Strollerderby

Does Obama's Election Mean Black Kids Now Have "No Excuses"?

Posted by Kate Tuttle

Op-ed contributor Charles Blow, writing in the New York Times, recently assailed comments by South Carolina Congressman James Clyburn that, in a post-Obama age, "every child has lost every excuse." In other words, if a blak man can become president, you -- black child, Latino child, poor child -- can scale every mountain, too. I can see what Clyburn meant, that his aim was to both exhort and inspire (and he spoke these words at a BET event, which I think is significant), but Blow's right: "no excuses" is a vast overstatement of how even the playing field now is. 

The statistics Blow cites can make you cry: 60% of black kids grow-up in low-income homes, half of them in what the government offically calls "poor" households (believe me, what the Feds call poor is several steps more grim than what you or I would). Black kids are twice as likely as their white and Latino counterparts to be the victims of mistreatment, ranging from neglect to physical abuse. They are far more likely to be raped. 

I don't think it's an excuse to say that the circumstances in which a child grows up have an overwhelming influence on her or his opportunities to lead a happy, healthy life. Nor do I think that acknowledging the inequalities that still exist in our society is in any way throwing a damper on the incredibly inspiring story of Obama's rise to the presidency, nor on the real-world solutions all of us hope his adminstration can bring to bear on them. And while I like Clyburn's old-school call for kids to overcome whatever obstacles they face, I cringe at how a slogan like "no excuses" sounds in the mouth not of a black warrior for equal rights, but yet another clueless white conservative pundit. So yes, I hope that President Obama means, among many other things, that nobody will ever again assume a black child can't get there, but I also hope it means we can all work together to improve the chances that she or he will be able to. 

And besides, it didn't seem to me as if having a President Bush in office prompted academically sub-par rich white kids to stop making excuses. 

 

Related: 

Teacher Wants to Drop Huck Finn, To Kill a Mockingbird, "For Obama"

 

More by this author:

Would You Toilet-Train Your Child On National TV?

Biracial Twins -- Is One "Black" and One "White"?

Death by Peanut: Epidemic or Urban Myth?

Is This Baby Obese? Aussie Mom Says No

 

 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Melissa said:

I agree with you.  Children of any race, color or creed who grow up in poverty suffer a huge blow to their ability to succeed in life.  Children of more affluent and/or educated parents benefit from better nutrition, better education and more time spent on enrichment activities from birth on.  This gives them a huge advantage.  

Obama's family weren't rich, but his mother was educated and made sure that he was well educated.  It's not really the same thing as the at-risk children that are the result of poverty and poorly-educated parents.

January 26, 2009 11:27 AM
 

Laure68 said:

I totally agree that poor children in this country grow up at a huge disadvantage. I don't want to dismiss what Barrack Obama was able to do. However, his father came from another country, so he does not have the heavy weight of history on his shoulders. He was also raised by a white, middle-class family. Although his mother was single, his grandparents did a lot.

A more appropriate role model might be Michelle Obama, who actually grew up on the south side of Chicago. She did have a very stable family life, though, and you really can't compare her to kids who grow up in an unstable situation. I just think that people sometimes forget how amazing her story really is.

And I totally agree about rich white kids complaining. I can't believe how many rich white men tell me how unfair life is to them. Then I learn they partied their way through school, barely passed, and have a top position and make tons of money. I never understand where this complaining comes from.

January 26, 2009 12:27 PM
 

MailDeadDrop said:

Laurie68 wrote: "I never understand where this complaining comes from."

I dunno. Maybe from people making broad generalizations about people based on immutable aspects, such as "rich white men".

Pot, meet kettle.

MDD

January 26, 2009 12:50 PM
 

Laure68 said:

@MDD, eh? I wasn't make any kind of generalization. I am not saying that all rich white men are like this. I am just stating that I have met a lot of privileged white men who say one, or both, of the folloing

- "Minorities get so many breaks - it is not fair to the rest of us"

- "Those people, like janitors, with menial jobs, they really have the life. My job is so hard. I wish I could live like they do" (this statement is often made over dinner at a pricey restaurant. Seriously, I am not making this up.)

I actually am white, and I know I have a quite a few advantages because of that. I can't ever imagine saying I am disadvantaged because I am white. I grew up in a very mixed neighborhood, and my friends that were not white had to work much harder just to make it, and then they get comments about how affirmative action must have really helped them. It really is like a double edge sword.

January 26, 2009 10:44 PM

About Kate Tuttle

I'm raising a toddler and a teenager in a leafy suburb just outside Boston. In between having kids I've been an editor and writer, most recently with the African American National Biography and the late great Africana.com.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage