Strollerderby

Smackdown: Boob Nazis - Is Breastfeeding that Big A Deal? NO!

Posted by Cole Gamble

By now you’re probably thinking, “Why are two DUDES arguing the merits of breastfeeding? Where do they get off?!” Well, here’s where I get off (that sounds weird): I offered to tackle this subject with any of the ladies at Strollerderby and they were all too scared. The ladies were too scared to argue about breastfeeding. That’s why, for better or worse, you’ve got Brett and me. What would we know about it? We have children and wives who birthed them, don’t we? We were first hand throughout the breastfeeding process and we did the research right along with our partners. So, I’m gonna say we’re qualified.

 

My biggest beef with some of the breastfeeding advocates is guilt. I’m not a big fan of guilt as a motivator and I’m even less of a fan of fear tactics. You know, like that pro-breastfeeding commercial that had a heavily pregnant woman thrown from a mechanical bull—equating that with not breastfeeding. I’ve also got no love for bullying, as in the La Leche League member who met my wife at a party and upon learning breastfeeding didn’t work for my wife, ended the conversation, turned on a dime and proceeded to belittle my wife throughout the rest of the party. (This woman is still breastfeeding her 5-year-old. Let that sink in)

 

But my appeal here won’t be emotional. That’s too easy. I’m gonna give you the facts. The cold hard facts that boob pushers and breast bullies obfuscate or completely deny.

 

1)      Mastitis. An inflammation of the mammary gland occurring in lactating mothers. Nipple can get infected and turn into an abscess that must be surgically removed. Although this can occur in non-breastfeeding women, it’s more likely in breast feeders.

2)      The Psychological Benefits are False. The conventional wisdom was breastfeeding led to a more focused, less hyperactive child adept at forming peer relations. However, an exhaustive study recently proved these assumptions wrong.  Experts and laymen presumed that the constant physical closeness involved with breastfeeding would do all kinds of psychological wonders. Nope.

3)      B-Milk in the Bottle is Just as Good. Some women can’t get their kids to latch. Some women simply don’t like the feeling of breast feeding. No problem, just pump a bit of that magic elixir and give it to junior via bottle. Not only is there no shame in it, but now that we know the physical act of breast feeding comes with no special benefits, the bottle is more acceptable than ever.

4)      Where’s the D? This news is hot off the presses: there is insufficient vitamin D in breast milk. A lack of vitamin D can lead to rickets. So, if you breast feed, your kid will become a pirate.

5)      You Should Never Do Anything Just Because of Peer Pressure. Like I said above, breast feeding is a choice. If you want to get a little breast milk to your kid but can’t or don’t want the suckling, that’s your business. And if you don’t want to do it at all, you are not abusing your child.

 

 

The Other Side and More BF articles:

Smackdown: Breastfeeding -- Why Not?

Smackdown: Damned if You Do, Doomed if you Don't

5 Things That Make You a Breastfeeding Nazi . . . And 5 Things That Don’t

More by this Author:

Should You Take A Risk on Orgasmic Birth? (Orgasmic Birth Video included)

Anti-Abortion Group Up In Arms Over Krispy Kreme Abortion Donuts

"I Ate Little Black Girls for Two Years"

Bizarro News: Flaming Squirrel Sets Elementary School on Fire

4 Ways Birth and Breastfeeding Will Ruin Sex


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Mike Adamick (Cry It Out!) said:

Blurg - stuff like that LLL anecdote drives me batty. Does anyone think that is useful in any way?

January 27, 2009 10:22 AM
 

JeanneSager said:

Just reporting in that I wasn't scared - just too far in Cole's camp!

Breastfeeding is good for some mothers, and for some it doesn't work - and neither side is the better mother (see Madeline's post).  

So Cole - nanny, nanny, foo foo!!

January 27, 2009 10:58 AM
 

melissa said:

your facts nos 3 and 4 are deceptive or simply wrong. recent research has shown that the act of suckling on the breast is where a lot of the actual benefit comes from. and, while breastmilk is low in vitamin d, it is so easy to get enough from sunlight, there is only a worry in northern latitudes.

January 27, 2009 11:11 AM
 

Cole Gamble said:

I have to invent conflict, Jeanne.

January 27, 2009 1:12 PM
 

Lucy said:

You don't like how some LLL woman judged your wife on something that's doesn't have to do with her yet you judge the same woman because she is still breastfeeding a 5 year old.  What does that have to do with you?

I breastfed for a whole year and am proud of my accomplishment because it was really hard the first couple of months.  I think it's like running the marathon.  Lots of people start not all finish.  A lot drop off for different reasons and some wouldn't even want to run a marathon.  

I don't understand this whole anti-breastfeeding thing.  Breastfeeding is  just a natural thing people have done for centuries.  I am not sure why you can't be happy that I finished a marathon even if it's something you wouldn't want to do.

January 27, 2009 2:26 PM
 

Laure68 said:

Lucy, I think some of us just don't like the judgmental tone of some breastfeeding advocates. It is not that we are anti-breastfeeding.

That being said, I do agree that the author was being judgmental about the woman who nursed her son up to 5 years old. I have absolutely no problem with women who nurse for an extended period of time. However, the author being human, I do think maybe when you are being judged the first reaction is to find something to judge back. It doesn't make sense logically, but humans aren't always logical.

January 27, 2009 4:02 PM
 

karmamama said:

I don't get it - so, you're pro-breastMILK, but just not breastfeeding? Did I read that right? I'm going to take a wild, wild guess and say that you've never used a breastpump on yourself AND you've never breastfed. I've done both, and I can tell you that my experience was that breastfeeding wasn't only faster - and used a lot less stuff I had to wash multiple times a day - but it felt a lot less weird and uncomfortable than hanging out with a plastic suction pump attached to my boob.

As for the mastitis scare tactic, having your boob become so infected that they have to REMOVE YOUR NIPPLE is extraordinarily rare. Usually, if it happens at all, mastitis clears up with a little time, some hot compresses, and some antibiotics if needed.

January 27, 2009 4:12 PM
 

Cole Gamble said:

Perhaps my comment on the La Leche League lady who is still breastfeeding a five-year-old is judgmental. But is your arguement that the practice is entirely healthy for the kid's emotional and social development? Because there we must disagree. Although you've never met the kid. She is the same age as my daughter but acts and speaks like a three-year-old.

January 27, 2009 5:12 PM
 

rs said:

I agree with karmamama that your 'cold hard fact' #1 was misleading.  You are leading the reader to believe that if a person gets mastitis, the only result is surgery.  

January 28, 2009 12:07 AM
 

Manjari said:

When I was teaching kindergarten we had a student who was used to still having a bottle. She was also very much more like a baby than many other students in that she sucked her thumb, wanted to be held a lot, etc. I can see the breastfeeding thing being similar. I definitely think that breastfeeding is good for babies, but I'm just not sure that it is good for school aged children. It's none of my business what other moms do, but I'm just chiming in to agree with Cole that it's maybe not so healthy for a kid's emotional and social development to keep nursing forever. Also, that mom kind of started the judgefest.

January 28, 2009 4:00 PM
 

Amy Kuras said:

I wasn't scared either, Gamble. Like Jeanne, I just thought a smackdown that turned into a "you're right! Why, how right you are!" hugfest might be bit boring for our readers.

And for the record--nursed kid #1 until she started attempting to bite my nipple off, am still nursing kid #2. (neither are yet five). I do, actually, think breast is best. But I also think the breast bullies need a big heapin' helpin' of GET OVER YOURSELF. Not every parent is going to make the choice I would on everything, and most of them are doing a fine job.

January 28, 2009 4:02 PM
 

Joanie said:

I am willing to say out loud that I think there is something unhealthy about nursing a five-year-old child.  I don't understand why people are unwilling to judge that, but totally willing to judge a new mom who wants her husband to be able to feed the baby on occasion... Ah, whatever.  I guess I will always be in the minority here.  Fortunately, I get to do whatever I want in my own home!

January 29, 2009 1:37 PM
 

LuluBelle said:

As a nurse, my observation is that some breastfeeding advocates do less to nurture the child and more to make the mother feel inadequate and self-loathing. While we do teach the mother to breastfeed, and reinforce that it is a natural process, if they aren't comfortable with it then it isn't going to work, period. Pumping and feeding with breastmilk or using non cow milk formula are good alternatives and no new mother should be chastised for that decision.

January 30, 2009 12:35 AM

About Cole Gamble

Cole Gamble’s writings on the crimes of Willy Wonka, man-eating beds and tales from his cringe-worthy life appear here on Babble, the humor site Cracked, The Daily Beast, The Huffington Post and Salon. He is working on a book entitled, Conquer Everything! A Self Help Book to Destroy All Other Self Help Books and Grant You Mastery in Everything.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage