Previous Post Next Post

Baby

Not shared with friends Share now

Baby bonding is hard for new dads when the breastfeeding mom gets all the infant attention. Babble has parenting advice for new fathers on child bonding and fatherhood.

My husbands depressed because the baby loves me more.

By Ceridwen Morris |

Isn’t it normal for a breastfed infant of three months to respond more to his mother than his father? Our son is a generally happy child. He has recently started smiling, laughing, and sharing flirtatious eye contact. However, it seems as though I’m on the receiving end of these happy moments more than his father. This has sent my husband into spirals of depression. He’s convinced that his son hates him, and more, that they will never forge a connection. Moreover, his despair is sometimes tinged with a mild anger, and he’s started to make hurtful comments about the ways in which I’m “forcing myself” onto our son, which he says is why I’m getting all the happy responses. These sorts of comments have started to make me feel guilty about the smiles and baby love that, until recently, thrilled me to no end. I know I’ve got no reason to feel this way, but can’t seem to shake it. Is this fatherly response a normal stage that he’ll grow out of? Is there any study out there I can point him to, to prove that our son’s behavior is normal? – M.

Dear M.,

It is normal for a nursing baby at this age to be mother-centric. It’s also normal for the father of a nursing baby at this age to feel left out and depressed. It’s not guaranteed to happen – everyone bonds at different times for different reasons – but there’s plenty to explain why it can.

Your three-month-old baby’s world revolves almost entirely around feeding. So he spends a huge amount of time physically connected to your body. There is a lot of research on the mom-baby bond, fed by the “bonding hormone” oxytocin, which is released during breastfeeding and close newborn contact. The connection is so close, some refer to the mother and baby at this point as not two separate people but as a symbiotic “mother-baby dyad.”

Lots of dads deal with jealousy around this issue. Whether it’s focused on the mom or the kid, the theme is usually the same: Dad’s left out in the cold. Your husband’s temptation to throw up his hands in defeat is understandable. But you are right to be concerned about how he’s handling it. He seems really anxious about being a good dad, and frustrated that he’s not able to make it happen.

The first few months of a baby’s life are sometimes referred to as the fourth trimester. If we interpret that literally, the pregnancy is JUST ending now. In a few months, solids will be introduced, which is, for many, the beginning of the weaning process. But breastfeeding doesn’t have to end in order for your husband to feel connected. In fact, it’s much better for everyone to think less about subtracting from your bond with the baby, and more about adding to your husband’s. Try to reassure him that he WILL develop his own relationship with his son, and that it will get easier in time, as your baby grows more interested in the world outside your arms.

Here are a few ideas that might help him to get more comfortable and confident:

* Build routines with dad into your baby’s day. Your husband really needs the room to find his own way of comforting and connecting with your son. This might mean you need to literally leave the room, or even the house, so you should try this when you know your son’s not hungry. It might take a while for them to get into a groove, so encourage your husband to keep trying (even if initial experiences are not all that gratifying). To ease any potential pressure, you may want to frame these sessions as a break for you rather than remedial bonding time for him.

* Reassure yourselves that babies’ – and later children’s – attention is adaptable, and will be more or less focused on one parent at any given time. You won’t really know this until you’ve gone through it, but for now you’ll have to believe that it’s true. During the early months of parenthood everything can seem so heightened and final: “This is who I am as a parent!” But it’s not! Your roles (and your baby) will change constantly in subtle and not so subtle ways. And when they do, you might actually experience some jealousy yourself: “He’s the one who makes the baby laugh hysterically, I’m just a meal ticket” is one common complaint.

* Lastly, it’s important to be able to talk openly and respectfully about your feelings. Though he may not be handling it all that gracefully, your husband’s accusations come from a place of genuine hurt. It might be up to you to let him know that while it’s okay (even expected) to feel sad about being left out, it’s not okay to imply that this is some kind of pathological ploy of yours. What’s going on might not be fun for him, but it’s normal and temporary. He may want to talk to some other fathers. There are bound to be at least a few in any group who can relate, and maybe help reassure him of the fleeting nature of this particular moment of paternal angst.

Have a question? Email beingpregnant@babble.com

About the Author

bcceridwenmorris

Ceridwen Morris, CCE, is a writer, childbirth educator and the co-author of From The Hips: A Comprehensive, Open-Minded, Uncensored, Totally Honest Guide to Pregnancy, Birth and Becoming a Parent.

Read More

You May Also Like

« Go back to Baby

Use a Facebook account to add a comment, subject to Facebook's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your Facebook name, profile photo and other personal information you make public on Facebook (e.g., school, work, current city, age) will appear with your comment. Comments, together with personal information accompanying them, may be used on Babble.com and other Babble media platforms. Learn More.

11 thoughts on “Baby bonding is hard for new dads when the breastfeeding mom gets all the infant attention. Babble has parenting advice for new fathers on child bonding and fatherhood.

  1. sam and astrids mom says:

    oh, this same thing happened with me and my hub. he even cried sometimes! with our second he sort of expected it, and so it wasn’t as bad, but it still bothered him. it gets better around seven months or so. you’ll see!

  2. Spartic says:

    I don’t know who the biggest baby is your son or your husband. Why are some men so ridiculous?

  3. mamasan says:

    my boyfriend did this too! not sure what his problem was, he should’ve been happy that our daughter preferred me…because when she started wanting him more, his time was not his own ever again! be careful what you wish for, I guess.

  4. Tetazdena says:

    “spirals of depression”? “convinced that his son hates him”? this guy obviously has much bigger psychological issues or the letter writer is seriously exaggerating.

  5. dvbebe says:

    why do we have assume the man has issues because he wants a connection with his son? especially what seems to be a first time father? I think PA hit it on the head…yes, his response isn’t perfect, but who is? a guy who’ll let the mother do everything and think nothing of it? my husband was heartbroken when our eight month old wanted nothing to do with him when he’d get home from work, and yes, he sometimes let his sadness turn to bitterness which would find its way to me. we worked through it as part of the process. no phycologist was necessary.

  6. casey1033 says:

    I think it’s completely normal for an infant to prefer mom, after all mom is the one who they’ve been around since conception. My boyfriend was scared of not being a good father, who isn’t… it took a bit for him to realize that simply being afraid meant he cared so therefore would be a good father. I know being a mom isn’t easy but men have a lot to deal with too. I don’t think men have any clear cut guide on what to do or how to be a father and they mostly aren’t socially or physically prepared for it. Our son is 9 months old and he lights up with the sight of his dad but when he’s tired, hungry, or just needs some affection he comes to me, I was the sole receiver of hugs and kisses until just last week. Does that bother his father? Sometimes but mostly he’s just really happy to see his son have a great time with a mother who loves them both. Hardly ever is one person right 100% and the other wrong 0%, there’s lots of gray area out there.

  7. gpgirl says:

    I think a big issue is that our generation’s fathers were not as involved with child raising. Don’t get me wrong, they worked hard to bring home money for the family, but nobody expected them to actually take care of a baby. (And a baby was not expected to show affection to both mom and dad.) Today’s dads are really breaking new ground. When things don’t go the way they expected, they have no real example to look up to. It can be very frustrating and confusing, and hard to understand that it is natural for a baby to prefer his mom at times.

  8. tcualum says:

    My son who was breastfed until 15 months preferred me when he was really young and now at almost 2 years he still totally loves me but he’s also a daddy’s boy. Your husband shouldn’t get discouraged and should keep trying because it will pass.

  9. Ali says:

    I dont think I would leave my helpless infant with a man who has angry tirades about not getting enough attention from the baby. What if the baby cries when left with him and he loses it? The man sounds like a baby himself and is not to be trusted.

  10. ebiemama says:

    this mom has two infants!  i am a mom who first baby preferred my husband.  i felt a twinge when the baby would show his preference but remembered that my husband and i are on the same team.  it’s not like our son preferred the mailman.  he’s five now and obviously loves us both equally. 

  11. auntie says:

    Perhaps the Mom can allow Dad to share in the feedings, using a pump to let Dad bottle feed. There’s nothing like a baby staring you in the eyes when you are feeding it, even when you’re the auntie! My friends did this with their son and both parents got to experience the doe-eyed baby bonding.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Previous Post Next Post