Strollerderby

They Say: Bilingual Babies Learn Better

Posted by Kate Tuttle

And not just languages, either. A new study, published today in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, compared babies' ability to both process linguisitic information and to correctly anticipate based on new information, a mental process linked to what neuropsychologists call "executive function." Babies rasied in bilingual households performed better than monolingual babies, although the study's lead scientist suggests that the monolingual babies will eventually catch up with their bilingual peers.

Undertaken at the International School for Advanced Studies in Trieste, Italy, the research may change attitudes in Europe, where Jacques Mehler, the study's author, says that "parents are wary of giving a bilingual education to their kids and tryto speak only one language." Given the geographical proximity and relative ease of exposing an Italian child to, say, French, it seems almost criminal not to try. 

For parents in the US, bilingual education in the home is fairly well accepted, and even kind of de riguer in certain circles (probably half the kids we play with in our Boston-area setting are bilingual), but there lingers a stigma that privileges certain languages over others. Your mother-in-law will brag to all the neighbors if your baby is learning French, for instance, but that kid down the block who speaks Spanish (as well as English) may well be seen as a potential problem for schools and society for her failure to assimilate. And while some innovative school districts have piloted two-way bilingual programs, many other districts have pushed for English-only learning as a means to help students succeed in English (even though these rules tend to raise dropout rates for immigrants and the children of immigrants). 

So it's nice to see some scientific confirmation of what parents who speak two languages in the home already know: a mind is made nimbler the more it's exposed to. When it comes to languages and learning, more is more. 

 

More by this author:

Exploited and Discarded? Seeking Protection for Egg Donors

Another Hospital Baby Mix-Up, Now With Added Racism!

Spurred to Action by Natasha Richardson Death, Parents Save Girl

Child Support Suffers in a Recession, Too

 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

Lisa said:

Is everything about racism with you?  sheesh.

It is unreasonable to equate an American teaching their child to speak French or Hebrew to an illegal immigrant's child who speaks limited English.  Bilingual students are not a burden on school districts because they don't require special services.  However, children who come in with no English do. It takes them years of special services to catchup to their peers.  

Most ESL students in my classroom are Asian.  They generally do not fall behind in anything but English because their parents have them continue their education, across the curriculum,  in Japanese or Chinese or whatever.  My Hispanic students typically come to us with weak skills.. even math (an ESL student's strength normally).

This isn't about race but class.  One set of parents can afford to expand their child's education;  the other set of parents have moved so much that their child has weak skills.  And yes, the second set will require more services and more expense than the first.

April 14, 2009 6:48 PM
 

MistressScorpio said:

Lisa, you answer your own question with your answer.

April 14, 2009 7:52 PM
 

Kate Tuttle said:

Nah, Lisa, I wouldn't say everything is about racism; some things are about sexism :)

Seriously, though, I don't think my comments are any kind of victimology. If you don't see a difference between the way your average English-only speaker perceives a child who's bilingual in French* and one who's bilingual in Spanish, then you must be seeing different things than I've seen. Sure, it's not necessarily about race. I think a lot of it is about class -- but is class prejudice nobler than racism? Mostly I think it's about fear of immigrants/immigration, but I'm sure you'll think that's just me being a knee-jerk liberal.

*with the caveat that bilingual French-speaking kids from Haiti are also seen/treated as a drag on the system, rather than the charming addition to junior's preschool that kids with one French parent are seen as!  

April 14, 2009 11:10 PM
 

Manjari said:

"Is everything about racism...?"

It seems that for you, Lisa, it's a combination of racism and snobbery.

April 15, 2009 7:45 AM
 

Shana said:

My kids will be learning Swedish.  We are requesting that my mother in law send some children's books in Swedish to ensure that our child can read the language also.  When visiting Aland (a little archipelago between Finland and Sweden), most of the relatives there do not speak a word of English putting me at great disadvantage.  It is a really uncomfortable feeling.  Yes they are all friendly and do make an effort to communicate with me, but it is very hard for them and me.  I do not want my kids to go through that.

I am very jealous of my brother in law though who speaks Swedish, English, Mandarin, Cantonese,Nepalese and a bit of Arabic.  His Serbian wife speaks Serbian, English, Arabic and some Swedish.  I only speak very little Spanish and very little Japanese.

April 15, 2009 8:46 AM
 

Kate Tuttle said:

Shana, your brother in law and his wife sound amazingly well-rounded!

I'm always amazed at the multilingual status of non-Americans (which is why I was surprised to learn of the resistance to bilingualism in Italy). I've had colleagues (particularly from Africa) who routinely spoke 6-8 languages, and I mean fluent in 3-4 with good conversational skills in another 3-4. Such a gift.

April 15, 2009 9:44 PM

About Kate Tuttle

I'm raising a toddler and a teenager in a leafy suburb just outside Boston. In between having kids I've been an editor and writer, most recently with the African American National Biography and the late great Africana.com.

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage