Strollerderby

Unweaning -- It Happens

Posted by Madeline Holler

Unweaning. Hmmm.

Unweaning is when you finally get your nursing kid off the breast and then cave in months (years?) later and let her take up breastfeeding once again.

For anybody who has weaned a child, this sounds a wee self-hating. That said, Jenna Hull makes a pretty good case for it.

An essay in the January/February issue of Mothering magazine, Hull explains why she decided to "unwean" her three-year-old daughter Georgia. Pregnant with her second child, Hull worked to gently get her big girl off the breast. Then the baby was born and big sister changed -- a lot. The once sweet girl had become mean, snotty, jealous and intolerable. 

Hull writes that she tried everything: showing Georgia her baby pictures, explaining how much she loved her, listening, reassuring. Nothing worked. 

Then, the crazy idea: why not start nursing Georgia again? Thus commenced the unweaning. Georgia didn't flinch.

In fact, the big sister changed immediately and Hull nursed the pre-schooler and the newborn side-by-side. All was well and eventually Georgia, the once again happy and now excited older sibling, weaned herself at around 4 years old.

Hull says she doesn't know where she came up with the idea of unweaning, but I do. I've weaned two kids, one easily and the other not so much, but both have looked at me with those eyes, a certain sadness, when watching me nurse a younger sibling. I remember thinking how much easier it would be -- at that moment -- to let whoever wanted to nurse to just get in line. But I never did -- too big of a can of worms.

Despite what the naysayers of extended breastfeeding may think, no kid ever came home from a freshman year at college to warm, sweet squirt of mama's num-nums. Every breastfeeding newborn is eventually weaned -- whether it's hours, days, weeks or years after that first latch (and re-latch).

What do you think? Is Hull a big old wimp or a loving mother? Were any of your kids unweaned? Would you ever consider it?

Photo: greenpeanursery.com


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Ashers mom said:

There are times I wish my little guy would unwean...

March 26, 2009 1:25 PM
 

Em said:

"Despite what the naysayers of extended breastfeeding may think, no kid ever came home from a freshman year at college to warm, sweet squirt of mama's num-nums. Every breastfeeding newborn is eventually weaned -- whether it's hours, days, weeks or years after that first latch (and re-latch)."

Actually, I heard a story on the radio (told by both daughter and mom) of a 20-some-year-old who still suckled (for lack of a better word) in her 20s for comfort...

March 26, 2009 1:35 PM
 

Madeline Holler said:

Em! Was it the Howard Stern show? Damn! I'm gonna put that mother/daughter pair (if they actually exist) in a different category than the usual extended breastfeeder.

20?!

March 26, 2009 2:08 PM
 

TolaniLucia said:

No thank you. I think that children naturally become angry at the arrival of a new baby. And I think it is also natural for them to want to regress a bit back into babyhood. But why on earth would you want to help them regress instead of helping them to be a a wonderful older sibling? She just didn't want to deal with the inevitable moody toddler. So a bit wimpy yes!

March 26, 2009 2:21 PM
 

Mia said:

I nursed both kids until they "self-weaned". I put it in quotations because, honestly, weaning was a gradual process in which we both participated (I had certain rules and limits once they became toddlers), but mostly, it just gradually faded away for both. However, when the youngest was born there was a lengthy period of time where I tandem nursed. Sometimes it was hard, but mostly, it really helped my older child adjust to the new family dynamic. It was very comfort nursing and absolutely essential to his well being. Without it, unweaning would have been the only recourse.

My kids are school age now. Gregarious, confident and well adjusted. We are a stereotypical middle class family. No one knows how long my kids nursed and neither has any interest in resuming, but they both remember it fondly.

For us, extended nursing was the right decision and in my experience, there are many more closet extended nursers than most people realize.

March 26, 2009 2:24 PM
 

NoVa Mommy said:

I read that article, too! Although I did not do extended breastfeeding, I honestly got choked up when the author describes how her toddler got all relaxed and ran her hands through her mom's hair just like she'd always done when nursing. It wouldn't be for me, but who am I to judge anyone else's nursing relationship?

March 26, 2009 3:00 PM
 

Manjari said:

I thought about unweaning a few times in the first month or two after we stopped. I never did it though. At the time I was more than happy to have a little more freedom. Later there were times when they were sick or really upset when I wished I could still nurse them.

March 26, 2009 3:50 PM
 

Twyla said:

Sounds like the mother made the right decision for her family. It was hard for me to chase my one year old while nursing my newborn. For that reason I would have unweaned. To know that they would both be sitting still in arms reach? Seems like a hazard avoider to me.

March 26, 2009 5:09 PM
 

Kelly said:

I just weaned my 19 month old about a month ago and I'm expecting a new little one in about 6 weeks.  I weaned to have a (brief) amount of time where I wasn't nursing anyone to sleep at night (and also so I could stop stressing about how my little man would survive going to bed without me for a night or 2 when I have this baby!).  Once this little one gets here and I have our new nursing relationship established I would probably have no problems letting my toddler nurse again if he wants to.  I don't see any problems with it, especially if it helps his adjust to our new family member.  

March 26, 2009 7:57 PM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage