Strollerderby

Teen Girls Fight to Take "Toddlers and Tiaras" Off the Air

A couple of smart, engaged teenage girls from Niagara Falls have gotten some media attention through their efforts to ban the TLC reality TV show, Toddlers and Tiaras—better known to some as, “Scarring Your Children for Life on National TV.”

The high school seniors started a Facebook campaign to ban the show, arguing that it sexualizes children as young as two and encourages pedophilia. The group quickly attracted close to 5,000 members.

TLC has defended the show, saying they are simply depicting—“from an objective and unfiltered perspective”—something that 100,000 kids take place in each year. For someone like me, the show may appear objective in that it succeeds only in making me even more disturbed by parents who are willing to dress their toddlers up like sexy dolls.

But any time a trend gets major press, there are bound to be people who jump on the bandwagon—plus, the young people whom we’re watching being tortured with hair curlers, fake tans, and fake teeth are real children. Tuning in to watch them paraded around like fashion accessories is implicitly supporting their treatment. As long as there is money to be gained by exploiting young kids in this fashion, it will continue to happen.

If I sound melodramatic in my depiction of what these poor children are made to go through, you probably haven’t had the joy watching the show. So, in a paradoxical effort to support the Niagara girls’ Facebook campaign to ban the show, I present you with a short clip of two-year-old Marleigh (pictured), which you can watch here via Jezebel. On the off chance that you then want to add your voice to the call to take the toddler torture off the air, go here.

Photo: Jezebel


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Manjari said:

It's hard to believe that parents do this to their little girls. I just don't get it.

I think you forgot to finish your 3rd paragraph.

March 2, 2009 7:19 PM
 

Shana said:

I totally agree that these pagents are weird, but these kids are not as scarred as you think.  I went to high school with a girl that did pageants from the age of three and was still doing them in high school and she was doing fine.  She was an honor roll student who also was part of the drill team and many school clubs.  You should actually watch Painted Faces a British documentary about pageant kids and they also went and reinterviewed all the girls ten years later and you know what they had their shit together.

The tanning and stuff is horrible to do to kids, but I hardly think these kids are ending up in therapy forever specifically because they were pageant kids.  And the assessment that this somehow encourages is pedophilia is just ridicuous.  They know what pedophiles are right?

March 2, 2009 10:37 PM
 

Alice said:

One of my sisters put herself through law school doing pageants. Most of those kids love doing it.  It is not all bad and you cant make a child participate.  There are benefits for them. They learn public speaking skills, a talent such as dnce or a musical instrument, they learn to compete and lose gracefully.  Later they often represent a platform which they do a lot of work towards.  My sisters' platform was Domestic Violence.  She spoke publically at many forums about the issue, volunteered many hours to shelters and fundraisers and eventually became a lawyer defending the rights of women a children against their batterers.  She brought a serious issue to the public forum.  It is not all about pretty dresses.  Since when is a fake tan abusive?  Not every family eats granola bars, wear Birks and recycles.  Stop being so judgemental. And those children are not behaving in a sexual way at all.  It is a sad day when a child can not prance around dressed pretty because this Puritan nation thinks it s sexy.

March 3, 2009 12:37 AM
 

Allys said:

I think when they say it encourages pedophilia is how the girls are dressed up beyond their ages. It's never right to put make up on girls so young. And one the of the mothers shaving a 6 year old's legs? Just wrong. Nothing against the whole pageant scene, if you wanna be objectified for a good portion of a silly contest, go for it. It's just how at too early of an age these girls are being taught that to be heard and accepted they have to care so much about their appearances.

When I see a mother putting a girl too young to make that choice or are at an age where they just wanna make mommy happy put her child through something like that, I see a woman who is trying to validate herself through "LOOK WHAT A PRETTY GIRL I MADE!! MY GENETICS ARE AMAZING!!". Bah. *steps off soap box*

March 3, 2009 12:51 PM
 

Connie said:

My daughter & I love pageants, Yes they have become over the top with some of the stuff that they do, but it is their choice to put their daughter in a pageant. What gives you the right to say its wrong? I think the Jon Benet' thing just gave pageants a bad name b/c she did do pageants.

There are numerous children that have been molested and abused that do not do pageants. Do you have a theroy of why they were?? It is SICK people out there and your child is not safe no matter what sport you put them in. Perverts are on every corner.

March 3, 2009 1:39 PM
 

Hannah Tennant-Moore said:

Thanks for the heads up, Manjari!  The ending of that paragraph is restored.

March 3, 2009 2:11 PM
 

elohveeee12 said:

i get what you are saying, i have seen the show many times. i do think that some of the things they do to the kids is a little extreme. but in their defense, i dont see the kids objecting. in fact they all seem to very much enjoy it. they love wearing the dresses and the makeup, they love being out on the stage and winning the trophies.

now i would never shave a 5 year olds legs, send them into a tanning bed, make her wear a "flipper", or do up her hair and face like a porcelin china doll. but if the girls like it, i dont see the problem with it.

also, the mothers always say, we are only going to do it until she doesnt want to, the second she says she doesnt want to do pageants, we are done. in one episode, one of the ladies who runs the pageant also mentions that no one but families are allowed in the rooms during the pageant. and because the girls are always running around with their families, they usually only end up performing in front of the judges and their coaches/parents.

honestly the people boycotting the show are not going to do anything. getting it taken off the air is not going to stop the girls from doing pageants. so really what is the point... you wanna make a difference, raise money to cure cancer, help save kids who will probably never get the chance to be in a pageant.

March 10, 2009 12:30 AM
 

bm said:

I absolutly dont see any problem with pageants. If you are a good parent and let your child know that it is just a competition, just like any other sport, what is the harm? As long as it doesnt stem out from pageants..like as long as you dont let them continue with the big hair and fake stuff just in everyday life. I have a 3 MONTH OLD that is doing pageant. She started when she was 2 months...i DO NOT put make-up on her and NO she doesnt know what us going on but i do it to give her an edge.. pageants are confidence boosters and help with self-esteem and gracious losing...and not every parent is like the ones on the show...like myself, and a few others i know. But it is like any other compitition. It calls for preperation and time and money. So i do get as little coo-coo in the days leading up to it. But i would be that way if it was cheerleading or a dance class or softball...or ANYTHING!! It is a sport. And i agree with above comments...pageants are a long-running tradition. They arent going to stop. So accept it..And noone is forcing anyone to watch them! So dont watch it if you dont like it..And i am the same way as most parents involved..as soon as my daughter says 'mom i dont wanna do pageants anymore', then we are done...and that is the point-of-view from someone who is actually there, doing pageants, not someone who just looks in from the outside.

March 10, 2009 5:44 AM

About Hannah Tennant-Moore

Hannah Tennant-Moore is a Brooklyn-based freelance writer whose work has appeared or is forthcoming in Best Buddhist Writing (2008); The Sun; Guantanamo: Inside the Prison, Outside the Law; Tricycle; Turning Wheel (as the winner of the Young Writers Award); and elsewhere.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage