Parents have filed suit against the Nevada City
School District after their
twelve-year-old daughter was called out of class by her school counselor and
asked to take a pregnancy test.
The counselor, Steve Davis, had heard through the middle
school grapevine—a very reliable source of information, as we all know—that the
girl was pregnant, and he wanted to see if this was true. The girl (who is naturally
remaining anonymous) explained that she was only the butt of a nasty rumor, but
took a urine test supplied by the school nurse at Davis’ insistence. Lo and behold, the test came
back negative.
My sense, from the limited information we have about the
story, is that Davis was genuinely concerned about the girl—he just acted on
that concern in the most misguided possible manner. If the rumors about the
girl’s pregnancy were so widespread that he felt he had to act on them, he
should have found a way to speak with the girl privately and then he should
have spoken with the classmate she identified as having started the rumor.
Instead, he behaved in a way that humiliated a
12-year-old and enraged her parents—which is why they’re suing the school
district for emotional distress and violation of the right to privacy.
Clearly, no parents would want a school counselor to
intervene in their child’s life in such a thoughtless manner as Davis did. But would you
want your child’s school counselor to gently and skillfully approach her without
your permission if she seemed to be struggling in some way?
Photo: Westridge School (unrelated to this story)