feedback for "A Touchy Subject"

  1. Excellent topic and great coverage, Ms. Hamilton!!  I admire your honesty and great advice.

    -Rachael

    posted by : CrankMama on 3/12/2007 at 2:30 PM Flag For Abuse

  2. loved this article!  made me guffaw out loud.  i was one of those beet red youngsters, i'm afraid.  i was young, innocent, but very horny.  i'm mortified to think of it now, but i was rubbing up and down desks during school, Hebrew school as well...oy. my parents were even called in to try and remedy the problem.  I just remember them saying to me "everyone does it" and not really understanding what that meant.  my daughter is 3 and i see her touching herself and for some reason, it doesn't bother me at all. i think i've used up all my embarassment on myself! thanks for a great piece!

    posted by : daniella on 3/13/2007 at 7:35 PM Flag For Abuse

  3. Very refreshing. I had not read anything like this before and had sometimes wondered about the foggy memories of my own behavior as a child. I guess I was normal after all. Thank you for that.

    posted by : Hiker1956 on 3/2/2008 at 2:04 AM Flag For Abuse

  4. Three of the four times I was spanked as a child were when my mother caught me masturbating. This is not including the times when she yelled and shouted at me, or otherwise disciplined me severely. I was probably around seven before I became much more cagey about it, waiting until she'd left to run errands, or finding an isolated corner of the house with a chair. (I should add that my mother's approach to sex education was pretty inconsistent. Some of the things she taught me, especially the emphasis on being assertive even in situations where - as a woman, I might be expected to be compliant - were sincerely progressive; at other times she would have made even our nutty abstinence-oriented national education program seem downright liberal by comparison.)

    The result is that while I have a playful, varied, and pretty awesome sex life with my boyfriend of many years, I still find it difficult to masturbate. My years in high school, before I met my boyfriend, were pretty promiscuous; like most teenagers I desperately sought release for the sexual tension roiling inside me, but masturbation seemed like a more furtive, nastier option, more fraught with looming disapproval and negative consequence than a clean roll in the hay with one of my comrades. My mother probably would not appreciate the irony in that.

    In summary, I am utterly delighted and relieved to read an article that not only addresses this issue in a positive and sensitive light, but also indicates that public perception of the issue seems to be lightening as well.

    posted by : anonymous for a reason on 7/16/2008 at 5:22 AM Flag For Abuse

  5. Thank you so much for posting this article! My daughter is an avid "self explorer" and we are in the process of trying to teach her that it should only be done at home in private. I like your tip about referring to it as "private time", my husband and I were struggling to come up with a name for it:) She is starting preschool next month, and I'm torn as to whether or not I should mention it to her teacher. I'm sure they see it all the time, yet I'm still embarrassed to discuss it. I think I just need to get over it and let them know up front so that they can deal with it if she tries to do it there. Thanks again, your article made me giggle and I am glad I'm not the only one dealing with this!

    posted by : toddler mom on 7/21/2008 at 5:41 PM Flag For Abuse

  6. I'm glad I discovered this article. Not only did it make me laugh real good, but it answered a lot of questions about a terribly taboo subject. It truly is appropriately titled "A Touchy Subject" not just because it involves touching, but because there are so many viewpoints out there. I'm glad this article had a positive side to it.

    Childhood masturbation is definitely very normal and common. Many babies and toddlers will just happen to discover it on their own by accident, while many other children may not discover it until puberty. I was one of those children myself that Nancy Hamilton so colorfully described as "a common source of stress and concern among parents — who, like me, want their children to grow up to be socially and sexually well adjusted people -- the kind of well adjusted people who later in life have normal, healthy sexual relationships and who, as children, do not straddle the corner of the coffee table, rocking back and forth until their faces turn beet red during Mommy and Daddy's dinner party." I straddled many table and chair legs among other things as a toddler and I wouldn't stop till I was hot and sweaty. Eventually, I started humping pillows, blankets, teddy bears, towels, and other things. And shortly after that, I started humping my hands quite regularly.

    As a toddler, my parents just ignored it. When I was three and could start to understand things better, my mom brought up the subject with me. She said that I may have discovered certain "special parts" of my body that may feel good to touch and / or rub. I asked, "Which parts?" She said that she can't tell me just yet until I'm older but that most of them would be located between my belly button and my knees. Then she said that it's okay if I play with them now and then but that it's important for me to only do it in my bedroom or in the bathroom when I am truly by myself. She said that people wear clothes so that other people cannot see these "special parts" and that nobody should touch these "special parts" that our clothes cover up when other people are around.

    That was all I needed to know and it was enough for me to understand. I knew what she meant by "Special parts" and I was old enough to understand public and private behavior. Basically, through all that she explained to me, she was telling me that my straddling of furniture, my humping of pillows, my humping of hands, and anything else that I was doing with my "special parts" were inappropriate for others to see me do. But she said it was fun, and that I can keep doing it if I want, with the only restriction being that nobody else should ever see me do it. I felt good knowing that I wasn't doing anything bad, and I felt better knowing that I wouldn't be embarrassing myself and / or others anymore because I'd only do it in secret from that moment on.

    When a child is too young to understand, you may have to wait a bit and endure some awkward and embarrassing moments until you can explain to them when it's appropriate and when it isn't. Once your child is old enough to understand, there shouldn't be anymore awkward or embarrassing situations. And you don't have to give out a lot of information. My mom never told me what the word "masturbation" or "orgasm" or "humping" meant when I was that little, and she was wise not to. But using the terms, "Special parts", or "private parts" were enough to explain to me about private and private behavior.

    posted by : Another one of those beet red ch on 8/18/2008 at 7:56 AM Flag For Abuse

  7. my 4-month-old son recently started to grab his balls, and now i know why!!! he must be the next Einstein i guess!!!
    thanks for the article! it all is so true!!! i remember at the age of 3 I was a big fan of 'private times' myself..

    posted by : selftoucheress on 9/12/2008 at 6:07 AM Flag For Abuse

  8. One evening when our daughter was only ten months, we heard some rocking sounds coming from her crib. When we checked in on her, she was lying down on top of her hands and her waste kept rocking up and down. After a few minutes her face got all red, and she felt hot and sweaty. Then she'd slowly move her hands away and go back to sleep. We were initially shocked when we first saw her do this, but got used to her doing it every night. She is now two and a half years old, and does her rocking thing every night and afternoon at bedtime before going to sleep and she appears to have orgasms. Every night before she goes to sleep she spends some time doing this. I noticed when she was younger when she first started she'd stop after five minutes. Now it takes her ten to fifteen minutes before she has an orgasm and stops. And then sometimes, after she stops for a bit, she will resume for another ten or fifteen minutes if she hasn't fallen asleep yet. Once in a while, she may do it upon waking up in the morning as well. My concern is that even though she doesn't do it anywhere else other than her bed, is she addicted to it? Will she always have to do it before she can sleep? Can she fall asleep without rocking over her hands with her waste?

    posted by : jessica7 on 9/15/2008 at 12:46 AM Flag For Abuse

  9. We used to have a dog in our home and often he frequently humped the floor. We were told by the vet that this is quite normal for many household dogs including other pets, and that we shouldn't be too concerned or worried.

    Well, I'm worried now, because a couple of years ago, our two year old daughter started imitating the dog once when the dog was masturbating. She got onto the floor next to the dog and started sliding and rocking her stomach and waste areas back and forth rapidly on the ground. Sometimes her hips would go around in circles on the floor, and her legs would be kicking or swinging in the air or floor. Basically the whole front part of her body would rock or wiggle on the floor.

    The first time she did it, I was surprised but thought she would tire of the activity. But she quickly started just doing this at random times throughout every day, often when she would see the dog doing it. We got rid of the dog, hoping she would forget and stop masturbating, but that didn't really help. Now she's started placing soft objects, or her hands between her legs and really giving it. And once she starts, we cannot distract her until she finishes which is usually five to ten minutes later. Once she is finished, her breathing is a bit loud, her face is red, and she's all sweaty. Then she calms down and says that it was fun.

    She's never done this outside of our house (thank goodness), and she never takes her clothing off to do it either (thank goodness), but it's something she just randomly gets onto the floor, bed, or couch to do. Sometimes, she won't do it for a week, other times she might do it five times a day.

    We try to ignore this activity, because she only does it at home, but sometimes even at home it's awkward for us and not appropriate for her to do, especially if we have guests over. When she talks about how much fun it is after, I try to tell her that it's okay to have that fun sometimes, but that she should go to her room or to some other place where people aren't around to see her. But she doesn't understand that concept, she asks, "Why can't people see me, is it bad?" And all I can tell her is that it's not bad just not appropriate in front of others. And then she gets confused and doesn't understand why she can't do it whenever and where ever she wants. It seems like something she does when she is bored, like during commercials during a children's tv show, or when an adult visitor comes over to visit with me and her dad and there's nothing for her to do.

    Last week, I took her to one of my friends. We had coffee one afternoon at her place. But she got bored and while the television was on with a movie to keep her occupied in the living room while we visited in the kitchen, she started masturbating at her house on her floor. And my friend who saw her doing it, told me and was all surprised that I let her keep doing it. I told her that she does it frequently and won't be distracted until she finishes and that we are trying to get her to be more discreet, and only do it in her bedroom or when she's alone. She said that she isn't alone over here. I told her that she sort of is because we're in the kitchen and she's the only one in the living room and even though the room's are close together and we can see her, she considers herself alone. I reminded her that she's only four, doesn't know what she's doing, and that she'll know better when she gets a bit older.

    At this point in the conversation, we could clearly notice my daughter getting louder and really getting into it. My friend says that there's no way my daughter would be doing this unless she was abused or something. And she's very adamant that I talk with her and try to figure out how she was abused. She says somebody must have taught her to do this. I'm glad she's not pointing fingers at me, she says I'm a good parent, but she's adamant that someone else probably did something to her when I may not have been around. But I know that's not true, it was our dog that taught her if anything. Nobody abused her, and she reprimanded me for not trying to sort all of this out. I told her about our dog, but she thinks something happened to her prior to that, and it wasn't only the dog.

    I'm worried that others may think we're abusing her now, and I don't know what to tell my friend next time I talk to her. I know the truth, but she doesn't believe it. And what if other people who have seen her do this who may not have said anything to us in the past think we're being bad parents? What if others think the same way as my friend did?

    And what if my daughter starts doing it in school or something when she gets to kindergarten. I'm sure she will learn by then that it's not appropriate, but what if she doesn't?

    I don't know how true this is, but I've heard of rumors about young children openly masturbating in day care, or inside a church sunday school class, and then getting taken away from their parents right aways because they get accused of molesting their children. I don't want that to happen to me. And I guess with my friend confronting me about this, I'm really worried now because my daughter's never been abused.

    Has anybody here ever had to worry about this, and get worried to that extent?

    posted by : Really worried and concerned on 11/19/2008 at 2:25 AM Flag For Abuse

  10. Dear Really worried and concerned

    I think that child-hood masturbation is only one among many other signs of a case of child abuse. Perhaps this is what your friend heard about. So I doubt that your child can be taken away from you purely on the basis of her masturbating. If you have doubts about this, perhaps talk to your paediatrician about the masturbation.

    posted by : RE Really worried and concerned on 12/5/2008 at 8:01 AM Flag For Abuse


   
  
 
 
   


Click here to login and post feedback using your login name or
Post feedback anonymously using this alias :


New This Week


What's New on Babble

Daily Poll

Are you hitting the stores on Black Friday?