Strollerderby

Should Child Beauty Pageants Have More Legal Restrictions?

Finally, someone with some power has realized that tanning lotion and false eyelashes might not be the best thing for toddlers.

Representative Annie Mobley has introduced a bill that would establish a regulatory body called the North Carolina Agency to Regulate Beauty Pageants for Girls Under Thirteen. The agency, comprising 10 Congressmembers, would look into the effects of beauty pageants on young girls and make recommendations based on the findings, such as how involved parents should be and what minimum age is appropriate to start participating in pageants.

In principle, I am thrilled with this idea, especially after watching a few clips from Toddlers and Tiaras that actually brought tears to my eyes—those little girls were just so miserable.  (Naturally, the older kids seem to have fully embraced the pageant atmosphere, fussing over their hair and makeup with the same panicked attention as their moms once did.)

But in a country deeply committed to the individual’s right to parent as she sees fit, beauty pageants seem like a bit of an arbitrary—and difficult—place to start monitoring parents. Plus, it seems like psychiatrists or social workers, not legislators, would be best able to determine how beauty pageants affect young girls. If the bill passes, I'll be curious to see what effect, if any, the regulatory body has on child pageants.

 Do you think that is an invasion of parents’ rights or a commonsense measure to protect children?

Photo: Jezebel


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

TolaniLucia said:

There are regulations to protect kids in the movie industry, theatre and in the modeling industry. There most certainly should be some form of bill of regulations for the pageant circuit.

April 14, 2009 9:24 AM
 

Lee said:

There aren't enough resources available to properly oversee the families and children currently in foster care or under CPS supervision -- those who have already been identified as at high risk. That is where any discretionary funding or congressional time should be spent.

Pageants may appear to some to be an inappropriate activity for children but pageant parents are only exhibiting the same behavior as the parents at the ball field or at the piano teachers' pushing their children to compete in a sport or play an instrument the child may not always feel like playing. Where will this kind of government interference end?

TolaniLucia: I wouldn't compare child pageant contestants to children working in the movie, modeling, or theatre industries because those children are actually working for a paycheck. The vast majority of kids in pageants are lucky if any winnings even cover the cost of participating, and they certainly aren't supporting their families a la McCauley Culkin, etc.

April 14, 2009 11:23 AM
 

TolaniLucia said:

The reason I compare pageants to the movie and modeling industries is due to the fact that they are all entertainment in some form. A much lower form but still entertainment.And in many cases the families of the girls are in fact hoping to reap the benefits of their child’s potential win. Comparing pageants to sports or piano lessons is way off.

April 14, 2009 12:18 PM
 

Lee said:

The laws regulating children who work in the entertainment industry are child labor laws.

At these  pageants the audience being 'entertained' is made up of the children's families and friends, much like little league games and music recitals.

As a child I was a competitive equestrian and show sponsors often offered cash prizes. There were days that I was crabby and did not want to dress in my riding habit or have my mother pull my hair into the required tight bun. I didn't always cooperate with my trainer. Would horse shows also qualify as entertainment and as a result be subject to the same government oversight?

April 14, 2009 1:00 PM
 

TolaniLucia said:

Horse shows are sports. You learn something from them. There is honor in the equestrian world. What do little girls learn from being in pageants? How to be shallow and unhealthily competitive. I will now sound harsh but I see nothing good in these narcissist in training fests called pageants. Nothing. So whatever makes it harder for parents to enter their children into them is fine with me. Peace:)

April 14, 2009 4:53 PM
 

Taylor said:

I think that this is a bunch of bull. Pageants are a great way to express your self and parents are just trying to prepare their kids for outside their homes. I admire pageants and every thing that comes with it. and its called stage make up nobody can see your face if you dont wear hevey make up and fake eyelashes. not only pagents wear eyelashes compitive dancers and cheerleaders wear them too. so leave pagent girls alone.

April 19, 2009 11:44 AM
 

peggy said:

i see nothing wrong with pageants. its a beautiful thing to make a little girl feel good with her self. if little girls dont like it then it becomes a moral issue with the parent. not the law. is the law going to start telling me when to eat and sleep.

April 22, 2009 2:41 PM

About Hannah Tennant-Moore

Hannah Tennant-Moore is a Brooklyn-based freelance writer whose work has appeared or is forthcoming in Best Buddhist Writing (2008); The Sun; Guantanamo: Inside the Prison, Outside the Law; Tricycle; Turning Wheel (as the winner of the Young Writers Award); and elsewhere.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage