame, drama-filled relationship with a high school boyfriend and went on to meet the guy who would later become my husband while I was in college.  I felt that I could be mature and realistic while dating my husband because I had learned a lot in my first relationship.  I'm SO glad my first boyfriend distracted me during high school (which was somewhat shitty anyway) and not during college.

Your views here probably depend a lot on your own experiences...

January 22, 2009 4:22 PM
 

Pollyanna Sunshine said:

I'm not sure whether you do or don't have sex necessarily affects the amount of headspace it takes up or the amount of psychodrama that it involves--in my adolescence, NOT having sex was a major source of drama in its own right.  Everything you say about relationships being emotionally draining and getting sucked into warped Hollywood fantasies can be just as true for kids who don't have sex, and even for those who don't date.  And at the same time, there are kids who have sex in high school who managed to be remarkably healthy and balanced about it (as well as those who were totally screwed up about it).  And frankly, waiting until my 20s to have sex meant that I went through a lot more drama over sex at that time than I might otherwise have.  I think this is an issue that really varies widely.  But I am in total agreement about comprehensive sex ed, because it's info most people need eventually, no matter how old they are or whether they are married or not.

January 22, 2009 5:19 PM
 

gpgirl said:

I totally agree with you, Shannon. Of course we can't force our kids not to have sex, but I do hope my son waits until he is a bit older.

I was a relatively late bloomer at 19. The only reason I really did it then was because I felt like some kind of prudish freak. It was much less about sexual discovery than being excepted. I love this post because it says it is OK to wait. According to movies, TV, etc., if you don't have sex by the time you are 16, there must be something wrong with you.

@Barb - I think the girls you are talking about were kept locked up by their parents. That is different from girls making choices for themselves. I was a top student in HS, and almost all of my friends graduated from HS before having sex. None of them went crazy in college, and we all have healthy relationships today.

I for one am really glad I kept my innocence a little longer, being able to concentrate on other aspects/adventures of growing up. Now, I am sure there are girls who are just ready and curious about sex earlier, and that is fine. I just don't think there should be so much pressure to have sex so early.

January 22, 2009 9:47 PM
 

Shannon LC Cate said:

Yeah, I didn't go crazy in college either.  In any respect.  I never got drunk in my life until I was 20 and that was just because I didn't know my limits.  Once I figured that out, it never happened again.

And I wasn't kept under lock and key by my parents.  They were pretty hands off about my social life.  I just had other things going on that interested me more.

None of my friends were "crazy" in college either and most of them waited longer than I did.

January 22, 2009 10:44 PM
 

Allie said:

I wouldn't want to generalise about *when* sexual relationships will/will not be a good idea for my children.  I think this depends almost entirely on the relationships involved.  Personally, I learned a lot from sexual relationships before I was twenty and first had sex with my current partner when I was nineteen.  Given that we have now been together for more than seventeen years, I'm glad I didn't let her get away!

January 23, 2009 9:19 AM
 

Tam said:

I didn't date until I was done with my first degree - it wasn't a religious decision, I just saw my friends heading off to the clinic with pregnancy scares and STD scares and weeping hysterically because the twenty-year-old guy they were besotted with had broken their heart AGAIN, and decided that all of that would be fatally distracting to my schoolwork.  (I needed to get and then maintain my scholarships.)  I also didn't want to have sex until it wouldn't be a complete disaster if I accidentally fell pregnant, which seems only logical to me but apparently crazy to other people.  

Anyway, I waited, chose very carefully, and three years later, wound up married to the guy in question.  I also hope that my kid waits until they're at least out of high school before starting a sexual relationship, if only because I think that the baggage which attends said relationships is an awful lot to deal with at sixteen or so.

January 25, 2009 6:57 AM

About Shannon LC Cate

Shannon LC Cate, PhD is a lesbian housewife and work-from-home mother of two girls via domestic, open, transracial adoption. They are both under five and already too brilliant and beautiful for their own good. Shannon lives, writes and assembles tricycles in Chicago, Illinois.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage