Strollerderby

What Happens When Looney-Warde Marries Butts-McCracken?

Posted by KeriF

It was bound to happen. With so many people hyphenating their children's last names, it was only a matter of time before these hyphenates wanted to get married. Then what do you do?

One woman in Germany found out when she tried to triple-hyphenate her name, combining her own (single) last name with her husband's hypenated name. The answer? No dice. 

Germany's highest court ruled on this case, which involved dentist Frieda Rosemarie Thalheim-Kunz-Hallstein. At least, that's what she wanted to call herself. The court, however, said she couldn't. According to the court, triple hyphenating a name "lessened the impact of a name to do what it was supposed to do, namely 'to identify.'"

The court apparently also feared of setting a dangerous precedent, to which I say, gimme a break! Hyphenated surnames are hard enough. Who would want to bother with the complexities of having a triple-barrelled name? How would you fill out government forms? What would your coach call you (Jones-Murphy-Goldstein, give me 20, doesn't quite carry the same authoritative snap)? And if combining hyphenated surnames became the norm, it wouldn't be long until Mary Jones-Murphy-Goldstein married John Smith-Brown-Flynn, and then what would their poor children do?

Apparently there are very strict naming laws in Germany to prevent such travesties, which is why this case went to court in the first place. Parents must choose from a list of government-approved names, and if they desire a different name, they must appeal to authorities. German law allows married couples to take one of their existing surnames, combine the two with a hyphen, or keep their own names. 

I haven't heard of any multi-hyphenate names here in the states, though I suppose it's bound to happen (if it hasn't already). So what should happen when a hyphenate marries a hyphenate?

Any ideas?

Photo: Maxim (click for more hilarious hyphenates)

Related Posts:

 


+ DIGG + STUMBLE

Comments

 

JeanneSager said:

As someone with a hugely long maiden name, I got some crap from my friends when I dumped it in favor of my husband's much shorter last name.

I'm proud of my family, but being able to fit my whole name in those little teeny weeny boxes on a registration form? So worth it!

June 2, 2009 10:10 AM
 

e said:

This is one of the reasons I didn't want to hyphenate my son's name. I thought, if he ever wants to join his name with a partner's he'll have to choose one of the names. Why not just do it for him? Choosing was tough, but I'm glad we did it!  

June 2, 2009 10:22 AM
 

elohveeee12 said:

my friend has a hyphanated last name, and i always joke about what he would do if he ended up marrying someone with a hyphanated last name. but he always says that he doesnt have to keep both, or she could just take his, or one from each.

personally i think it is too much. give the kid one name, and call it a day. combine your names if you want, but i still dont see what is wrong with taking your husbands last name? when did that stop becoming the norm?

June 2, 2009 4:22 PM
 

Michele said:

My husband is from Spain.  In Spain everyone has two last names.  The first last name is the father's first last name and the second last name is the mother's last name.  

For example:  If Joe Smith Jones married Jane White Doe, the child's last name would be Smith White.

So, in order to register our son with the Spanish government, we had to give him the traditional last name thing. . . and we decided to do that for his US birth certificate... because, really, why should he be called one thing in Spain and one thing here?

To make matters easier, though, the women in Spain don't take their husband's name.  So, I didn't take my husband's name either.

If our son gets married and his wife wants to take his name, I'd totally be fine if she just took his first last name.

But yeah, a bit confusing over here. . . not so much confusion in Spain, though.

June 3, 2009 2:29 AM

in

GROUP BLOGS

  • Strollerderby

    The smartest, funniest, most exhaustive parenting blog in the blogosphere.
  • Droolicious

    Modern design for modern parents.
  • FameCrawler

    Your daily baby celebrity fix.
back to blog homepage