Swine Flu and Children
Everything you need to know about the vaccine, symptoms and treatment.
Swine Flu and Children
Everything you need to know about the vaccine, symptoms and treatment.
by Shelley Abreu
October 23, 2009

Swine flu season is upon us, and that raises a lot of questions. As this year’s health scare spreads, Babble is giving answers to all your questions about your kids and the H1N1 virus. Learn everything you need to know about the vaccine, signs to watch for, treatment and whether you’re worrying too much, or not enough. – Babble Editors
- So, are parents’ fears valid?
- Who are the vaccine opponents?
- Is the vaccine really safe?
- What about thimerosal?
- Who is most at risk?
- What’s the verdict?
- What to Do if Your Child Gets the Flu
- H1N1 by the Numbers
It’s the question every parent seems to be asking: Are you getting the H1N1 flu vaccine for your child? The CDC and FDA both claim that the vaccine is safe and effective, yet, according to several polls, more than one third of parents might decline to have their children vaccinated.
So, are parents’ fears valid?
Simply put, parents are concerned that the vaccine is more dangerous than the virus itself. The basis of those concerns stems back to the 1976 swine flu vaccine produced during that outbreak of H1N1. It was associated with a slightly increased risk of Guillain-Barre Syndrome (GBS), a disorder in which the body’s immune system damages its own nerve cells. In rare cases, it can cause death or permanent damage, although the majority of people do recover. In the United States, the chance of contracting GBS with or without receiving a vaccination is approximately 1 in 100,000. In 1976 the rate increased slightly to approximately 2 in 100,000 among those who received the swine flu vaccine. Scientists have never determined a definitive reason for the increased risk, but the CDC believes that advances in how vaccines are made today will very likely prevent an increased risk with the current H1N1 vaccine.
For parents who are still concerned about the potential risk of GBS, it may be helpful to consider that more children have already died since August 30th of this year from the swine flu than those who died from GBS during the vaccination period in 1976 (Approximately 500 people contracted GBS and twenty-five died).

4 Most Important Things Parents Should Know About Swine Flu
With the barrage of info out there, we enlisted the expertise of Dr. Richard Besser, senior health and medical editor at ABC News, to help sort it out. Here’s what you absolutely need to know about swine flu. – Andrea Zimmerman
1. Swine flu is preventable
Just like any other respiratory infections, encourage your kids to wash their hands and cover their cough. If your child is sick, keep them home from school.
2. Children are at a greater risk
The CDC reports that hospitalization rates for children are very high and 80 deaths have occurred so far–a higher number than what they tend to see over the entire flu season in a year.
3. Children with underlying medical conditions are at even greater risk. If your kid has a medical condition like asthma, cystic fibrosis, or cerebral palsy that makes it hard for them to breath, vaccinate them and talk to your doctor to draw out a treatment plan before your child gets sick.
4. Watch for danger signs. Take your child to the doctor if they exhibit any blue or grayness around the lips, which means they’re not getting enough oxygen, or if they have trouble breathing. Look for gasping or pulling at their chest; babies may have trouble nursing or sucking from a bottle.

Who are the vaccine opponents?
Many parents continue to worry about other safety aspects of the current H1N1 vaccine, in part because of the fast-tracked safety trials the vaccine underwent. A vocal minority of doctors against the vaccine have increased those fears. Dr. Mercola, publisher of a popular natural-health website, is the author of the article, “Do Not Let Your Child Get Flu Vaccine: 9 Reasons Why,” which is now circulating as an email. Yet much of the information contained in that piece is misleading. For instance, Dr. Mercola claims that the vaccines used in trials differ from the final version. But the FDA says this is emphatically untrue. They state, “The vaccines used in studies to determine dose and regimen are the same vaccines that were licensed.” He also argues that American children are over-vaccinated, suggests that the vaccine contains squalene (though it’s not used in the U.S. at all, and has a good safety record in Europe), and cites climbing autism rates as a reason not to vaccinate (though recent studies all disprove any connection).
Dr. Kent Holtorf, in an interview with Fox News back in September, disseminated similar mis-information when he called the vaccine “too big of a risk.” In his segment, he said the vaccine was “rushed to market” and also mistakenly said that it contains “high levels of adjuncts, including squalene” and that vaccines are “highly implicated in autism.”
Opponents like Dr. Larry Palevsky, a New York-based pediatrician and President and Co-Founder of the Pediatric Holistic Foundation, insist that the vaccine’s safety cannot be proven. He’s advising his patients to pass. “Having the authorities tell us it’s completely safe is in contradiction to how safety studies need to be done, and how data needs to be collected in order for us to conclude they are safe enough to administer,” says Dr. Palevsky.
Is the vaccine really safe?
The CDC disagrees with Dr. Palevsky. Abbigail Tumpey, a spokesperson for the Immunization Safety Office, indicates that vaccines are actually one of the most regulated kinds of medicine for safety. What’s more, the vaccine is made using the same tested and approved methods as the seasonal flu vaccine. Dr. Grace Lee, Assistant Professor of Population Medicine & Pediatrics at Children’s Hospital Boston and Harvard Medical School, is currently involved in the active surveillance of H1N1 and seasonal influenza vaccine safety. She explains, “Each year, the seasonal flu vaccines change to accommodate [different] strains of flu – meaning that the flu strains that circulate each season differ from the previous year. H1N1 is just like the seasonal flu vaccine, it’s just that the H1N1 vaccine will protect against the circulating H1N1 strain in the community.” While Dr. Lee acknowledges that, although rare, adverse reactions can occur with any vaccine, she says the benefits far outweigh the risks.
Concerns that dominate all vaccine programs have also made their way into the swine flu conversation. Anti-vaccine groups have postulated that flu vaccines aren’t very effective – another reason parents might skip the swine flu vaccine. While the CDC admits no vaccine is 100% effective, they also state that they’ve “seen a very good immunoresponse in adults and older children that was evident within eight to ten days after the vaccination was given.” The seasonal flu vaccine is considered two-thirds effective in young children, and the swine flu vaccine may yield better results since the vaccine is matched to the virus strain. (Note: children under ten will need two doses for the vaccine to be adequately effective).


The level of ignorance among otherwise intelligent and educated parents on this is staggering. To not vaccine your child against a virus that targets them is the height of stupidity and irresponsibility. They put their own children at increased risk and make it more likely that an outbreak will strike others. Thanks for helping to snuff out the misinformation out there.
If you’re trying to disprive “mis-information,” it would be helpful to readers if you cited the sources you used to refute those doctors’ statement.
I have been sifting through teetering piles of information on the H1N1
vaccine for months now. It is especially frustrating that doctors are posting
inaccurate information on websites. Clearly there is a lot of dogma around
vaccines these days, that I imagine would have been unthinkable during the time
of polio. (Maybe because the numbers of kids dying from vaccine-preventable
diseases is so historically low, there’s enough room to argue rather than line
up gratefully for a shot).
My son, now 4, was born at 25 weeks and still
has lung issues associated with his premature birth. When our community receives
the H1N1 vaccine, I will have him vaccinated. I wish I could opt out like I will
with his full term sister, but it’s not an option given his respiratory
status.
This is ONE of the MANY hard decisions where neither choice feels
100% great; oh, sounds a lot like parenthood.
Rachel
Growing children
at 6512 feet:
http://6512andgrowing.wordpress.com/
This subject (to vaccinate or not to vaccinate) has become tiresome, as it is nearly impossible to locate a vaccination in the city I live in. I am nine months pregnant and have a five year old son – I would love to vaccinate our entire family, but can’t find the shot anywhere. I am so over hearing people “debate” this non-issue – almost as much as I’m over seeing dire warnings about how pregnant women are dying of this flu. This information would be much more useful when there is actually a choice to be made and I have the option of walking into a clinic or pharmacy to be vaccinated. It seems to me that by the time the vaccine is readily available, most of us will have already been exposed. Very frustrating.
@6512: You will protect one child but not the other?
KG – I totally agree! Why is no one in the media talking about the fact that it seems like no doctors actually have this vaccine? We’re being beaten over the head ‘Vaccinate or die!’ and yet if we do decide to vaccinate we can’t because the vaccine is not available.
KG/onemum – this really is a big deal. Only in the last few days have I seen any media coverage at all about the low amount of vaccine available. In our area it is impossible to find. I understand that it takes a long time to make vaccine. (Can you imagine if there had been any shortcuts? Anti-vaccine groups would have a field day.) However, I think it was irresponsible to promise so much vaccine and not be able to deliver.I find it ironic that the anti-vaccine folks are screaming that these have been “untested” or “under-tested”, but the fact that it is following the same regulatory pathway as the seasonal flu shot is causing this shortage. Can I add I cringed when I saw the name of Dr. Mercola. This guy is a well-known quack, and very dangerous. One other thing is that this vaccine is coming at an optimal time for those who are against a government-run healthcare option. Types like Rush, Glenn Beck, Don Imus have been shouting against this vaccine because it is (according to them) another piece of “proof” that the government cannot be trusted.
Los Angeles County has redirected a lot of vaccine to free public clinics for uninsured at the expense of private practices. Unfortunately, this does make sense as uninsured may crowd emergency rooms; but at this rate so will insured. I managed to get the vaccine at my OB’s office because of pure luck: the shipment arrived an hour before my appointment. I am due to deliver my second child in 3 weeks: not a moment too soon for me.
KG is right. The media and medical community are putting everyone in a panic about H1N1 insisting we get the vaccine….then don’t provide the vaccine. Even worse they aren’t talking about the shortage, they’re just ignoring it. Here in NYC, it’s not just the H1N1 that’s not available it’s the plain old regular seasonal flu shot! I believe the same thing happened here that NoHo Mom describes for Los Angeles. Here in NYC, Pediatrician offices and doctors all over the city don’t have it and don’t know when they’re getting it. But we were able to get it at a drugstore located in a low income neighborhood that borders our own. I’m so glad I thought to go there when we learned our doctor on the Upper East Side didn’t have the flu vaccine in stock. As for whether to vaccinate or not, I understand fears about autism and GBS, but the idea it’s preferable for one’s child to be dead than to have autism – good lord, really?? That’s ultimately what people are saying and doing by not vaccinating. It’s ridiculous. Just because we’re not offered the perfect option to choose doesn’t mean we get to avoid making the choice.
Thank you for a great article — we need more pieces like this to counter the spread of misinformation and fear.
My two boys (4 years and 8 mos) are getting the H1N1 vaccine on Monday morning at the peds office. They are on the schedule, so I hope they still have the shot!
My daughter, age 7, will get it through the public schools. She has asthma, and the boys lungs aren’t great, either, so I’m happy for them all to get vaccinated. We get flu shots every year.
Thank you so much for this article- I have to dispel vaccine hysteria and misinformation in my office one by one, and I hope that articles like this one can help spread the word a little quicker.
By the way, for those looking for references – the CDC has pages of info on their website.
My two year old has asthma, so she is a good candidate for the vaccine, but she also has a severe egg allergy, so her pediatrician is recommending against it. This is a moot point, of course, since it’s not available here anyway, and probably won’t be for several months.
@Pedsdoc: Unfortunately, the same people that don’t “believe” in the efficacy of vaccinations also are highly suspect of the CDC. Simply laughable if it wasn’t so serious.
I’m glad most folks here plan to vaccinate. I share your frustration with the lack of vaccine, our son has his annual physical and I know his doc won’t have it here in Chicago.
mrb1, if you’re a Chicago resident, the city colleges are having H1N1 clinics. 3 of the 4 of us got ours on Saturday (the other son was too sick to get it; I’m pregnant, so my husband was able to get it too). Our doctor doesn’t have it either. I found the info by googlin “Chicago h1n1 vaccine.” Good luck!
@ChiLaura…thanks. Our son’s doctor actually had the nasal vaccine yesterday so he got it. He woke up this morning with a 99.4 temp and feeling lousy, which is to be expected with the administration of the live virus vaccine as the body mounts an immune response.
Far better 1 day of mild flu instead of 8 days of full blown misery for him (and us.)
Thanks for the info, though. May check out the city college option for myself.
I’m not anti-vaccine at all, but that doesn’t mean I’m going to get every vaccine that comes down the pike. People talk about weighing the risks and I agree with that. I’m weighing the risk of my child – who is not in daycare, doesn’t have asthma, or known underlying health conditions, etc – actually getting a fatal case of H1N1 against possible risks of the vaccine. It’s ridiculous that it’s become a ‘get it or die’ discussion.
It’s not just us “ignorant parents” opting out. Doctors and health care workers all over the country are opting out. Some are suggesting that NYC won’t be hit as hard as some places because we were so hard hit last year and more people have built an immunity. Maybe true, maybe not. We’re not all crazies yapping on links to autism.
Excellent point, my 2 cents.I have a breastfed six-month-old cared for at home and I’m really, really up in the air as to whether or not to get the vax because our risk of getting h1n1 is probably much lower than a six-year-old schoolkid eating a diet of Halloween candy and string cheese. If I were in that camp, I’d probably head straight for the ped’s office.Vaccines aren’t free of risk (and I don’t mean autism) and I’m slightly wary of something this new. I don’t think this makes me crazy or a bad parent.
Completely agree with my 2 cents and one more cent. There are many thoughtful, rational, informed people out there struggling with this decision. They are not ignorant or crazy. This is a new vaccine and I think it’s natural to have some concerns.
As a Canadian I find it interesting that part of what is in this article to “reassure” people about the vaccine is untrue of the vaccine available here. Our vaccine has the adjuvant squalene in it, and you can’t get the adjuvant- and thimerosol-free version unless you are pregnant. Up until last week pregnant women here had to decide whether to get the regular vaccine (with squalene and mercury) or wait for the one free of those ingredients which wasn’t yet available. They were told both were safe, that there were just more studies on pregnant women for the adjuvant-free vaccine. But then our government bought 200,000 doses of the adjuvant-free vaccine from Australia to make it available to pregnant women sooner than the ones on order from our provider would get here. Even thought the regular vaccine is perfectly safe for them. What are we supposed to think?
On the upside, they have now decided that because of the adjuvant (which makes the vaccine more effective), young children will only need a single half dose of the vaccine instead of the two doses they previously thought would be required. They decided this two weeks in to the delivery of the vaccine programs. If the vaccine had been fully tested prior to roll out, wouldn’t they have already known that? Not trying to be incendiary there – that just occurred to me.