feedback for "The Phantom Menace"

  1. My daughter is being tested for SPD. She is gifted and has many of the symptoms. I had to pick her up form Pre-K class at least once a week, sometimes more, due to tantrums. Her teachers said "they came out of nowhere". I watched her perform beautifully in her ballet recital and then melt down and scream through out her singing recital the next day because the lights were in her eyes. As a baby she would have fits of crying if I laughed too loud or cuddled her too much or too tightly. At 5 she still sucks her thumb at night and goes everywhere with an entourage of stuffed animals. Her bed is covered with stuffed cats and wild cats. I think it is her emotional armour. I have thought of leaving or sending her off becuase I thought I was a poor parent for her. Now I understand it is not my fault or hers.

    posted by : India on 6/16/2008 at 2:15 PM Flag For Abuse

  2. I live in Dallas and have two boys who have very different issues but qualify in their own way for sensory issues and have SID diagnoses. They attend very expensive therapy that is a fight to get isurance to cover. Both kids are very smart...reading at the age of 4 BUT one cannot tie his shoes laces at 7 and has terrible handwriting and still is very uncoordinated and cannot play sports. The other one also reads at 4 but has awful tantrums and is chronically anxious and flips out at everything. They both are immature seeming and have very poor coping skills compared to some other chidren in their classes. There is an epidemic of something in this country...I am not sure what it is....the OT's office has a waiting list a mile long...there are kids lining up outside after school ...OT is the fastest growing after school activity in our fair town...and what are they learning? To not be picky eaters, to develop core strength so child can sit at his seat and not fall out, to be able to do a worksheet without talking...the list is endless and seemingly ridiculous. There are kids who come with ADD/ADHD and autism diagnosis and ones that have no diagnoses other than that they are perplexing their teachers at school. Or those that just seem quirky and have a hard time managing themselves and so need something to help them fit in! I have mixed feelings about this trend....yes my son has possibly benefited from some OT but I have also seen it being taken too far and with little to show for the time, money and effort spent. Some of this is just society expecting too much from little kids, not allowign them to be kids and wanting to fix everyhting instead of letting the child grow into their own. This is a tough issue and one I deal with on a daily basis...I am conflicted on this and really have no great insight other than that there is something very wrong when tons of kids need a therpist to learn to ride a bike or to form better letters!

    posted by : livingSID on 6/16/2008 at 3:24 PM Flag For Abuse

  3. "There is an epidemic of something in this country"

    There sure is. There's an epidemic of trying to deconstruct the human mind down to a set of defineable diagnoses.

    Soon the parameters defining "normal" will narrow so much that the majority of people will not be "normal" and the concept of "normal" will disintegrate. Then we'll have come full circle back to the idea that we're all unique and not necessarily "sick".

    posted by : k1 on 6/16/2008 at 3:55 PM Flag For Abuse

  4. I contributed my daughter's experiences in this article and can understand and certainly appreciate the frustration all of the Moms are experiencing. Sensory issues have been around for a LONG time - this isn't the flavor of the month type thing - it's just our knowledge and understanding of ourselves is increasing.

    Unfortunately, we live in a time where we are increasingly expecting more and more of children at such a young age. Teachers and administration want everyone to fit neatly into a "box". I'm all for celebrating differences and learning styles, but that doesn't work in a coventional school setting.

    I look at it this way. We, as parents of children with SPD, need to honor their uniqueness by raising awareness and knowledge so that they receive appropriate help. Not all kids with SPD present the same way, so they're needs are as unique as each child. If you're seeking support for your child through OT or other, make sure they're highly qualified and have a strong background of SPD.

    We've spent quite a bit of time/money getting our daughter the help she so desperately needed. She's improved tremendously with this support, and still has some challenges (who doesn't?), but it's my job as her parent to provide her with the support she needs to become a strong and confident young woman.

    And that's what it's all about. Loving and supporting your child so they grow up to be wonderful and loving people.

    posted by : JCBMD on 6/16/2008 at 5:01 PM Flag For Abuse

  5. I have a 7 year old daughter with mild SPD who receives private OT services once a week. She was denied services by the school system because her only diagnosis is SPD. In their words, "There's nothing wrong with her." She does look pretty normal but she appears to be socially behind her peers. People think we are spoiling her because of the things we let her eat but frankly, we feed her what she will eat. She lacks the motor coordination of her 4 year old sister and finds many normal daily activities very difficult. She recently learned to fasten buttons but don't even talk to us about tying shoelaces. However, she has a beautiful singing voice and an exceptional imagination.

    I don't think anyone is perfectly normal, sensorily speaking. All of us have our little quirks. I imagine everyone on a line, with "0" representing normal. Most of us learn to deal with the fact that we don't like loud noises or that certain smells make us nauseous. The problem comes when it interferes with daily life: You can't separate the teacher's voice from the classroom noise; the tags in your clothes feel like needles in your skin; you can't concentrate because every nerve cell in your body is screaming for you to crash into something, anything, because you just have to FEEL; you can't coordinate your body to follow a set of three step instructions; you move awkwardly because you don't understand where your body is in space. In my opinion, that's the test. Does it interfere with daily life?

    posted by : Kimmee on 6/16/2008 at 6:05 PM Flag For Abuse

  6. Yeah...
    I don't think anyone is making up the symptoms or anything or that there are docs and related professionals out there rubbing their hands together with glee at all the insurance money to come rolling in, but - all these descriptions are what used to be called 1) personality or 2) misbehavior.
    Most definitely, many kids (and many adults - so make that, many *people*) do not do well in highly stimulating environments, many people are extremely sensitive compared to others, and I find it very believable that some brains are better at multi-tasking than others. But that's part of who they are, not a malfunction from the default "normal" personality, thus making it a DISorder that needs to be re-ordered. It's all so brave new world-ish, yaknow?
    Extra teaching of certain skills to better get along in the world is cool - I guess what is so bothersome about all this is the "DISORDER" part and the label that's going to follow each child through their entire school career (and beyond) and be the lens through which everyone looks at them, and serve to excuse behavior or lower expectations. Especially since these are so often otherwise gifted people (not a coincidence - gifted has always been associated with quirky) who should go on to do great things. Not to mention how this will affect the ability to get health insurance - it may not be so great to get this approved as an insurance-paid disorder, because having any whisper of psychological disorders in a medical history means huge upratings or denials for individual policies (there's a great story in Slate about this).

    Eh, 2 cent rant...

    posted by : CG on 6/16/2008 at 8:08 PM Flag For Abuse

  7. My 2 year old daughter has severe anxiety when faced with sensory over load...the sensory over load I am refering to are normal situations for most children. She has axiety everytime she see's certain people that are too loud or socially aggresive...anxiety coping with other children in our mom and tots class we attend, or the gym class we routinly go to. All of these settings have bright lights and loud children who may aproach her and touch her, this sets her off in a crying rage. She has seperation anxiety all the time..it is a fustration I have been dealing with since birth and am always making excuses for her...she is shy, she will adjust just give her time. etc. She has a couple of people in her immediate family that she trusts and that is it (5 people)..anyone else sets her off in fits of tears and severe clinginess.Even as an infant she would react to loud people and loud noise with anxiety...at 2 months old I noticed this..I knew there was something different about her...and she has not grown out of it. I have not come accross other children with this extreme case of anxiety. I have discussed this issue with a therapist, but my daughter has never been evaluated..the therapist thought i should put her down on a waiting list for child pschycology. I thought I would wait to see if time could correct this but reading this article makes me think that she may have this disorder, I have never heard of it before. Thank you for bringing this disorder to my attention. Her anxiety interferes with our lives on a daily basis and I would not mind finding some help coping with it as it can become exhausting. She is a poor sleeper and eater as the article points out to be common also. Other than that she is a very smart little girl and her motor skills are quite sharp..

    posted by : mamawith2yrold on 6/16/2008 at 8:10 PM Flag For Abuse

  8. Is it bad to wonder what the lifestyles of all these SPD families are? As a "sensitive" person I accept certain things about myself. Sometimes I prefer to stay home rather than go out with people all the time. Sometimes certain types of touches bug me, especially at certain times of the month. It's my "pokey" time. I once skipped a cheese making excursion on a trip to Holland because I was sick of being around people and just wanted to be alone and so explored Amsterdam with just my camera. I wonder if my parents hadn't been such homebodies if I would have had more "sensitive" related problems (I used to stem, to boot) but because I wasn't in an urban, on-the-go environment, my problems never became severe. How much of our present-day frenetic lifestyle is exacerbating these natural tendencies?

    posted by : SPDelect on 6/17/2008 at 12:12 PM Flag For Abuse

  9. To SPDelect:

    I understand what you're saying regarding lifestyle choices and on-the-go environments affecting more sensitive children. However, when your child can't even manage sitting in a classroom because he/she can't tolerate the noise, lights, sounds, then I think there is a legitimate concern. I don't think any of these parents sound as those their child's "sensitivities" is inconveniencing their lives rather, it's truly disrupting their child from functioning in normal, day-to-day, things. BIG DIFFERENCE!

    posted by : MOMofSPDChild on 6/17/2008 at 1:58 PM Flag For Abuse

  10. To SPDelect:
    We too have a daughter with SPD. We did not let her watch any TV until age 2 and then it was 1/2 hour of appropriate children's TV a day. She is 8 years old now and she still only gets one hour of TV, does not own any type of video game system and outside of scouts is only allowed to participate in one extra-curricular a season. We eat breakfast and dinner together as a family almost every single day and try very hard towards having the quieter lifestyle. Even with doing all of this, SPD has a daily impact in our lives. The tricky part is you don't know the triggers, they can be different every day. And the same calming techniques don't work every time. We have just started OT and we have an outstanding therapist and look forward to helping our daughter gain exceptable control of her senses. I agree with many here, our daughter is an extremely bright, creative, and spiritual girl. I appreciate all the work being done in this field of research to help us help our daughter to reach her full potential and be the person she is called to be in life.

    posted by : mom of 3 special gifts on 6/18/2008 at 10:13 PM Flag For Abuse

  11. I'm a 20 year old with moderate SPD that I've suffered from my entire life, and I spent most of my childhood miserably upset and anxious and unable to put a finger on what was bothering me, because, for instance, birds chirping had never felt like anything other than nails on a chalkboard to me. Please, it's incredibly exciting to see people paying attention to this for once. No one denies that children with autism experience severe sensory processing issues, but the moment it appears in those of us who appear normal, who function in daily life, it's dismissed as overdiagnosis, or whatever. For me, without medication and earplugs and a LOT of effort, I'd have panic attacks at least once or twice a month from not being able to get away from horrific noises or textures, and I'm an adult, capable of walking away and making my own decisions. Anything that can help parents not unknowingly inflict intense pain and anxiety on their children can't be anything but a good thing in my book.

    posted by : Bekka on 6/20/2008 at 12:52 AM Flag For Abuse

  12. My daughter Amaya also has "Autism" and sensory issues. My wife and I caught it early and Amaya has come a long way in less than a year's time. The one thing that we learned, that most of the medical field never mentions, is that most of these children are normal and just have viral and/or fungal issues going on in their brains. These can be treated and your child can live a normal life again. I encourage you to read some of the material on a new website I put together (still in the works):

    http://www.not-autism.org

    I think this information could be very helpful for you. As parents we have to rise up above the current medical system and do what is right for our children as the current system is dismissing our precious children.

    Justin Lofton

    posted by : Not Autism on 6/21/2008 at 7:18 PM Flag For Abuse

  13. The Massachusetts Department of Health has an Early Intervention program to assist children with developmental problems. My nephew went through the program from around one-and-a-half through to age four, and it changed his life and the lives of our immediate family.

    My nephew cried all the time as a baby. I'm not talking normal baby fussing or crabby baby fussing, or even sick baby fussing, I'm talking full-on, red-in-the-face, top of his lungs screaming until he lost his voice. Constantly. My sister had to carry him at all times, as he would totally flip out if he was put down for an instant. He wouldn't consent to let anyone else hold him. She had to wear him on her back in a sling sticking out of the shower curtain while she showered. She was, essentially, a marsupial for a year. Bathing him was difficult, as water seemed to cause him physical pain. Even in a warm bath on a warm day his lips and nails would turn blue, his fingers and toes would turn icy, and his teeth would chatter. But the worst was what we called his "baby OCD" -- he'd twist his hair until it fell out, leaving round sores on his soft little scalp, and chew on his fingers until they bled. This behavior was very upsetting to watch, because it obviously simultaneously pained and comforted him, and we all felt at a loss as to how to help him. We really couldn't take him anywhere, as his behavior elicited complaints and sometimes insults from strangers.

    On one outing, however, a woman approached my sister and said that she thought my nephew might have Sensory Integrative Dysfunction, and that my sister should contact Early Intervention. The EI people evaluated and diagnosed him with sensory issues, and enrolled him in a program in which he was exposed to the stuff that bothered him and taught to cope with it. They also trained us to help him. It was extremely cool. We learned, for example, that he cried when he wasn't being carried because he was experiencing severe vertigo, and by holding him tightly and spinning him in the air we could "reset" his brain. He was very sensitive to sounds, so we bought him a hat and earmuffs, and were able to take him to restaurants. If he became overwhelmed, we could brush his arms and the soles of his feet with those soft, plastic brushes surgeons use to wash their hands, and it would instantly calm him. A lot of stuff we learned to do with him was really fun, like swinging him in a blanket or squishing him between cushions, and he enjoyed his EI therapy and considered it play.

    The change in him was immediate and remarkable -- in just a few weeks he went from being that kid you see screaming and beating his fists on the floor (when you turn to your friend and say "no kid of mine would ever...") to being an adorable little laughing guy who yelled "HUGS!" when you walked into the room, and smothered you in love. With his sensory distractions removed, he was able to learn songs and poems, and showed a natural talent for sports and skating (he began skating on his own -- that is, without a cone, not without instruction! -- at about two, and now competes professionally at the national level). He's now nine, achieves perfect marks in every class, and is enrolled in his school's Gifted & Talented program. He plays soccer, hockey, and baseball, and is an enthusiastic skateboarder. He just enrolled in guitar lessons, and is forming a band with his sister and friends. Most importantly, he's the most decent, pleasant kid you could ever hope to meet. He actually enjoys hanging out with us old folks, but is also one of the most popular kids in his class. His teachers say he's a joy, and they wish they had an entire class like him. They say that he brings peace to the playground, because he's friends with both the bullies and the picked-on kids, and negotiates between them. He never complains or whines or asks for presents or demands anything, and he still gives and receives hugs freely, even in front of his peers. People who meet him marvel at what a great little dude he is, and always end saying darkly, "well, we'll see how long THAT lasts." But they've been saying it for years, and he just keeps getting better. I think he might even turn into that rare breed of non-hideous teenager. All signs point to "yes."

    I've heard many, many times in many, many forums and articles and what-have-you that Sensory Integrative Dysfunction is a myth, that it's a product of an overly concerned culture, that the symptoms are normal childhood behavior that should be disciplined, not indulged, and so on, and I have no scientific rebuttal to these claims. However, having witnessed my nephew's remarkable transformation firsthand, I can attest to the success of his treatment, and I hope that other kids like him have access to the same resources. When we first sat down with the therapist she explained that SI is a product of strange "wiring" in the brain, and if caught early enough, that wiring could be reset. She likened it to that experiment we all enjoyed as kids when you grab a cold pipe and a warm pipe at the same time, and your brain tells you you're being burned. In my nephew's case, this sort of informational misfire was more widespread and had greater physical and psychological manifestations. And as intensive as the Intervention program was, it was no doubt less expensive in the long run than years of special ed classes, followed by therapy for emotional problems incurred through years of frustration, followed by a stint in juvenile detention, followed by jail, followed by unemployment, and so on. I think it's possible that there are fewer bad kids and brats than we'd previously thought, and more kids that need a kind of help we adults aren't trained to give. And surely that's a good thing, because all we have to do is learn. And if the kids can learn to think and react differently, than so can we, right?

    posted by : Auntie in Boston on 7/3/2008 at 2:46 PM Flag For Abuse

  14. Anyone who thinks that SPD is a sham diagnosis applied to kids who just have quirky personalities, please, go read my blog.

    My son starved himself right off the growth chart not eating because of his SPD. I very nearly had to put him on a feeding tube. I took him to see a veritable parade of pediatric allergists, endocrinologists, nutritionists, gastroenterologists, etc for months, and all of them considered him a medical mystery. I finally met an occupational therapist who was able to diagnose him and help him.

    For some kids, the symptoms of SPD lead to tangible physical problems.

    posted by : Jaelithe on 7/23/2008 at 3:41 AM Flag For Abuse

  15. What is your blog?

    posted by : not psychic on 7/23/2008 at 11:36 AM Flag For Abuse

  16. MY DAUGHTHER IS 9YOA AND HAS BEEN HAVING PROBLEMS AT SCHOOL WITH ANGER MANAGEMENT. SHE HAS HAD THIS ISSUE ALL ALONG BUT WE THOUGHT WE HAD HANDLED THE PROBLEM IN HER PREVIOUS GRADES (SHE IS NOW IN THE 4TH) AND TODAY WE WERE INFORMED BY HER SCHOOL THAT IF WE DONT GET THE ANGER UNDER CONTROL THAT THEY MAY HAVE TO ASK HER TO LEAVE. SHE IS IN A PRIVATE SCHOOL AND THEY DONT HAVE THE ABILITY TO HANDLE CHILDREN WITH SPECIAL NEEDS. SO OFF TO THE DOCTOR WE WENT AND AFTER TELLING HER PEDIATRICIAN ABOUT THE PROBLEM WE WERE INFORMED THAT SHE HAS POSSIBLY GOT SENSORY INTEGRATON DYSFUNCTION AND THEY ARE MAKING AN APT WITH A OCCUPATIONAL THEREAPIST SOMETIME NEXT WEEK. I AM SCARED TO DEATH AND HOPE THIS IS THE RIGHT APPROACH TO TAKE

    posted by : SID9YOA on 8/26/2008 at 9:07 PM Flag For Abuse


   
  
 
 
   


Click here to login and post feedback using your login name or
Post feedback anonymously using this alias :


New This Week


What's New on Babble

Daily Poll

Have you started your holiday shopping?