Babble Best: Forward-facing Car Seats

Our five favorite ways to chauffeur your toddler. by Katie Bayless

July 17, 2007

The summer driving season is well underway, with its four-dollar gallons of gas, rousing games of slug bug and endless choruses of "Are we there yet?" With my son's first birthday just around the corner, I've been in the market for a forward-facing car seat to replace the infant seat he's been in. There are two main options in the forward-facing market: convertible seats (can face backward for infants or forward for one-year-olds) or booster seats (can only face forward and will often last until your kid is out of a car seat).

To get some input, I called in the help of Nikki Studt, an investigator with the Santa Barbara Fire Department and a certified car seat safety installer. Nikki says that 90% of all car seats have three or more installation errors (yikes!). If you're installing yourself, be sure to read all the directions or find a (usually free) certified installer by contacting your local fire department or checking this listing. Nikki's recommendation for the best car seat? "Find the seat that fits your car and your child the best. A sound installation into your particular car and a secure fit of straps and harnesses on your individual child are essential for safe riding." — Katie Bayless



Recaro - Young Sport Child Seat - $249

The Recaro Young Sport booster seat has won my heart, even if it did empty my pocketbook. Some of the highlights: first-class side impact protection with deep side wings, EPS energy-absorbing foam in the head and shoulder padding, compliance with both U.S. and European vehicle safety standards, a number of luxe cushions that can be removed when your child no longer needs them, an easy-to-adjust five-point harness and a number of fashionable fabric combos to choose from. Usable with children from twenty to eighty pounds, my favorite feature is the adjustable headrest with narrow wings that provides superb protection and prevents that dreaded scrunched-neck-sleeping problem.

Forward-facing Car Seats : Runners-up

Safety First Cosco Alpha Omega Elite - $159

Whether rear or forward-facing, the Alpha Omega Elite convertible seat by Safety First is a swell ride. With swing-down armrests, EPS energy-absorbing foam, a detachable cup holder and an easy-adjust headrest, this car seat has all the padding and extras your little one could want and all the safety features you demand. (If you want an even cushier ride, check out the Eddie Bauer Deluxe 3-in-1, which is nearly identical, but with enhanced padding and a slightly higher price point.) Keep in mind that, while this seat works for kids five to one hundred pounds, Nikki pointed out that the five-point harness is only tested up to forty lbs. After that, it's meant to be used as a belt-positioning booster seat. Update: a safety recall has affected some Cosco and Safety First car seats. Click here to check which models have been recalled.

Sunshine Kids Radian80 - $280

For twins, triplets or smaller cars, check out the Radian80 convertible seat by Sunshine Kids. This is not only one of the narrowest seats on the market (fits three across in the back of most cars), but it also folds in half for easier hauling with the included carrying strap. Suitable from five to eighty pounds, this compact car seat includes side impact protection with EPS safety foam, a steel alloy frame and removable infant padding. Available in four color options, the hefty price tag gets you a seat that is big on quality and safety but small on size.

Britax Decathalon - $284

Britax has built a stellar reputation with their line of car seats, including the Decathalon, the Marathon ($269) and the ultra-lush Boulevard ($300). The differences between these seats are mainly in the plushness of the padding. I test-drove the Decathalon, which includes Britax's patented HUGS padding system, built-in seatbelt lock-offs, adjustable positions for the five-point harness and an ultra-soft washable cover. This seat covers kids from five to sixty-five pounds and has a unique tether system when facing backwards. It's hard to go wrong with any of the Britax carseats; they're popular for a reason.

Eddie Bauer Deluxe High Back Booster - $150

Although Consumer Reports did have that little mishap with their car seat testing a while back, they have since redone their recommendations and list the EB Deluxe High Back Booster as their top pick for booster seats. Recommended for children twenty-two to eighty pounds, this seat has less adjustability for crotch and shoulder straps, but does include a slide-out cup holder in the base and the extra padding that comes with the deluxe model. Update: a safety recall has affected some Eddie Bauer car seats. Click here to check which models have been recalled.

Planning a road trip? Check out Babble Best: Audiobooks.

Discuss this article   |   PRINT THIS ARTICLE  |   EMAIL TO A FRIEND  |     RATE THIS NOW!
+ DIGG  |   + STUMBLE  |     |   + MY YAHOO  |   + GOOGLE  |   RSS
 

About the Author

author bio Kate Bayless is a writer, reviewer, editor and mother of two. In addition to Babble, you can see her reviews at Mommies With Style and Mom's Favorite Stuff.  Visit her at katebayless.com.

New This Week