Strollerderby

Married vs. Single Moms: Who's Got it Easier?

Posted by Madeline Holler

One could hardly envy a single mother if she's struggling emotionally or financially. But what about single mothers who are doing fine? Have you ever found yourself thinking she's lucky? She has it so much better -- so much easier -- than the married mothers out there?

Over at Motherlode blog in the NY Times, Lisa Belkin asked: which is easier, parenting alone or with a partner?

She pulls from a few other blogs and Katie Kowalski, of the Orlando Sentinel, had this argument in favor of being a single mom:

I like that no one complains when I leave my sweaty workout clothes on the bathroom floor overnight, or that no one cares when I decide that it’s going to be cereal for dinner (again). Some might call that a lack of accountability on my part — but hey, don’t we all do better work when someone isn’t looking over our shoulder?

I already have a bossy little girl who demands that I sing the Tigger song 100 times a day, and who regularly bullies me out of my breakfast. The last thing I need is a man who needs…. well, anything that takes effort on my part.

That may be how relationships work for Kowalski, but I would argue some partners may be better than others. Feeling watched and/or burdened by one's other half does make a good case for building a family of just mom and the kids.

That aside, I'll admit I've envied some single moms. Shared custody, to my tired eyes, has its benefits. Namely, visitation! Those nights/weeks/weekends/summers where the kids pack off to live in their other home. Ahhhh, sleep. Ahhhh, benders. Ahhhh, French fries and mayonnaise for dinner.

Perhaps I'm oversimplifying the matter.

Anyway, let's hear it. Single moms? Are you secretly (or openly) relieved to be the only one in charge? Any smug marrieds secretly (no, really, secretly!) jealous of your single-mom/dad friends?

More Posts

Teacher in Affair with 6th-Grader to Host 'Hot for Teacher' Night

India Baby Boom: Surrogate Birth Every 48 Hours

How Fertile Couples Outsmarted Wall Street

Michael Pollan Doesn't Know if He was Breastfed!

They Say: Moms, It's Still Your Fault. Well, Yours and Daycare

Top 10 Pregnancy and Birth World Records

City's 5th Co-Sleeping Death in 10 Weeks Reported

550-Pound Woman Gives Birth

Photo: single-parent-project.com


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

JJ said:

I guess my husband isn't as annoying as the imaginary ones she has cooked up or the husbands of her friends.

But being a single mom is probably better than being unhappily married. I like my husband. Someone to help out and do the cooking and take out the garbage.  I hate taking out the garbage.  And vacuuming! And it doesn't hurt that he's easy on my eyes.  

Call me smug!

I'm pretty lucky in that my husband and I seem to hate different chores.  Most of the time, I do the ones he hates and vice-versa.  I guess not all marriages are like that.

May 23, 2009 4:10 PM
 

feefifoto said:

Single mom: openly relieved to be the only one in charge (which may be part of the reason I'm single ;))

May 23, 2009 11:39 PM
 

Alice said:

I like having a partner.  When I was so sick I had to go to the ER he took me and watched our newborn for me while I was in the hospital.  He brought her up twice a day to nurse and pick up my pumped milk.  He helps so much more than I know.  He is their other parent.  I like a democratic family.  I like my child having two sets of grandparents, two heritages to learn about.  My husband never complains about my cooking or cleaning.  That was the 50's, not today.  

May 24, 2009 12:04 AM
 

DaintySplendor said:

JJ my huisband is so much like yours!!

My mum was a single mother and she openly admitted how happy she is that she doesn't have another child (aka husband) to care for

May 24, 2009 12:22 AM
 

Sheri said:

I was single for four years with my oldest...hated it.

I'm glad I don't have to do this alone, because I'd suck at it.  

May 24, 2009 12:54 AM
 

O Solo Mama said:

It was quite an animated discussion on Motherlode! I posted to say single motherhood works for me--in fact, I love it. It's an intensely individual decision and how easy it is depends so much on the resources you have. The thing I took away from that discussion is that all parents deserve to be supported, not judged.

May 24, 2009 10:09 AM
 

A Married Military Mommy Living in Japan said:

I am married to an active duty United States Naval officer.  He has been underway (out to sea) for more than half of our 8 month old daughter's life and approximately 1/3 of our 3 and a half year olds life.  As a result, I have experienced single Mommy life and married Mommy life.  

Sometimes it's easier when he is away because the girls and I get into our routine and I only have 2 people relying on me.  On the "bad" single parenting days, I yearn for his assistance and comforting presence.  On the "good" single parenting days, we're ok although it's sad that he misses so many experiences and celebrations.  The girls miss their Daddy when he is away, as do I.  Sometimes when he is around, I feel like I have a ton of extra responsibilities and commitments but I am usually glad he is here.  He is a good Daddy and quite helpful, partially because he is trying to make up for the time apart and partially because he loves them to pieces and wants to have a positive influence on their lives.

Having experienced both positions, I prefer to have him here.  We made our family together and I want him to experience life with them as much as his duties allow.  That being said, every person needs to do what is right for them.  To all the single Mamas out there, I salute you!  It's a tough job, especially when it is all Mommy, all the time.  And to all the Married Mamas out there, I salute you too!  Having a partner around does not necessarily make it any easier.      

May 24, 2009 10:46 AM
 

Marj said:

So much depends on the people involved.  I didn't want kids until I wanted a family with my husband.  He's not a big child, he is a grown-up.  I think a lot of people never grow up, and being married to one of them would make parenting an actual child harder.

May 24, 2009 2:09 PM
 

Mary G said:

I have been in both, married 17 years, 3 kids, he left now I've been a single mom 5 years.  I love being a single mom.

If I were married to a loving, helpful man, that would be nice too.  It's hard work, but us tough moms just get tougher with this challenge :) (especially those of us with severely disabled children:)  God bless you all

Mary of Marysfreebies.com

May 24, 2009 10:17 PM
 

maeby said:

ive been both as well and although i was single with my fist, i dont think i could do it with the three now. It's nice having someone help out, but it does seem to come with more work. sometimes i feel like i have 4 kids. i guess it really comes down to how well you and the other parent mesh.

and we totally have cereal for dinner and leave our gym clothes on the floor sometimes ;)

May 25, 2009 1:28 PM
 

g8grl said:

Single mom here, most of the time liking it.  Lots of times I'll see my married friends doing extra chores, not being able to make decisions on the own and having extra obligations...those are the times I'm happy to be on my own.  Then there are times when my friends husbands watch their kids while they go out and play, sleep in or run out on a quick errand and I think...that would be nice.

Ultimately, if I could afford a few extra hours of childcare and a housekeeper to come in twice a month, I would say being a single mom is bliss.  AS it is, it's still pretty great.

May 26, 2009 12:44 AM
 

Frazz said:

I don't think its a black or white answer...most days, I am happy that I have "backup" in the form of my husband and love of my life.  Only very rarely have I felt that I'm dealing with two children instead of one.  I suppose that if he wasn't as hands on and involved as he is, I may feel differently, even if as a couple, we were happily married.  But its not a question I've had to address myself, personally.  

May 26, 2009 9:00 AM
 

Twyla said:

I think women should stop marrying immature boys. That would help. I married a great man who is a huge help with the kids and the housework and the cooking. The always-available sex is nice too. I was single with my first one and with my husband for the second two. I don't know how I would have done it without him. Especially with the last one. I had a 5 year old, 1 year old and a newborn who came via c-section. There is no way I could have safely managed that household. My husband is a wonderful. Even when we don't agree, I am glad he is there.

May 27, 2009 2:45 AM
 

Resveratrol Pills said:

I am married to an active duty alaska as a navi officer.

I think women should stop marrying immature boys.

married women is also happy because she got a licence of the sex.she want kids after married she orn it but unmarried dont born

May 27, 2009 3:39 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage