Let Your Baby Sleep Outside?
Surprising parenting wisdom from Scandinavia
A few weeks ago, I watched the hit documentary Babies and, like many other moms, I’ve spent many a moment since re-evaluating my parenting style and wondering why I went into such a panic last summer when my now 16-month-old son, Oliver, happily devoured a healthy portion of goose droppings at the park.
If Namibian Ponijao’s mom was so cool about her baby girl sticking string in her mouth and teething on rocks, and Mongolian Bayar’s mom didn’t mind a rooster hopping around her baby’s head, who was I to keep my son from educational encounters with nature?
Exposure to other cultures’ parenting methods can be humbling, funny, and, at times, even infuriating. But whatever the case, at their best, cross-cultural encounters tend to be quite enlightening.
And enlightenment was exactly what I got when I spent last summer in Copenhagen, in my husband’s native Denmark.
We’d lived there for three years before we were parents. So I knew that I could expect to hear that no kid’s life is complete without a daily dose of dark, chewy rye bread (how do toothless Danish kids eat that stuff?). But that was just the tip of the iceberg; there was so much else I didn’t know about parenting, Viking-style. And although during my three baby-free years in Copenhagen, most culture clashes had left me pretty frustrated, the encounters with new parenting styles had just the opposite effect.
I’d always marveled at how totally relaxed Copenhagen parents are. The kids go romping through the streets, crawling into shops, picking up choking hazards, running toward stairs – and the moms – usually tall, blonde, beautiful, and lacking any outward signs of sleep deprivation, don’t bat an eye.
They don’t raise their voices, don’t hover, and generally make parenting look like a day on the best beach on earth. (The one year of paid maternity leave and job security might have something to do with it.) I’ve also honestly never seen a Danish kid have a meltdown – ever. It’s uncanny.
My good Danish friend Nathalie embodies the mystery that is the Danish mother. Her son was just a month old when we visited her in her sun-filled, modern flat – as impeccably neat and style-savvy as ever. She looked exactly the same as I remembered her pre-baby and was sporting a stylish top (“What, this old thing?) that I would have saved for a rare Manhattan night out.
As we later strolled through the city with our Bugaboos, she shared her concerns about hers. She’d taken a leap from the Danish norm with the Cameleon. It’s a far cry from the portable, bed-like prams that Danish kids use throughout infancy and toddlerhood – really until they just won’t fit. She was afraid to convert her bassinet to the toddler seat too early. “It’s really important that babies sleep flat on their backs,” she informed me. “Doesn’t Oliver get uncomfortable sleeping sort of:folded like that?”
It hit me that for a Danish mom, flat-back sleeping is considered nearly as important as empty-crib sleeping is for us Americans (How many times have we heard that our crib should be devoid of anything other than baby? God forbid the bumpers detach themselves and fall on him, the toys stick in his nasal passages, or the books come alive and attack!).
But Danish kids sleep under down comforters called dunes from the time they’re born, and dunes are just what they sound like: mini mountains with no living creature in sight. “How does Elliot breathe under there, Nats?” I wanted to ask. There have been times in the subway in New York when I’ve seen foreigners’ kids covered up in much the same way – nose submerged – and had to fight the urge to casually lean over and pull the blankets down. But lo and behold, the kids survive.
For Danes, the dunes are a matter of necessity because their kids nap outside year-round. If the family doesn’t have a yard or a balcony, the babies might nap in the courtyard while moms check on them occasionally from their fifth-story windows as they bring their minimalist houses to the impossible levels of perfection Oprah featured in her Copenhagen segment.
“Doesn’t Oliver sleep outside?” someone would ask on a bizarrely regular basis, as if the habit were as essential as regular diaper changes. Yeah, of course he does! We roll him right out onto Broadway and ask the guy selling fake Fendis on the corner to keep an eye on him while we run up to fill our slow cooker. And when I go out shopping and he falls asleep, I park him outside the store and run in for a few odds and ends. Sure.
But if I’d said it, they would have believed me. Because even in this cosmopolitan Scandinavian capital with its population of one million and regular flow of tourists, most Danish moms feel totally at ease leaving their sleeping treasures in their prams as they run into boutiques to do what Danish moms, in my opinion, do best: buy whatever it takes to look so gorgeous you’d never guess that pram belonged to them.
I spent four to six hours a day walking through Copenhagen with Oliver for three months straight. Once I was out on the town, the thought of hauling him and all my baggage up five flights of stairs made me woozy. So I’d stroll, cursing the geniuses who’d placed a good 75% of the cool shops about five to ten steps below ground level.
I didn’t have the resolve to bump my overloaded stroller down the stairs. Nor was I brave enough to leave Oliver outside. Even if the shop had giant windows, the thought of exposing him to the imaginary goons who could, at any moment, decide to abduct him unnerved me.
But in the Danish capital, the only hot commodities that ever really get stolen apparently are bikes. Babies? Never. Which is exactly what that Danish mom was thinking in 1999 when she left her sleeping 14-month-old daughter in her stroller outside a restaurant in Manhattan’s East Village and popped in for a drink – and then got arrested.
I think of that mom often as I stroll through our New York City neighborhood, wondering what she thought of our American ways. Did she balk at the fences and gates that define our – and our children’s – boundaries? In Denmark, where people don’t typically sue for their own mistakes, safety barriers are few and far between. Did she wonder why American babies couldn’t eat strawberries while hers devoured berry puree with gusto? Most Danes just laughed when I mentioned the strawberry threat.
I’ll never know, but it doesn’t matter. Having had my own immersion in Danish parenting, I now have a little voice inside my head that tells me to calm down and let Oliver explore his world. I’ve bought him a dune comforter and put toys back in his crib. I’ve stopped worrying if he drinks from three strangers’ cups at the playground. As for that weird, dark rye bread – well, it turns out it’s his favorite kind.






Thanks for the great article.
From a mother in Norway; yes, this is good, safe and normal in Scandinavia. My babyboy sleep outside all winter, until -10 degrees, and he sleeps for 3 hours stait, loving it. Everyone who has a front/backdeck or a balcony should try it. But make sure that the baby doesen’t freece, me little boy has 3 layers of wool strait on his body and sleeps in the dune:)
It was fun reading about “myself” from another mom’s point of wiew!!
This was really interesting. It takes me back to the time I was interviewing babysitters (18 years ago, in upstate New York) and met a European mom whose baby was asleep outside on her deck (in January). I scratched her off the list and got out of there pretty quickly. Only later did I feel some curiosity about the practice. Today, I would probably try it (at least when we didn’t have company!haha)
The old Dr. Spock–post-WWII–recommended putting babies to sleep outside for “at least” two to three hours a day. I wonder when the practice died out in this country?
My dad was stationed in Germany when I was born. I was a December baby and they left me outside to sleep for hours at a time as well.
where can i buy one of these dunes??? sounds wonderful!
This is a very curious tradition to me. Do adults sleep outside daily also? What are the benefits of sleeping outside?
To Kari:
The fresh air is the biggest benefit, the babies sleep so mutch better. It’s really important to keep the baby safe from a windy place, if not they can catch a bad cold.
To babyboyblue:
On http://www.voksi.com you can by the original dunes.
Thanks so much for the great feedback! I’ve been placing “dune” orders from family in Scandinavia, but it looks like Pottery Barn Kids has “European down” blankets. The Danish ones we have are pretty great and come with fluffy down pillows our son loves almost as much as his rye bread. As for the benefits: I’ve heard sleeping in the cold helps kids fight of illnesses but haven’t yet found scientific proof
. It’s kind of like the Russian tradition of jumping into ice-cold water in the winter – that crowd can apparently never “catch a cold.” I don’t think Nordic adults sleep outside daily simply because it’s tough to find the place and time, but try taking a nap in a hammock sometime if you can and I bet you’ll get the best rest you’ve had in a while.
Now, if you could only find a European-style pram in the US to keep on your deck or out in the yard…
So let’s talk about SIDS. SIDS has been correlated with babies who are dressed to warmly. Really, even though correlation does not equal causation, it’s such a strong link some would imply it as factual. I find it very interesting that Danes are letting their children sleep outside, I think this is actually preventing SIDS. Yes, the infants are covered under a lot of blankets, but it may just be a tad nippy in there! However, if you think that sleeping in a crib is equal to sleeping in negative 10 weather, I would still be cautious.
Wonderful article. I thought it was fascinating. Thank you for writing it!
Wonderful piece. Removing the lens of our culture now and then can be revelatory. I still can’t believe the Danes leave their kids outside of shops … amazing. Our world keeps getting safer and we keep thinking it’s getting more dangerous.
So true about the benefits of exposure to other methods! I was so surprised when we moved back to the US when I was 7 months pregnant and my new American OB gave me a list of “absolutely, no ways.” I’d been eating deli meat, loads of smoked salmon (impossible to avoid in Scandinavia!), tuna sandwiches (my Danish GP had green-lighted them)…and it turned out I was committing all sorts of pregnancy faux-pas. I still can’t figure out who’s right but knowing that kids in Denmark are happy and healthy (and mine turned out just fine) is reassuring.
I was a November baby and my mom used to put me outside in my pram for my naps (we live in Canada). Now my mom is also French-Canadian so she had more ‘Europeean’ type practices than most Canadians in general. I would have done the same for my daughter but for the lack of a pram (they’re freakin’ expensive) and a non-windy place to tuck her in.
I grew up in Germany and my mom had us nap outside, under a huge down blanket, all the time as well
I didn’t do that with my son here in America.
Dagmar
Dagmar’s momsense
http://DagmarBleasdale.com
my baby sleeps outside here in Canada, on her grandmothers orders:) Great article, thanks so much.
Laura http://www.cubitsorganics.com/
So it’s an international phenomenon – and it seems the colder the weather, the more common outdoor baby sleeping! My mom just reminded me that I also napped outside on our balcony in Moscow as a newborn. Not sure it did much for my immunity, but maybe that’s just because Moscow air isn’t the freshest…
So interesting!
I often do not let American mothers know the truth about me – my 2 boys were babes when we lived in the far north of Canada (yes, the Arctic) and I left them to sleep on a regular basis outside. In -40 and colder weather. I actually planned my day around it. My boys are now 6 and 4, healthy and hearty. With rather high cold tolerance.
Both my boys napped in their stroller on the back deck or inside the shed. It was the only way they would fall asleep. I’m in Canada, and even when it was minus 20 Celsius, we would bundle them in 3 layers and put a plastic cover over the whole stroller. It felt like a dirty little secret. Glad to see that it’s common practice.
Very interesting article. I love to hear about other parenting styles and cultural practices. I feel like I have that care-free style of parenting you described. I think it’s good for my little girl to explore and get her hands on things. I let her put things in her mouth and play in the dirt. I think it’s important both for development and for her immunity. BUT sometimes I get some looks from friends and family that show disapproval for my methods – can make me feel like a not-so-great mom. I think here in the states we could use some insight into other cultures about parenting.
We could learn some from the Danes. I love seeing how other cultures do things.
Love this article on variety of parenting views
So evidently we need to let Piper sleep outside in the snowy air. I’m intrigued but quite wary. Anyone know anything about this practice?
As an Englishman abroad, it took me a long time to get used to the Nordic way of things, but in answer to the “…let Piper sleep outside…” comment and question?
Absolutely.
As long as the little one is protected against the cold, it is not a problem.
My Finnish-born daughter is 10½ – and she spent much of her first winter sleeping in the pram in the sub zero temperatures (F AND C…) of Helsinki – and she’s turned out okay.
A very good article, too.
Ok I just wan to know what a Dune Comforter looks like!
as a swedish mother of 4, whom herself slept outside in all weathers as an infant…I’m not so sure this is always wise. There are much research both in Scandinavia and abroad especially from spinal specialists. Maybe taking long walks in the fresh air with infant close in sling is safer for all
http://www.sleepywrap.com/index.php?page=stroller-baby-carrier
SO true!!
LoVe1
love 11
Love it! So funny! And raises a lot of crucial questions and concerns.
I saw “Babies” too, and noticed the seemingly long periods of time the Mongolian baby was left on his own, tethered to a piece of furniture. Definitely would be cause for calling Child and Family Services here. I kinda wished the movie had some occasional narration or occasional FAQs on the screen to provide more context.
I have a 5 month old who has slept with a blanket since day one, I could not stop reading this, loved it!
Good point. I hadn’t thuohgt about it quite that way.
I found this article incredibly interesting, as I had never thought about this idea before. I am more of a ‘lax’ mom and I find that I get disapproving looks when I let my little girl gnaw on a rock or some grass, or when she picks her binkie up off the floor after dropping it and sticks it right back in her mouth.
Thanks for the great article, I love reading about how other cultures handle parenting!
Being one of those tall, blond Danish mothers of a 2 year old and a 3 weeks old: Thank you for writing this article.
It was actually fun to read abut myself ha ha. It made me understand, that being a mom is the same thing nor matter the culture – but the habits and behavior varies a lot from country to country
It is exactly how you described it. All babies (up till 3-4 years of age) sleeps outside with a dyne (thats how it is spelled
) all year – down till -10 degrees (celcius). The kids love it, and it is soooo healthy. It strengthen the immune. Also I always leave the pram with my kids outside at shop. Being inside a warm shop full false air and lots of people – is both irritating for the baby, me and other customers. Much easier to leave them outside. In Denmark no kid has ever been stolen. You are right about the bikes though. All Danes has lost at least 1 bike before turing 18 years old.
I could go on commenting – but no need. You covered everything beautifully in your article, and to be honest: I am glad to have kids in Denmark, not having to worry about if the kid get stolen etc. At the same time I am absolutely certain, that Danish mothers can learn a lot from other mommies around the world as well. All cultures has something we all could learn from
Br
A Danish mom
This was both funny and interesting to read. Here in Scandinavia we always think of Americans as a bit hysterical, but yet – we see that your culture is much different from ours.
.
There has never been a baby-kidnapping in Norway. I’m 36 years old, and in my entire life here in Norway, we have experienced only two kidnappings. They both were 6-year old girls. So here we are relaxed. But it more often happens that a father kidnaps a child from the mother, and take the child back to their native country, if the parents are divorced.
In Norway we are only 5 million people. And in our capital Oslo, it lives about 500.000 people. Norway is the richest country in the world, compare to how many inhabitants we are, and with no depth at all. Our family social system are unbelievable! Free healthcare, 1 year of paid maternity leave, and trhee of those months are for dads only. Etc. ,etc., etc.
I have three children (a 4 months old baby daugther, an 11 years old son, and a 15 years old son, and I have no doubt about letting my baby sleep on the balcony. Even though I myself wouldn’t leave my baby outside a shopping center or a cafe, that would stress me and it’s so easy to bring them in. And alone in the car ? No way ! Norwegian parents often can’t see where our kids are when they are outdoors playing. And thats ok, we are sure they are fine. Let that two year old run up that little mountain, if it gives him so much joy. Let them play without going bananas, even though they might eat a little sand or fall of the swing, or the slide is far too long and heaten up by the sun. Bruises and cuts and a broken leg… Well, that hurts for both the child and a parent’s heart – but it is part of growing up and learn to manage balance, running, jumping, etc. They go to school, even in the traffic and in the dark, and no parents are following them. But of course we have rules and restrictions for our children too, to keep them safe and to help them growing up to be decent, hardworking and happy citizens, with a good self esteem and well developed social skills. Norwegians encourage our children to spend a lot of time outdoors in the nature, and get lot of exercise and fun.
We are a lot more concerned about our teenagers. Because it feels difficult to grow up, and it’s so much that they want to try out… Alcohol, tobacco, sex, even maybe drugs… Our teenagers stress us up a lot more than our babies and small children do.
We are quite relaxed about other things as well. Most of us don’t lock our front doors unless we are sleeping or we are gone. I trust my neighbour will watch after my mail and flowers when our family go on vacations, even though I might not know her. We might not lock our cars when we take a quick visit to the store. To day we have sendt our son to a consert in Oslo, our capital, to see a huge consert outdoor, whith about 100.000 other teenagers. Almost all of his friends and the teenagers on his school where there as well. And he took the planned train back to our city, Moss, and was back on the time we had told him to – at midnight.
In Scandinavia we don’t sue for injuries we obviously must blaim ourself for. We hear unbelievable stories from you, about law suits. F.ex: a woman got burn on hot coffee, and she took Mc’Donald’s to court. A woman dried her cat in a microwave oven, the cat died, and she took the microwave company to court. And both women won in court !!!! Eeh… What’s up with that??? So here we might think that Americans are a bit hysterical… Even though we love your kindness and spirit. And that you are so service minded.
A huge thank you to you all, for reading this
Thank you for writing this. It is highly interesting reading, and I’m glad to see that not all Americans wants to live in a disabling paranoid society.
But one thing is left unsaid; the fact that it doesn’t matter if you are physically there or not.
In a typical Scandinavian opinion a child is not unattended if you are looking at the baby through a window or a glass door. And that is true! Think about it: The worst thing that would happen is that someone would steal the baby, right? But the truth is that if somebody wanted to take the baby, they would succeed regardless of you being physically there or not. They would knock you down from behind or even shoot you. (The crime rate in Scandinavia is ridiculously low, btw so they simply doesn’t understand the fear of getting killed in the streets)
So you being there doesn’t really prevent ANYTHING. You would spot everything else (such as bears or choking), and get outside in the right time. Giving that you DO watch from the inside, of course. And you should. In Scandinavia as well.
US laws states that you have to be right next to your child at all times when outside. But the truth is that it probably won’t prevent anything you couldn’t prevent by watching the child from inside your house. (If that made any sense.)
False safety is worth absolutely nothing! And being a parent is exhausting enough even without the constant fear of other peoples actions. Right now I have to choose between letting my children sleep comfortably in fresh air (and go to jail because of worried neighbors), or try for hours to getting them to nap inside and eventually give up.
Just walk with the stroller, you said? Right now I walk for FIVE hours straight every single day because both of my babies needs to sleep, and they simply can’t do it inside! I’m blessed with two feet, but my back is hurting from all the walking.
If I had only one small child, I would sit on a chair next to the stroller. I don’t care if it looks ridiculous, it’s that important to me. Sleep is the most important factor of a child’s brain development. Fresh air also prevents asthma.
Never leave the child unattended. I agree with that. Watching on the other side of the window is attending if you ask me.
Thanks a lot for reading all this, btw. I hope all of you paranoid neighbors think rationally before reporting “child neglect” to the Police.