Our 20 Best Thanksgiving Pies

Apple cranberry pie

We make a lot of pie at the The Family Kitchen. Pies of all types are churning out of our ovens year-round. I compiled 20 of our most delicious recipes for your reading pleasure. They range from fruity to creamy to chocolatey to vegan. Have you ever thought about serving individual pies baked into mason jars? Why not? It would be so much fun! They are all totally amazing and easy for any home cook to make. You don’t need to have any special skills to make these, just the interest in making a truly delicious dessert pie for your guests. Have a happy Thanksgiving!

  • Blackberry Slab Pie 1 of 20
    Blackberry Slab Pie
    This simple recipe is a cinch to pull together and makes a delicious rustic dessert for any event.
    Make blackberry slab pie
  • Bananas Foster Cream Pie 2 of 20
    Bananas Foster Cream Pie
    This fluffy delicious pie is always a crowd pleaser and is much easier to make for a crowd than actual bananas foster!
    Make bananas foster cream pie
  • No-bake Blueberry Yogurt Pie 3 of 20
    No-bake Blueberry Yogurt Pie
    A healthier pie for the table, this terrific treat is low in calories but high in taste.
    Make no-bake blueberry yogurt pie
  • Butterscotch Brulee Pie 4 of 20
    Butterscotch Brulee Pie
    The perfect flavor for fall is showcased in this yummy pie that tastes like a butterscotch sundae.
    Make butterscotch brulee pie
  • Cherry Pie in a Jar 5 of 20
    Cherry Pie in a Jar
    Give cherry pie a fun twist by baking it up in mason jars as individual servings for your guests.
    Make cherry pie in a jar
  • Chocolate Cream Pie 6 of 20
    Chocolate Cream Pie
    All you need is this classic pie to please all of the chocolate lovers gathered at your table.
    Make chocolate cream pie
  • Impossible Coconut Pie 7 of 20
    Impossible Coconut Pie
    Coconut pie is a terrific change from classic apple — plus, you'll love how impossibly easy it is to make.
    Make impossible coconut pie
  • Jack-o-Lantern Apple Pie 8 of 20
    Jack-o-Lantern Apple Pie
    A classic apple pie is always welcome at Thanksgiving, and why not add the cute pumpkin face anyway?!
    Make apple pie
  • Lattice Top Blueberry Pie in a Jar 9 of 20
    Lattice Top Blueberry Pie in a Jar
    Never underestimate the popularity of pie in a jar, especially in classic blueberry flavor.
    Make blueberry pie ina jar
  • Mexican Chocolate Pecan Pie 10 of 20
    Mexican Chocolate Pecan Pie
    Pecan pie gets a chocolatey twist with the addition of hot spices and deep chocolate.
    Make mexican chocolate pie
  • Peach Pie in a Jar 11 of 20
    Peach Pie in a Jar
    Peach pie with vanilla ice cream is nearly as classic as it gets. Enjoy this sweet pie with whipped cream!
    Make peach pie in a jar
  • Eggnog Pie 12 of 20
    Eggnog Pie
    It is never too early for eggnog, especially when it is baked up in this creamy pie.
    Make eggnog pie
  • Pumpkin Pie Apple Crisp 13 of 20
    Pumpkin Pie Apple Crisp
    Pumpkin pie? Apple crisp? Why not have both at once?
    Make pumpkin pie apple crisp
  • Vegan Pumpkin Cream Pie 14 of 20
    Vegan Pumpkin Cream Pie
    This creamy pumpkin pie is a great alternative to the classic version and is vegan.
    Make pumpkin cream pie
  • Classic Pumpkin Pie 15 of 20
    Classic Pumpkin Pie
    Never underestimate the popularity of pumpkin pie from scratch. This is the perfect recipe!
    Make classic pumpkin pie
  • Pumpkin Ginger Pie 16 of 20
    Pumpkin Ginger Pie
    Give pumpkin pie a spicy twist with this sweet gingery version.
    Make pumpkin ginger pie
  • Rocky Road Pie 17 of 20
    Rocky Road Pie
    A break from tradition, this crunchy chocolate pie is bound to be a hit with anyone looking for a change.
    Make rocky road pie
  • Almost Tiramisu Cream Pie 18 of 20
    Almost Tiramisu Cream Pie
    This vegan whipped pie is a fabulous coffee, chocolate alternative to fruit pies and is tasty to boot!
    Make tiramisu cream pie
  • Apple Cranbery Pie 19 of 20
    Apple Cranbery Pie
    Classic with a twist, this apple pie sparkles with the addition of tart cranberries.
    Make apple cranberry pie
  • Apricot Crumble Pie 20 of 20
    Apricot Crumble Pie
    A cozy apricot crumble pie is so easy and delicious.
    Make apricot crumble pie

Photo: Julie VR

Holiday meal prep: 7 make-ahead meals for Thanksgiving, plus recipes!

Article Posted 4 years Ago
share this article
facebook twitter tumblr pinterest
See Comments
what do you think?
share this article
facebook twitter tumblr pinterest
See Comments
what do you think?
what do you think?
close comments
Subscribe to the
Welcome to
Sign Out
Follow us on