Strollerderby

Boys Can Babysit Too

Posted by Amy Kuras

 When you think about giving the neighbor kid a call to babysit, are you thinking of a girl or a boy?

Most of us are thinking about a girl. There are lots of reasons for that – we certainly sill see childcare as women’s work, and some of us just don’t trust males around our children, which is sad. There’s still an outdated notion that a man who takes interest in children who aren’t his has some sort of creepy motive, when people don’t generally think the same about females.

Which is too bad for all the teen boys out there who would make fabulous sitters. Certainly on my husband’s side of the family where all the nieces and nephews except ours are in their teens and 20s, it’s the boys who are most likely to be holding or playing with our kids and if any of them lived closer, we’d be hiring them for child care regularly. And my dad iss as likely to take care of my kids as my mom is.

That’s why I liked this story about a group of Boy Scouts getting babysitter training from the Red Cross as part of a badge program. It’s the same certification that girls receive,, and qualifies them to babysit for younger kids. Unlike other classes, though, this one was all-male, which gave the boys a chance to see that they were not alone in being interested in caring for kids.

They learned how to change diapers, feed babies and market themselves to parents.

How do you feel about boy babysitters? Are you fine with it, or do you feel more comfortable with girls?


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Ashers mom said:

My husband's cousin is our babysitter-and he is a boy.  I trust him more than his older sister.

February 3, 2009 6:38 PM
 

Jen said:

I definitely feel more comfortable with girls.  I know that this isn't fair to the buys out there who would make great babysitters, and I know I'm generalizing, but the statistics show that more child abusers are male, and I'm not willing to take that chance with my children.

February 3, 2009 6:59 PM
 

Sue said:

Any story I've heard about in my extended family (and most every story I read) involving child molestation, was done by a male. No one usually knew it but they started in their teens. I know I should be all equal-rightsy on this, but I have only hired girls to babysit.

February 3, 2009 7:22 PM
 

Kikiriki said:

When my sister and I were little, we were babysat by various siblings from one family, including the teenage brother, who was pretty much the most fun babysitter of the bunch.  He was great.  However, my cousin hired a male teenager to babysit her sons, and then found out he had tried to touch them and expose himself to them.  So I'm not sure what I'd do - maybe if I really, really trusted the family I'd let the boy babysit, but only if my kids were old enough to speak if something happened.

February 3, 2009 7:32 PM
 

snorkmaiden said:

I find the notion that people wouldn't hire a male babysitter because "most child abusers/pedophiles are male" to be utterly ridiculous.  It's one of those classic examples of people getting worked about sickos harming their children when the majority of sexual abuse is committed by family members, and there are far more likely and pressing dangers facing your children (like getting in a car accident while you eat/drink coffee/talk on your it's-hands-free-so-it-must-be-safe cellphone).

February 3, 2009 8:45 PM
 

Shannon LC Cate said:

The two most regular babysitters I've had have been male.  In fact, they've been gay men.  They are both awesome.  One lived with us for about two years after my daughter was born.

More men than women may be abusers, but that doesn't mean men are abusers, period.

I trust my gut when it comes to baby sitters.  I don't care what a resume says, let alone statistics.  Let me meet the person and then I'll make my call.

My girls have two moms.  Both of them consider visits from uncles and playing with male baby sitters to be a treat.

February 3, 2009 8:53 PM
 

Alice said:

A few years ago in my hometown there was a horrific case of a teen boy, a dear friend of the family, who raped and murdered a 2 year old girl he was babysitting. Turns out he had been raping her for months. It was so sad. She was the miracle baby they had waited so long for and he was the only son of a prominent family.  The cops said when they took her to the ER it made them weep how badly she was abused.  Sorry, I trust girls to not rape my children not boys.

February 3, 2009 9:17 PM
 

Terra said:

When I was a child, around 6 or 7, my parents hired a male babysitter for me.  He was the son of some friends and around the age of 13.  He had no sisters and apparently had an avid curiosity of what "a girl looks like."  After putting me to bed he snuck back into my room, lifted the blankets and my nightgown and tried to take a peek.   I woke up to him pulling my panties down. He didn't touch or do anything beyond look at me but it was unnerving none-the-less. I told my parents who in turn talked to his parents.  I don't believe he was a pervert or anything but just a curious boy with an opportunity.   I doubt I'll ever hire a male babysitter for my daughter!  Or at least a male between about 12 -15 with raging hormones and a wild curiousity!

February 3, 2009 10:45 PM
 

Em said:

Whenever this discussion is brought up, I get so, so angry. There are abuse men and abusive women. No matter what, a parent should always be on the lookout for any kind of abuse from their childcare provider.

I would absolutely love to have a loving male caregiver for my son. I think all children need to have as many positive role models of both genders in their lives, and I think that is especially important for boys.

Finally, what are you teaching your children by not letting a male watch them? That all men are bad? That men cannot have positive relationships with kids?

Sorry, I'm a bit fried tonight so my argument is a bit vague, but there it is, nonetheless. :)

February 3, 2009 10:59 PM
 

Knitty said:

OMG Alice, that might be the most horrible thing I've ever read.  It makes me not want to leave my child with anyone, ever (which I basically don't, aside from family members.)

February 3, 2009 11:08 PM
 

ShaLO said:

I had a male babysitter when I was five who watched porn and masturbated in front of me. On the other hand, I had a female babysitter who left the house with me and dropped me off a some stranger's house so she could go see her boyfriend. I was missing for several hours and my parents were hysterical. For these, and many other reasons, I don't plan to hire babysitters. I will rely on my parents and in-laws, as well as close friends and family. If no one is available...looks like I'm staying home.

February 4, 2009 7:59 AM
 

Manjari said:

We only leave the kids with relatives too (pretty much just my mom). The problem with this is that we never get out. I am going crazy not having any relief for 2 years, and I think I'm going to have to start trusting someone at some point. I really want to say that I would hire a male babysitter, but I'm not sure.

February 4, 2009 9:23 AM
 

Nicole said:

It's easy to let your fears get the best of you, especially with all the horrors that are committed against children these days.

My 3 & 4 year old boys are lucky to have two sets of grandparents as built in sitters, but love spending time with their uncle, my brother as well as my sister-in-law's bf who is 19. 2 of my best friends in college were gay guys and my boys (as toddlers) adored being babysat by them.

It just depends on the man and how well you know them and their back story.

As far as hiring teenage girls in the future, I have to say I'm just as unsure as hiring teenage boys: teens in general aren't all there in my opinion, but that's just me.

February 4, 2009 11:12 AM
 

Bunny said:

What message do you send to your sons if you don't have males babysit them, because they might molest them? That message, IMO, is, "You, one day, will grow up to be a disgusting pervert who will touch children." Yes, you're also telling them that childcare is women's work, but I think the implication that being male is somehow evil is even more disturbingly sexist than the implication that only women can care for kids.

February 4, 2009 2:54 PM
 

JeanneSager said:

Like Nicole, I often let my brother babysit my daughter - and am so fortunate to have a brother who adores his niece.

By the way - for those so worried about boys molesting their kids, what about the worry that teen girls might beat their toddlers, shake their babies, etc.? Either you find a trustworthy babysitter or you don't; gender has nothing to do with it.

February 4, 2009 4:10 PM
 

Emily D said:

I think that males can be great with children!  I have worked for nearly 7 years with an au pair program.  I have had many successful families who have gone so well with their female au pairs; however, there are issues occasionally with females (and often about personalities).  With my male au pairs - no issues - people are ecstatice - and definitely never a personalitye issue!  If you're interested in an legal au pair, don't hesitate to contact me at emily.davis@lcc.culturalcare.com

February 5, 2009 2:57 AM
 

Jess said:

My husband used to babysit when he was growing up, taking care of his younger sister (who was 10 years his junior) and neighborhood kids. I think that becuase of this he is always great when intereacting with young children, and is comfortable with being nuturing and gentle to them. It is unfortunate that male babysitter = abuser in some people's minds

February 6, 2009 8:37 PM
 

Shannon LC Cate said:

It's interesting that the folks here who say they wouldn't trust a male babysitter DO allow some men--relatives or close friends--to care for their children.  THAT is the very category of person MOST likely to be a molester.  Which just goes to show you that these decisions are not being made based on logic or statistics but by false stereotypes.

February 7, 2009 12:37 PM
 

Erick said:

well said shannon! I agree with you. All you people out there going by statistic's, you should check out the stats on child abuse by family members. You'll be amazed! In such cases family members never thought their own could be capable of such things.....Everyone can be fooled...male...female....is does not matter

February 19, 2009 3:20 PM
 

Paul said:

It really does amuse me when people think that girls would be more responsible than males at babysitting no matter what.  Most cases of child abuse come from people within the family first of all. Secondly, this does not go for all cases of baby sitting, but parents who's child was abused by a babysitter are just down right stupid for choosing that babysitter. No matter what gender, you should look into the person first. If some tragic story happened with a male involved don't stop hiring males. Just be more careful with who you choose, it's sad paranoid pathetic parents who make these generalizations.  Woman always used to complain and still do today about stereotypes against them.  Right now there are a lot of stereotypes against men, but you don't hear any complaining.  The reason behind this is men can stand the fact and don't have to be perfect.  It's funny how it works.

February 22, 2009 11:48 AM
 

Rebecca said:

You can stand it because you haven't lived it every day.

February 26, 2009 10:25 PM
 

smartfather said:

It would be awesome if there was a boy babysitter that we could use. Unfortunately all we ever find are girls. Maybe it's just our location...

March 4, 2009 5:57 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage