All the guidebooks and everyone who’d ever been to or thought about going to Iceland were unanimous on one point: we simply had to visit the Blue Lagoon.
Nothing to do with a pre-pubescent Brooke Shields in a fig-leaf bikini. The Blue Lagoon (or Bláá Loni∂ in the local lingo) is the most dramatic open-air hot pool you’ll ever see. It sits in the middle of a field of black volcanic rock, in the lee of a geothermal power plant that constantly belches clouds of steam. It’s also a convenient half hour from Keflavík Airport, which makes it the perfect stopover treat for people who are just passing through.
If the guidebooks are unanimous on one other point, it is that the Blue Lagoon is blue. But not just any blue. An ethereal, cerulean blue. A glimmering, magical, haunting blue. A brilliant, fluorescent blue, all thanks to a curious mixture of silica and algae in the water. My favourite description said it was “like swimming in melted Play-doh.”
And so it was… if the Play-doh at your house has, like mine, been squished together into a sort of khaki amalgam. I don’t know if it was a trick of the weather or the cumulative effect of all those sweaty tourists, but on the day we visited the lagoon looked pretty darn muddy.
I arrived with the boys around lunchtime. The scientists had headed out earlier in the morning, to spend the whole day there, most of it in a conference room but some of it in the water. Some sixth sense told me to arrange our own transport, on the off-chance that this much-touted wonderland might fail to entertain two small boys for longer than a couple of hours.
We rode in a small bus with two sets of honeymooners. James noshed on mixed lollies from the corner shop (weeding out the salty licorice ones for me) while Toby indulged in an uncharacteristic screaming fit that caused the honeymooners to give us the hairy eyeball. The magic boob saved my ears and for all I know their marriages, although they’d probably double up on contraception later that night to make absolutely sure.
As the lava fields raced past, we spotted occasional outcroppings, tall cairns that looked very much like trolls doing whatever it is that trolls do. Patrolling the horizon? It’s easy to feel you’re being watched, under the influence of that uncanny landscape. I told James that some people thought the rocks came to life.
“Well, everything has feelings, even rocks, even metal,” he said.
“Uh-huh? What does rock think about?”
“About what sort of shape it will be next.”
High school geography: igneous, sedimentary, metamorphic. Ancient history to me, and brand new and completely obvious to him.
When you arrive at the Blue Lagoon, more troll-sentinels line the path
to the entrance, which is framed by some genuinely blue lagoons to whet
your appetite:

Inside the building, we discover the scientists still at lunch. They are sunk in discussion about whether or not the fundamental constants of the universe change over time, and how you’d notice. Well, one fundamental constant of the universe I live in is that small boys need to eat, so we snagged a quick bowl of soup before heading off into the changing rooms. Richard and his colleagues would join us once
they’d nailed down a few more fundamentals.
Happily, through the windows of the café you get your first glimpse of the baths themselves. Under a veil of steam, tourists paddle slowly around in the jade-coloured water. A squeegee crew was working its way along the windows. All that silica must be a real bugger to keep at bay.

Ah, Blue Lagoon. So spectacular. And ultimately, so disappointing. Where did it start to go wrong? Was it in the changing rooms, where it took us ten minutes to figure out the locker system? Or in the showers, when Toby slipped twice on the ridiculously slick tiles, and although everybody gasped in horror, not one person lent a hand?
We dutifully coated our hair with conditioner, having been warned that the mineral-rich water can lead to a bad hair week (note to self: is that how the young Icelanders get their hair to look so freaky-cool?). I fitted Toby with a pair of complimentary water-wings. And then we headed out into the pool, a steaming pea-green soup under a glorious blue sky.
At first, it’s marvelous, a gorgeous reward for all that hassle in the changing rooms, and well worth the $30 entrance fee (the boys are free). The water is warm, silky, salty, and incredibly buoyant. Then, barely two minutes into our swim, we are hailed by an attendant. “How old is your boy?”
At first I’m gratified that somebody has got Toby’s gender right first time. Then I start to panic. Are they going to kick us out for sanitary reasons - no babies in the pool? James will flip out, and what will we do until it’s time to catch the return bus?
“He's eighteen months,” I say.
“No, the other one.”
"Um, six," I exaggerate, although he can pass for eight. We are informed that all children under the age of ten must wear the neon orange water-wings. (The website says it is "advised," but we were advised that it was compulsory).
Now, this is a plausible safety rule, given the depth of the water – and one I am grateful for a short while later when we paddle around the vent that pours hot water into the pool, and James temporarily vanishes in a cloud of steam. But it is a mortal blow to the self-respect of the Best Child Swimmer on the Eastern Seaboard. Poor James. With the floaties on, he can’t actually swim. He paddles in tiny ineffectual circles, getting angrier and angrier.
By way of distraction I tow him (and Toby) over to the buckets of white silica mud. You’re meant to smear this over your face so as to emerge from the water ten years younger. James begs off, on the logical grounds that this would make him negative four and a bit. I do it for the entertainment value, and quickly wish I hadn’t, as my skin starts itching like crazy. With my toes I pick up some of the squishy white mud from the floor of the pool and examine it closely. It’s got hair in it. I try not to calculate how many tourists shed here in a given week, or what other greeblies might be floating around, even if fresh hot water is constantly flushed through the pool.
We swim under a bridge and over to a waterfall that provides a free, thundering back massage. Or at least it would if I had someone to hand Toby to. We swim through a little cave with white silica handprints on the ceiling, and pretend we are cave-people. This part is fun, and James takes his floaties off now that the lifeguards can't see him.
But there’s an ominous twinge in my back, from bending to pick up Toby in the showers, and suddenly it develops into a full-blown muscle spasm. I try to climb up the steps out of the water, but simply cannot do it. My only hope is to stay in the water until it wears off, but how long might that be?
So I tow the boys over to the glass-walled restaurant, and we wave at the scientists until one of them summons Richard. He waves cheerfully. I grimace and gesture. He waves again. I grimace some more, and he seems to get it. Not long afterwards, he appears in the pool and takes the boys off my hands while I try to fix my back in the steam room and under the waterfall. There are also tiny hot-pools where you can have luxurious floating massage treatments, if you’ve booked in advance, but of course I haven’t. Ouch. This is bad. We gather in the cave, en famille, to make a plan.
There’s no way around it. The boys’ gear is in the locker in the women’s changing room, and you can’t get to the lockers without going through the showers and drying off. For once I curse the showering rigmarole, as I stoop and wince my way through rinsing off the salty water, peeling wet togs off two squirming children, making sure Toby only slips on the tiles once (again, many horrified gasps, but nobody lends a hand - what is wrong with these people?).
I towel all of us off, under the stern gaze of the ladies who police the drips. Then it’s back to the locker room, hobbling like a crone, where I dress all three of us under protest from one lower back and two cranky boys. The miracle waters have not cured me one bit. And as we pass the mirrors, where women are admiring the ten-years-younger effect and touching it up with make-up, one glance tells me everything I need to know. I’m pale with pain under the rash from the mud, the boys are red-faced and grouchy, and our hair is so stiff with silica the brush wouldn’t go through it. Collectively, we look insane.
To add insult to injury, the stroller won’t open. Apparently I jammed it shut on the latest Harry Potter (purchased at ruinous expense our first day in Iceland). So I drag the useless thing behind me like a broken wing, with Toby on one awkwardly hitched hip and James grumbling at my side. As I lurch, Igor-like, to the cafeteria, it sinks in that I am also about to commit the cardinal sin of a conference spouse: dragging one’s mate away from the proceedings on the basis of a suspiciously convenient malady. Oh the shame, although everyone seems very understanding about it.
Would it be different visiting without children? Probably, although my single friend who visited that same week also found it overcrowded and a tad overrated. In the bus on the way back to the city, despite the random rainbows that lit up the sky, I felt a new kinship with the post-pubescent, post-partum Brooke Shields. Yes ma'am, I got those pea-green, mashed-up play-doh, back-wrenching Blue Lagoon Blues.